Fidelity vs Public: Trading platforms compared
Fidelity and Public are two trading platforms options. The sections below line up cost, what you get, fees, speed, and who each one fits.
| Fidelity | Public | |
|---|---|---|
| Fees | $0 commissions for US stock & ETF trades | Earn rebates on your options trades, $0.06–$0.18 per stock or ETF contract based on monthly trading volume. |
Why compare them
When choosing a trading platform, it's essential to compare options. Fidelity and Public offer distinct advantages. Each caters to different investing styles and needs. Understanding these differences can help you make a better choice.
Fidelity is ideal for those focused on US stocks and ETFs. It has no account fees and offers commission-free trades. This means you can invest without worrying about extra costs eating into your returns. Additionally, Fidelity allows fractional shares starting at just $1. This feature makes it easier to invest in high-priced stocks without needing a large sum upfront.
On the other hand, Public appeals to a broader audience. It's designed for multi-asset investing, including stocks, bonds, crypto, and options. Public has no commissions on trades, which is a significant plus. However, it does have fees for options trades based on your monthly trading volume. This could be a consideration if you plan to trade options frequently.
Public also offers unique features like AI-driven investment strategies and customizable indices for direct indexing. These tools can help you tailor your investments to your specific goals. Furthermore, Public provides a competitive margin rate and attractive yields on cash and bond accounts.
Both platforms have their strengths. Fidelity is straightforward and cost-effective for traditional stock and ETF investing. Public, however, introduces more diverse investment opportunities and advanced features. Depending on your investment style and goals, one may suit you better than the other.
- Fidelity: Best for US stocks and ETFs
- No account fees and commission-free trades at Fidelity
- Fractional shares available at Fidelity starting at $1
- Public: Great for multi-asset investing
- No commissions on trades at Public
- Public offers AI-driven investment strategies
- Options trading fees at Public vary by volume
- Public provides a competitive margin rate
- Consider your investment style when choosing between them
Cost
When choosing a trading platform, understanding the cost structure is crucial. Both Fidelity and Public offer competitive pricing, but they cater to different investing needs. Fidelity stands out with its zero account fees and no commissions for US stock and ETF trades. This makes it an attractive option for investors focused on US stocks and ETFs. Additionally, Fidelity allows fractional shares starting at just $1, enabling investors to buy portions of expensive stocks without breaking the bank.
On the other hand, Public adopts a different approach. While it does not charge commissions on trades, it has a fee structure for options trading. Depending on the monthly trading volume, users can expect to pay between $0.06 and $0.18 per stock or ETF contract. This can add up, especially for active options traders. Public also offers a base margin rate of 5.15%, with the lowest rate being 4.20%. This is something to consider for those looking to leverage their investments.
In terms of cash management, Public provides a 3.30% APY on cash balances, which is quite competitive. It also offers a 6.44% yield on its Bond Account, appealing to those looking for fixed-income options. Furthermore, Public has a unique feature where it matches 1% of annual contributions for IRAs, adding an incentive for retirement savers. Overall, while Fidelity offers straightforward, commission-free trading, Public provides a broader range of investment options with some associated costs.
- Fidelity:
- - $0 account fees
- - $0 commissions for US stock & ETF trades
- - Fractional shares starting at $1
- Public:
- - No commissions on trades
- - $0.06–$0.18 per stock or ETF contract for options trading
- - 5.15% base margin rate (lowest 4.20%)
- - 3.30% APY on cash
- - 6.44% yield on Bond Account
- - 1% match on annual contributions for IRAs
What you get
Fidelity offers a straightforward approach to investing. You can open a brokerage account with no fees. This means no account maintenance charges. You can trade US stocks and ETFs without worrying about commissions. This is a significant advantage for frequent traders. Additionally, Fidelity allows fractional shares starting at just $1. This feature makes investing more accessible, especially for those who want to invest smaller amounts.
Public, on the other hand, provides a different experience. It operates as an investing app that supports multiple asset types. You can trade stocks, bonds, crypto, and options all in one place. There are no commissions on trades, which is appealing for cost-conscious investors. However, there are fees for options trades, which vary based on your trading volume. This could add up if you trade options frequently.
Both platforms have unique features. Fidelity focuses on simplicity and low-cost trading. Public incorporates AI-driven investment strategies, which can help users make informed decisions. This is particularly beneficial for those looking to leverage technology in their investing. Public also offers a competitive margin rate, starting at 5.15%, with the lowest rate being 4.20%. This can be attractive for investors who use margin.
In terms of rewards, Public stands out with a 3.30% APY on cash and a 6.44% yield on its Bond Account. Additionally, it offers a 1% match on annual contributions for IRAs. This can enhance your savings over time. Overall, both platforms cater to different types of investors, each with its own set of features and benefits.
- Fidelity: $0 account fees
- Fidelity: $0 commissions for US stock & ETF trades
- Fidelity: Fractional shares starting at $1
- Public: No commissions on trades
- Public: Access to stocks, bonds, crypto, and options
- Public: Earn rebates on options trades
- Public: 3.30% APY on cash
- Public: 6.44% yield on Bond Account
- Public: 1% match on annual contributions for IRAs
- Public: Low margin rates starting at 5.15%
Who each one fits
Fidelity is a solid choice for those focused on investing in US stocks and ETFs. It is ideal for beginners and seasoned investors alike. The absence of account fees and commission-free trades make it accessible. Investors can buy fractional shares starting at just $1, making it easy to diversify without a large upfront investment. This feature is particularly beneficial for those who want to start small or invest in higher-priced stocks without breaking the bank.
On the other hand, Public caters to a different audience. It’s best for those interested in multi-asset investing. This platform offers access to stocks, bonds, crypto, and options, which appeals to investors looking to diversify their portfolios across various asset classes. Public’s AI-driven investment strategies make it attractive for tech-savvy investors who appreciate innovative tools. The customizable indices for direct indexing also allow users to tailor their investments to their preferences.
Both platforms have their strengths. Fidelity is straightforward and cost-effective for traditional stock and ETF investors. Public, however, is geared toward those who want a broader investment strategy that includes options and cryptocurrencies. Investors who are new to options trading should consider the learning curve involved, as it may not be suitable for everyone. Ultimately, the choice between Fidelity and Public depends on individual investment goals and preferences.
- Fidelity is best for:
- - Investing in US stocks and ETFs
- - Beginners and seasoned investors looking for straightforward trading
- - Those who want to invest with no account fees or commissions
- - Individuals interested in fractional shares to diversify easily
- Public is best for:
- - Multi-asset investing including stocks, bonds, crypto, and options
- - Investors who appreciate AI-driven investment strategies
- - Those looking for customizable indices for direct indexing
- - Tech-savvy users who want innovative tools and features
What you need to qualify
When considering a trading platform, understanding the qualifications required is essential. Each platform has its own set of criteria that users must meet to start trading. For Fidelity, there are no specific eligibility requirements beyond being of legal age to open a brokerage account. This simplicity makes it accessible for most individuals looking to invest in US stocks and ETFs. You can open an account with no minimum deposit, which is a significant advantage for new investors.
On the other hand, Public has a slightly different approach. While it does not list strict eligibility requirements, users must be at least 18 years old to open an account. Public encourages a diverse range of investors, from beginners to seasoned traders. The platform's focus on multi-asset investing means that users can engage with stocks, bonds, crypto, and options, broadening their investment opportunities.
Both platforms allow users to trade without commissions, which is a major draw. However, Public does have some fees associated with options trading, which depend on the user's monthly trading volume. This could be a consideration for those interested in options. Additionally, Public offers features like customizable indices and API access, which may appeal to more tech-savvy investors.
In summary, Fidelity is straightforward with no account fees or minimums, making it easy for anyone to start investing. Public, while also user-friendly, offers a broader range of investment options and features but comes with some fees for specific trades. Understanding these qualifications can help you choose the platform that best fits your investment style.
- Fidelity: No specific eligibility requirements beyond legal age.
- No minimum deposit needed to open an account.
- Public: Users must be at least 18 years old.
- Encourages diverse investors from beginners to experts.
- No commissions on trades for both platforms.
- Public has fees for options trading based on monthly volume.
- Public offers customizable indices and API access.
Fees and extra charges
When choosing a trading platform, understanding fees and extra charges is crucial. Both Fidelity and Public offer competitive pricing structures, but they cater to different investing needs.
Fidelity stands out with its zero account fees. Investors can trade US stocks and ETFs without worrying about commissions. This can be especially beneficial for frequent traders. Additionally, Fidelity allows fractional shares starting at just $1. This feature enables investors to buy portions of expensive stocks without breaking the bank.
On the other hand, Public operates on a different model. While it does not charge commissions on trades, it introduces fees for options trading. These fees range from $0.06 to $0.18 per contract, depending on the monthly trading volume. This could impact investors who frequently trade options. However, Public provides a unique edge with its rebates on options trades, potentially offsetting some costs for active traders.
Public also has a base margin rate of 5.15%, with the lowest rate available at 4.20%. This is important for those considering margin trading. Additionally, the platform offers a 3.30% APY on cash and a 6.44% yield on its Bond Account. These rates can enhance the overall returns for investors holding cash or bonds within their accounts.
Both platforms have their pros and cons regarding fees. Fidelity is ideal for those focused on stock and ETF trading without extra costs. Public, however, appeals to multi-asset investors looking for AI-driven strategies, despite the potential fees associated with options trading.
- Fidelity: $0 account fees
- Fidelity: $0 commissions for US stock & ETF trades
- Fidelity: Fractional shares starting at $1
- Public: No commissions on trades
- Public: Fees for options trading ($0.06–$0.18 per contract)
- Public: 5.15% base margin rate, lowest 4.20%
- Public: 3.30% APY on cash
- Public: 6.44% yield on Bond Account
- Public: 1% match on annual contributions for IRAs
- Fidelity is best for stock and ETF investors
- Public is best for multi-asset investing and AI strategies
How fast you get it
When choosing a trading platform, speed is crucial. Approval time and funding speed can impact your investment decisions. Let's look at how quickly you can get started with Fidelity and Public.
Fidelity offers a straightforward account setup. Generally, you can open a brokerage account online in minutes. Once your account is established, funding it is quick. You can transfer funds via electronic bank transfer, which typically takes one to three business days. This means you can start trading in a matter of days after your initial setup.
Public, on the other hand, also provides a fast account opening process. You can create an account in just a few minutes using their app. Funding your account is similarly efficient. Public supports various funding methods, including bank transfers. However, the speed may vary based on your bank's processing times. Generally, expect your funds to be available within a few days.
Both platforms prioritize a smooth onboarding experience. However, Fidelity might edge out slightly in terms of consistent funding speed due to its established banking relationships. Public's innovative features, such as customizable indices and AI-driven strategies, may appeal to those looking for advanced tools, but the funding speed can be a bit less predictable depending on your bank.
In summary, both Fidelity and Public offer quick account setups. Fidelity may provide slightly faster funding times, while Public brings unique features for modern investors.
- Fidelity: Quick online account setup, usually within minutes.
- Funding via electronic bank transfer takes one to three business days.
- Public: Fast account creation through the app, typically in minutes.
- Funding methods include bank transfers, with variable speeds based on your bank.
- Fidelity may have more consistent funding speeds.
- Public offers advanced features like customizable indices and AI strategies.
How to compare them
When comparing Fidelity and Public, consider several key factors. Both platforms cater to different types of investors. Fidelity is a solid choice for those focused on US stocks and ETFs. Public, on the other hand, offers a broader range of investment options, including bonds and cryptocurrencies. This makes it appealing for multi-asset investing.
Next, look at the costs associated with each platform. Fidelity has no account fees and offers commission-free trades for US stocks and ETFs. This can lead to significant savings, especially for frequent traders. Public also has no commissions on trades, but it charges fees for options trading based on monthly volume. This could add up if you frequently trade options.
Another important aspect is the availability of fractional shares. Fidelity allows you to invest in fractional shares starting at $1. This is beneficial for those who want to invest smaller amounts. Public also supports fractional shares, but the specifics of their offering should be verified based on your investment strategy.
Consider the rewards and rates offered by each platform. Fidelity provides $0 commissions and access to fractional shares, which enhances flexibility. Public offers a 3.30% APY on cash and a 6.44% yield on its Bond Account. Additionally, it provides a 1% match on annual contributions for IRAs, which can be a significant incentive for long-term investors.
Finally, think about the tools and features each platform provides. Public incorporates AI-driven investment strategies, which can help you make informed decisions. Fidelity, while more traditional, offers a robust platform for serious investors focused on US markets.
- Fidelity: Best for US stocks and ETFs.
- Public: Good for multi-asset investing and AI features.
- Fidelity has $0 account fees and commission-free trades.
- Public charges fees for options trades based on volume.
- Fidelity allows fractional shares starting at $1.
- Public offers a 3.30% APY on cash and a 6.44% yield on bonds.
- Public provides a 1% match on annual IRA contributions.
- Consider the tools: Public has AI-driven strategies.
What to watch for
When choosing a trading platform, it's crucial to understand the limits and catches that may affect your overall costs. Both Fidelity and Public offer attractive features, but they come with specific considerations.
Fidelity stands out with its $0 account fees and commission-free trades for US stocks and ETFs. This makes it appealing for investors looking to keep costs low. However, while there are no commissions on trades, investors should be aware of potential hidden costs associated with other investment products or services not covered by the commission-free structure.
Public also has no commissions on trades, which is a significant advantage. However, it charges fees for options trades, which can range from $0.06 to $0.18 per contract, depending on your trading volume. This could add up quickly if you frequently trade options. Additionally, while Public offers a competitive base margin rate of 5.15%, the lowest rate is 4.20%. Investors should evaluate if margin trading aligns with their investment strategy and risk tolerance.
Both platforms provide unique features that may influence your decision. For instance, Public offers AI-driven investment strategies and customizable indices, which could be beneficial for tech-savvy investors. However, the complexity of these features may not suit everyone, especially those new to investing.
In summary, while both Fidelity and Public present no commission trading as a key benefit, it's essential to look beyond that. Consider any fees for specific trades, the suitability of advanced features, and how they align with your investment goals.
- Fidelity: $0 account fees and commission-free trades for US stocks and ETFs.
- Potential hidden costs for other investment products at Fidelity.
- Public: No commissions on trades but fees for options trades ($0.06–$0.18 per contract).
- Public's margin rates: 5.15% base, lowest 4.20%.
- Public offers AI-driven strategies and customizable indices.
- Advanced features may not suit all investors, especially beginners.
Which one to choose
Choosing the right trading platform depends on your investment style and needs. Fidelity and Public offer distinct advantages for different types of investors. Understanding these can help you make an informed decision.
Fidelity is ideal for those focused on investing in US stocks and ETFs. It has no account fees, making it easy to start without worrying about hidden costs. You can trade US stocks and ETFs without paying commissions. This is a major plus for frequent traders. Additionally, Fidelity allows fractional shares starting at just $1. This feature is beneficial for investors who want to diversify their portfolios without needing a large upfront investment.
On the other hand, Public caters to a broader range of investments. It allows access to stocks, bonds, crypto, and options. This makes it suitable for multi-asset investing. Public also has no commissions on trades, similar to Fidelity. However, it has specific fees for options trades based on your monthly trading volume. If you are interested in options, be aware of these costs.
Public also offers unique features like AI-driven investment strategies and customizable indices for direct indexing. These can enhance your investment approach if you prefer a tech-savvy platform. Additionally, Public provides a competitive base margin rate and attractive yields on cash and bond accounts.
In summary, if your focus is primarily on US stocks and ETFs, Fidelity is a strong choice. If you want a more diverse investment approach with advanced features, consider Public.
- Fidelity: Best for US stocks and ETFs.
- No account fees and commission-free trades.
- Fractional shares available starting at $1.
- Public: Best for multi-asset investing.
- Access to stocks, bonds, crypto, and options.
- No commissions on trades, but fees for options based on volume.
- AI-driven investment strategies and customizable indices.
- Competitive margin rates and attractive yields.
Rates and fees change. Check with the lender before you apply. This is general information, not financial advice.