E*TRADE vs Public: Trading platforms compared
E*TRADE and Public are two trading platforms options. The sections below line up cost, what you get, fees, speed, and who each one fits.
| E*TRADE | Public | |
|---|---|---|
| Fees | Options contracts 50¢ with 30+ trades per quarter; Futures contracts $1.50 per side, per contract plus exchange fees; Crypto commissions on the dollar value of each trade. | Earn rebates on your options trades, $0.06–$0.18 per stock or ETF contract based on monthly trading volume. |
Why compare them
When choosing a trading platform, it's crucial to compare options. E*TRADE and Public offer unique features that cater to different investor needs. E*TRADE is backed by Morgan Stanley, providing a robust brokerage account with a strong reputation. Public, on the other hand, is an investing app that emphasizes multi-asset investing and innovative AI-driven strategies.
Both platforms have their strengths. E*TRADE boasts zero commissions on online US-listed stock, ETF, mutual fund, and options trades. This makes it appealing for frequent traders. Public also offers no commissions, making it attractive for cost-conscious investors. However, Public's fee structure for options trades varies based on monthly trading volume, which may suit different trading habits.
E*TRADE provides competitive savings rates, including a 4.25% APY for six months and up to 4.80% for Certificates of Deposit. Public offers a slightly lower APY of 3.30% on cash, but it features a 6.44% yield on Bond Accounts. This difference can impact your decision based on your cash management preferences.
The welcome offer from E*TRADE is enticing, allowing new users to earn up to $1,500 with a qualifying deposit. Public does not have a welcome offer, which may be a factor for those looking to maximize initial investments. Additionally, E*TRADE requires a minimum deposit of $1,000 to open an account, while Public does not specify eligibility criteria.
Ultimately, the choice between E*TRADE and Public comes down to your trading style, investment goals, and preferences for features and fees.
- E*TRADE is backed by Morgan Stanley, providing a trusted brokerage account.
- Public is an investing app focused on multi-asset investing and AI strategies.
- E*TRADE offers zero commissions on US-listed trades, appealing to frequent traders.
- Public also has no commissions, but options fees vary by trading volume.
- E*TRADE provides competitive savings rates, including high APYs on deposits.
- Public offers a lower APY on cash but a higher yield on Bond Accounts.
- E*TRADE has a welcome offer of up to $1,500 for new accounts.
- Public does not have a welcome offer, which may affect initial investment decisions.
- E*TRADE requires a minimum deposit of $1,000 to open an account.
- Public does not specify eligibility criteria for account opening.
Cost
When it comes to cost, E*TRADE and Public offer different structures that cater to various investing styles. E*TRADE, a brokerage account from Morgan Stanley, has zero commissions for online trades of US-listed stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, and options. This makes it appealing for active traders. However, there are fees for options and futures contracts. Options contracts cost 50 cents each if you make more than 30 trades per quarter. Futures contracts have a fee of $1.50 per side, plus any exchange fees. E*TRADE also offers competitive rates on its savings accounts and CDs, with an APY of up to 4.80% for CDs. They have a welcome offer that can give you up to $1,500 when you open and fund a new account with a qualifying deposit. To qualify, you need to fund your account with at least $1,000 within 60 days of opening it.
On the other hand, Public operates as an investing app with a different fee structure. They do not charge commissions on trades, which is a significant advantage for casual investors. Instead, they earn rebates on options trades, with fees ranging from $0.06 to $0.18 per stock or ETF contract, depending on your monthly trading volume. Public also offers attractive yields on cash and bonds, with a 3.30% APY on cash and a 6.44% yield on their Bond Account. Additionally, they provide a 1% match on annual contributions for IRAs, which can enhance your investment growth over time. While Public's low margin rates and AI-driven investment strategies may appeal to tech-savvy investors, it's essential to note that options trading may not be suitable for everyone.
- E*TRADE: Zero commissions for online trades of US-listed stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, and options.
- Options contracts: 50 cents each with 30+ trades per quarter.
- Futures contracts: $1.50 per side, plus exchange fees.
- Up to 4.80% APY for Certificates of Deposit.
- Welcome offer: Up to $1,500 for new accounts with qualifying deposits.
- Public: No commissions on trades.
- Options trade rebates: $0.06–$0.18 per stock or ETF contract.
- 3.30% APY on cash.
- 6.44% yield on Bond Account.
- 1% match on annual contributions for IRAs.
- Low margin rates available.
What you get
E*TRADE and Public offer distinct features tailored to different types of investors. E*TRADE is a full-service brokerage account backed by Morgan Stanley. It provides zero commissions on online trades for US-listed stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, and options. This makes it an attractive option for frequent traders. E*TRADE also boasts market-leading savings rates, offering an Annual Percentage Yield (APY) of 4.25% for the first six months and 3.75% thereafter. Additionally, for those interested in Certificates of Deposit, E*TRADE offers rates up to 4.80% APY. The platform is known for its award-winning interface, making it user-friendly for both beginners and experienced investors. However, users should be aware that other fees may apply, particularly for options and futures trading.
On the other hand, Public is an investing app that emphasizes multi-asset investing. It allows users to trade stocks, bonds, crypto, and options without any commissions. Public offers a unique rebate system for options trades, with fees ranging from $0.06 to $0.18 per contract based on monthly trading volume. The app features AI-driven investment strategies, making it suitable for those looking for innovative approaches to investing. Public also offers a competitive 3.30% APY on cash and a 6.44% yield on its Bond Account. Additionally, users can earn a 1% match on annual contributions for IRAs, enhancing the overall value of their investments. However, options trading on Public may not be suitable for all investors, particularly those who are inexperienced.
- E*TRADE features:
- - Zero commissions on online US-listed stock, ETF, mutual fund, and options trades.
- - 4.25% APY for the first six months, then 3.75% APY.
- - Up to 4.80% APY for Certificates of Deposit.
- - Award-winning platform.
- - Other fees may apply, especially for options and futures.
- Public features:
- - No commissions on trades.
- - Rebates on options trades ($0.06–$0.18 per contract).
- - 3.30% APY on cash.
- - 6.44% yield on Bond Account.
- - 1% match on annual contributions for IRAs.
- - AI-driven investment strategies.
- - Options trading may not suit all investors.
Who each one fits
Choosing the right trading platform depends on your investment style and needs. E*TRADE and Public cater to different types of investors.
E*TRADE is ideal for those who want a comprehensive brokerage experience. It suits active traders with its zero commissions on online US-listed stock, ETF, mutual fund, and options trades. If you frequently trade options or futures, E*TRADE offers competitive fees, making it a strong choice. The platform also provides market-leading savings rates, which can benefit those looking to earn on their cash. Additionally, the welcome offer of up to $1,500 for new accounts is attractive for those ready to invest a significant amount right away.
On the other hand, Public appeals to newer investors or those interested in multi-asset investing. Its no-commission structure makes it easy for beginners to start without worrying about fees. The platform's focus on AI-driven investment strategies can help users make informed decisions. Public also offers unique features like customizable indices for direct indexing and API access for programmatic trading, catering to tech-savvy investors. The option to earn a 1% match on annual contributions for IRAs adds an extra incentive for long-term investors.
In summary, if you are an active trader seeking a robust platform with a variety of investment options, E*TRADE is the better choice. If you prefer a user-friendly app with innovative features and a focus on multi-asset investing, Public is likely the right fit.
- E*TRADE is best for: Active traders, those seeking competitive fees on options and futures, and investors interested in high savings rates.
- Public is best for: New investors, those interested in AI-driven strategies, and individuals looking for a no-commission trading experience.
What you need to qualify
To open an E*TRADE account, you need to meet specific requirements. First, you must fund your new account with at least $1,000 within 60 days of opening it. This is crucial to qualify for their welcome offer, which can give you up to $1,500. Keep in mind that this offer is only valid for accounts funded by February 28, 2027. E*TRADE does not specify additional eligibility criteria, making it accessible for many investors.
Public has a more flexible approach. There are no specific eligibility requirements listed for opening an account. This makes it easy for anyone interested in investing to get started. Public is ideal for multi-asset investing and offers AI-driven investment strategies. However, it’s essential to note that while there are no strict qualifications, understanding the platform's features and offerings is beneficial for effective investing.
Both platforms have their unique advantages. E*TRADE requires an initial deposit, which may deter some new investors. However, it rewards you with a substantial welcome offer. On the other hand, Public’s lack of qualifying criteria allows for a broader audience to engage with various investment options. This includes stocks, bonds, crypto, and options, appealing to those looking for a diverse portfolio.
- E*TRADE requires a minimum deposit of $1,000 within 60 days to qualify for the welcome offer.
- The welcome offer at E*TRADE is valid for accounts funded by February 28, 2027.
- Public has no specific eligibility requirements for opening an account.
- E*TRADE’s offer can provide up to $1,500 for new accounts.
- Public is suitable for multi-asset investing and AI-driven strategies.
- Understanding the features of each platform can enhance your investing experience.
Fees and extra charges
When comparing fees and extra charges between E*TRADE and Public, it's essential to understand the specific costs associated with each platform. E*TRADE offers a straightforward fee structure for various trades, while Public has a more variable approach based on trading volume.
E*TRADE charges options contracts at 50 cents each for users making 30 or more trades per quarter. For futures contracts, the fee is $1.50 per side, per contract, plus any applicable exchange fees. Additionally, crypto commissions are based on the dollar value of each trade, which can vary significantly depending on the transaction size.
Public, on the other hand, has a unique fee structure. It offers rebates on options trades, with costs ranging from $0.06 to $0.18 per stock or ETF contract. This fee is contingent on the monthly trading volume, meaning active traders may benefit from lower costs. However, this variability can make it challenging to predict total trading expenses.
Both platforms offer commission-free trading for stocks and ETFs. E*TRADE provides zero commissions for online trades of US-listed stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, and options. Public also boasts no commissions on trades, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious investors.
It's worth noting that while E*TRADE has a clear fee structure, other fees may apply that are not explicitly listed. Public's fees are dependent on trading activity, which may not be suitable for all investors, particularly those who trade infrequently. Understanding these fees is crucial for making informed decisions about which platform aligns best with your trading habits.
- E*TRADE fees:
- - Options contracts: 50¢ each (30+ trades/quarter)
- - Futures contracts: $1.50 per side, plus exchange fees
- - Crypto commissions based on trade value
- Public fees:
- - Options trades: rebates, $0.06–$0.18 per contract
- - Costs vary by monthly trading volume
- Both platforms offer:
- - Zero commissions on US-listed stocks and ETFs
- - E*TRADE: clear fee structure, but other fees may apply
- - Public: fees depend on trading activity, may not suit all investors
How fast you get it
When choosing a trading platform, speed matters. Approval time and funding speed can affect your trading experience. E*TRADE and Public offer different timelines for getting started.
E*TRADE requires you to open a new account and fund it with at least $1,000 within 60 days. Once your account is set up, funding can be done through various methods. These include bank transfers and wire transfers. Typically, bank transfers take a few business days to clear. Wire transfers are faster, often processing the same day. This means you could start trading almost immediately after funding.
Public, on the other hand, focuses on a seamless onboarding experience. While specific approval times are not detailed, the app is designed for quick access. You can create an account and start trading in minutes. Funding options include bank transfers, which may take a couple of days. However, Public emphasizes speed, aiming to get you trading as soon as possible.
Both platforms allow you to start trading without lengthy delays. E*TRADE has a structured process but offers multiple funding options. Public prioritizes quick access, making it easy to get started. Consider your urgency when choosing a platform. If you want immediate access, Public may be the better choice. If you prefer a more traditional brokerage experience with a range of funding options, E*TRADE could fit your needs.
- E*TRADE requires $1,000 funding within 60 days.
- Bank transfers at E*TRADE take a few business days.
- Wire transfers at E*TRADE can process the same day.
- Public allows account creation in minutes.
- Funding at Public includes bank transfers, taking a couple of days.
- E*TRADE offers multiple funding methods for flexibility.
- Public emphasizes a quick and seamless trading experience.
How to compare them
When comparing E*TRADE and Public, consider several key factors. Each platform offers unique features that cater to different types of investors. Start by looking at the fee structures. E*TRADE has zero commissions for online trades of US-listed stocks, ETFs, and mutual funds. However, it charges for options and futures contracts. Public also offers commission-free trades but has a variable fee based on monthly trading volume for options. This could impact frequent traders differently.
Next, evaluate the interest rates on cash balances. E*TRADE offers a competitive savings rate of up to 4.80% APY for Certificates of Deposit. Public provides a lower cash APY of 3.30% but has a higher yield on its Bond Account at 6.44%. Depending on your cash management strategy, one may be more appealing than the other.
Consider the welcome offers as well. E*TRADE has a limited-time offer where you can earn up to $1,500 for new accounts funded with a qualifying deposit. Public does not have a welcome offer, which could be a deciding factor for new investors looking for immediate incentives.
Lastly, think about the types of investments available. E*TRADE is known for its award-winning platform and offers a wide range of investment options. Public emphasizes multi-asset investing and AI-driven strategies, making it suitable for tech-savvy investors. Your investment goals and preferences will ultimately guide your choice.
- Compare fee structures: E*TRADE has zero commissions for US-listed trades; Public has variable fees for options.
- Check interest rates: E*TRADE offers up to 4.80% APY for CDs; Public offers 3.30% APY on cash and 6.44% on Bonds.
- Look at welcome offers: E*TRADE has up to $1,500 for new accounts; Public does not offer a welcome bonus.
- Consider investment types: E*TRADE has a broad range; Public focuses on multi-asset and AI-driven strategies.
What to watch for
When choosing a trading platform, it’s crucial to consider the hidden costs and limitations that can affect your overall experience. Both E*TRADE and Public offer appealing features, but they come with specific conditions that may impact your trading decisions.
E*TRADE has a straightforward fee structure for options and futures trading. Options contracts cost 50 cents with 30 or more trades per quarter. Futures contracts are priced at $1.50 per side, plus any exchange fees. While E*TRADE promotes zero commissions for online trades of US-listed stocks, ETFs, and mutual funds, other fees may apply. It’s essential to read the fine print to understand these potential costs.
On the other hand, Public offers a unique fee structure. They provide rebates on options trades, with charges ranging from $0.06 to $0.18 per stock or ETF contract, depending on your monthly trading volume. This could be beneficial for active traders but may not suit everyone. Additionally, while Public has no commissions on trades, options trading might not be suitable for all investors, which could limit your strategies.
Both platforms offer attractive interest rates on cash balances. E*TRADE boasts a 4.25% APY for six months, dropping to 3.75% thereafter, while Public offers 3.30% APY on cash. However, these rates could change, so it's wise to monitor them regularly.
Lastly, consider the eligibility requirements for promotions. E*TRADE requires a minimum deposit of $1,000 to qualify for their welcome offer, while Public does not list a welcome offer. Be sure to evaluate these factors carefully to avoid unexpected costs.
- E*TRADE fees include:
- - Options contracts: 50 cents with 30+ trades per quarter
- - Futures contracts: $1.50 per side, plus exchange fees
- - Other fees may apply for various services.
- Public fees include:
- - Rebates on options trades: $0.06–$0.18 per stock or ETF contract
- - No commissions on trades.
- Interest rates:
- - E*TRADE: 4.25% APY for six months, then 3.75% APY
- - Public: 3.30% APY on cash.
- Eligibility considerations:
- - E*TRADE requires $1,000 minimum deposit for welcome offer.
- - Public does not have a listed welcome offer.
Which one to choose
Choosing between E*TRADE and Public depends on your investing style and needs. E*TRADE is a strong choice for traditional investors. It offers zero commissions on online trades for US-listed stocks, ETFs, and mutual funds. This can be a big advantage for active traders. E*TRADE also provides a market-leading savings rate, which is appealing for those looking to earn on their cash. Additionally, the platform is award-winning, known for its user-friendly interface and robust research tools.
On the other hand, Public caters to those interested in multi-asset investing. It provides access to stocks, bonds, crypto, and options. This variety allows for a more diversified investment approach. Public also features AI-driven investment strategies, which can help investors make informed decisions. The platform has no commissions on trades, making it cost-effective for casual investors. However, options trading may not suit everyone, so it's essential to consider your comfort level with that type of investing.
If you are looking for a platform with high savings rates and a well-established reputation, E*TRADE is the way to go. It also has a welcome offer that can provide extra cash when you open a new account. For those who want a modern investing experience with innovative tools, Public stands out. Its customizable indices and API access for programmatic trading appeal to tech-savvy investors.
- E*TRADE: Best for traditional investors.
- Zero commissions for online trades.
- Market-leading savings rates.
- Award-winning user-friendly platform.
- Public: Best for multi-asset investing.
- Access to stocks, bonds, crypto, and options.
- AI-driven investment strategies.
- No commissions on trades.
- Consider comfort level with options trading.
Rates and fees change. Check with the lender before you apply. This is general information, not financial advice.