UNITED STATES
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
FORM 10-Q
(Mark One)
Quarterly Report Pursuant to Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
For the quarterly period ended October 31, 2008.
or
Transition Report Pursuant to Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
For the transition period from to
Commission file number 1-6991
WAL-MART STORES, INC.
(Exact name of registrant as specified in its charter)
Delaware
71-0415188
(State or other jurisdiction of
incorporation or organization)
(I.R.S. Employer
Identification No.)
702 S.W. 8th Street
Bentonville, Arkansas
72716
(Address of principal executive offices)
(Zip Code)
(479) 273-4000
(Registrant s telephone number, including area code)
Not applicable
(Former name, former address and former fiscal year, if changed since last report)
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant (1) has filed all reports required to be filed by Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 during the preceding 12 months (or such shorter
periods that the registrant was required to file such reports), and (2) has been subject to such filing requirements for the past 90 days. Yes No
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant is
a large accelerated filer, an accelerated filer, a non-accelerated filer or a smaller reporting company. See definitions of large accelerated filer, accelerated filer and smaller reporting company in Rule 12b-2 of
the Exchange Act. Check One:
Large Accelerated Filer Accelerated
Filer Non-Accelerated Filer Smaller Reporting Company
Indicate by a check mark whether the registrant is a shell company (as defined in Rule 12b-2 of the Exchange
Act). Yes No
Applicable Only to Corporate Issuers
Indicate the number of
shares outstanding of each of the issuer s classes of common stock, as of the latest practical date.
Common Stock, $.10 Par Value 3,922,552,337
shares as of December 3, 2008.
PART I. FINANCIAL INFORMATION
Item 1.
Financial Statements
WAL-MART STORES, INC.
CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF INCOME
(Unaudited)
(Amounts in millions except per share data)
Three Months Ended
October 31,
Nine Months Ended
October 31,
2008
2007
2008
2007
Revenues:
Net sales
97,634
90,826
293,248
268,099
Membership and other income
1,008
1,039
3,243
3,034
98,642
91,865
296,491
271,133
Costs and expenses:
Cost of sales
74,114
69,251
223,557
205,073
Operating, selling, general and administrative expenses
19,236
17,653
56,513
50,984
Operating income
5,292
4,961
16,421
15,076
Interest:
Debt
464
474
1,402
1,326
Capital leases
73
63
222
174
Interest income
(81
(77
(216
(246
Interest, net
456
460
1,408
1,254
Income from continuing operations before income taxes and minority interest
4,836
4,501
15,013
13,822
Provision for income taxes
1,690
1,556
5,186
4,764
Income from continuing operations before minority interest
3,146
2,945
9,827
9,058
Minority interest
(113
(99
(365
(305
Income from continuing operations
3,033
2,846
9,462
8,753
Income (loss) from discontinued operations, net of tax
105
11
146
(118
Net income
3,138
2,857
9,608
8,635
Net income per common share:
Basic income per common share from continuing operations
0.77
0.70
2.40
2.14
Basic income (loss) per common share from discontinued operations
0.03
0.01
0.04
(0.03
Basic net income per common share
0.80
0.71
2.44
2.11
Diluted income per common share from continuing operations
0.77
0.70
2.39
2.14
Diluted income (loss) per common share from discontinued operations
0.03
0.04
(0.03
Diluted net income per common share
0.80
0.70
2.43
2.11
Weighted-average number of common shares:
Basic
3,931
4,051
3,944
4,092
Diluted
3,944
4,056
3,956
4,097
Dividends declared per common share
0.95
0.88
WAL-MART STORES, INC.
CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS
(Unaudited)
(Amounts in millions)
October 31,
2008
October 31,
2007
January 31,
2008
ASSETS
Current assets:
Cash and cash equivalents
5,920
5,518
5,492
Receivables
3,250
3,062
3,642
Inventories
40,416
39,535
35,159
Prepaid expenses and other
3,245
2,880
2,760
Current assets of discontinued operations
25
511
532
Total current assets
52,856
51,506
47,585
Property and equipment, at cost:
Property and equipment, at cost
125,173
120,396
122,256
Less accumulated depreciation
(31,467
(27,537
(28,531
Property and equipment, net
93,706
92,859
93,725
Property under capital lease:
Property under capital lease
5,420
5,690
5,736
Less accumulated amortization
(2,581
(2,563
(2,594
Property under capital lease, net
2,839
3,127
3,142
Goodwill
15,416
14,898
16,071
Other assets and deferred charges
2,789
3,031
2,748
Non-current assets of discontinued operations
237
238
243
Total assets
167,843
165,659
163,514
LIABILITIES AND SHAREHOLDERS EQUITY
Current liabilities:
Commercial paper
7,932
9,126
5,040
Accounts payable
30,782
31,376
30,344
Dividends payable
993
896
Accrued liabilities
15,343
14,773
15,725
Accrued income taxes
355
1,000
Long-term debt due within one year
4,753
4,412
5,913
Obligations under capital lease due within one year
314
309
316
Current liabilities of discontinued operations
128
50
116
Total current liabilities
60,600
60,942
58,454
Long-term debt
30,803
30,070
29,799
Long-term obligations under capital lease
3,268
3,520
3,603
Deferred income taxes and other
5,575
5,590
5,087
Minority interest
2,034
2,432
1,939
Non-current liabilities of discontinued operations
24
23
24
Commitments and contingencies
Shareholders equity:
Common stock and capital in excess of par value
4,219
3,421
3,425
Retained earnings
59,809
55,522
57,319
Accumulated other comprehensive income
1,511
4,139
3,864
Total shareholders equity
65,539
63,082
64,608
Total liabilities and shareholders equity
167,843
165,659
163,514
WAL-MART STORES, INC.
CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS
(Unaudited)
(Amounts in millions)
Nine Months Ended
October 31,
2008
2007
Cash flows from operating activities:
Net income
9,608
8,635
(Income) loss from discontinued operations, net of tax
(146
118
Income from continuing operations
9,462
8,753
Adjustments to reconcile income from continuing operations to net cash provided by operating activities:
Depreciation and amortization
5,054
4,656
Other
749
321
Changes in certain assets and liabilities, net of effects of acquisitions:
Decrease in accounts receivable
394
31
Increase in inventories
(5,655
(5,037
Increase in accounts payable
914
1,450
Decrease in accrued liabilities
(745
(551
Net cash provided by operating activities
10,173
9,623
Cash flows from investing activities:
Payments for property and equipment
(8,174
(10,896
Proceeds from disposal of property and equipment
779
478
Proceeds from (payments for) disposal of certain international operations, net
838
(257
Investment in international operations, net of cash acquired
(74
(461
Other investing activities
(166
(87
Net cash used in investing activities
(6,797
(11,223
Cash flows from financing activities:
Increase in commercial paper, net
2,949
6,481
Proceeds from issuance of long-term debt
5,568
7,967
Payment of long-term debt
(5,064
(6,671
Dividends paid
(2,814
(2,707
Purchase of Company stock
(3,521
(5,279
Other financing activities
88
(669
Net cash used in financing activities
(2,794
(878
Effect of exchange rates on cash
(231
258
Net increase (decrease) in cash and cash equivalents
351
(2,220
Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of year (1)
5,569
7,767
Cash and cash equivalents at end of period (2)
5,920
5,547
(1)
Includes cash and cash equivalents of discontinued operations of $77 million and $51 million at January 31, 2008 and 2007, respectively.
(2)
Includes cash and cash equivalents of discontinued operations of $29 million at October 31, 2007.
WAL-MART STORES, INC.
NOTES TO CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
NOTE 1. Basis of Presentation
The Condensed Consolidated Balance Sheets of Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. and its subsidiaries (the Company ) as of October 31, 2008 and 2007,
the related Condensed Consolidated Statements of Income for the three and nine months ended October 31, 2008 and 2007, and the related Condensed Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows for the nine-month periods ended October 31, 2008 and
2007, are unaudited. The Condensed Consolidated Balance Sheet as of January 31, 2008, is derived from the audited financial statements at that date.
The Company s operations in Argentina, Brazil, China, Costa Rica, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Japan, Mexico, Nicaragua and the United Kingdom are consolidated using a December 31 fiscal year-end,
generally due to statutory reporting requirements. The Company s operations in Canada and Puerto Rico are consolidated using a January 31 fiscal year-end.
In the opinion of management, all adjustments necessary for a fair presentation of the condensed consolidated financial statements have been included. Such adjustments are of a normal recurring nature. Interim results
are not necessarily indicative of results for a full year.
The condensed consolidated financial statements and notes thereto are presented
in accordance with the rules and regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission (the SEC ) and do not contain certain information included in the Company s Annual Report to Shareholders for the fiscal year ended
January 31, 2008. Therefore, the interim condensed consolidated financial statements should be read in conjunction with that Annual Report to Shareholders.
General Liability and Workers Compensation Change in Estimate
Liabilities associated with general liability and
workers compensation claims against the Company are estimated by considering the Company s historical claims experience, including frequency and severity of claims, and certain actuarial assumptions. In estimating our liability for such
claims, we periodically analyze our historical trends, including loss development, and apply appropriate loss development factors to the incurred costs associated with the claims. During the last few years, we have enhanced how we manage claims. As
a result, our loss experience with respect to such claims has improved and the actuarially determined ultimate loss estimates, primarily for fiscal year 2004 through 2007 claims, were reduced during the quarter ended July 31, 2007. The
reductions in ultimate loss estimates resulted primarily from improved claims handling experience, which impacts loss development factors and other actuarial assumptions. Due to the beneficial change in estimate of our ultimate losses, accrued
liabilities for general liability and workers compensation claims were reduced by $196 million after tax, resulting in an increase in net income per basic and diluted common share from continuing operations of $0.05 for the quarter ended
July 31, 2007 and the nine months ended October 31, 2007.
NOTE 2. Net Income Per Common Share
Basic net income per common share is based on the weighted-average number of outstanding common shares. Diluted net income per common share is based on
the weighted-average number of outstanding shares adjusted for the dilutive effect of stock options and other share-based awards. The dilutive effect of outstanding stock options and restricted stock was 13 million and 12 million shares
for the three and nine months ended October 31, 2008, respectively, and 5 million shares for the three and nine months ended October 31, 2007. The Company had approximately 1 million and 68 million option shares outstanding
at October 31, 2008 and 2007, respectively, which were not included in the diluted net income per share calculation because their effect would be antidilutive.
NOTE 3. Inventories
The Company values inventories at the lower of cost or market as determined
primarily by the retail method of accounting, using the last-in, first-out ( LIFO ) method for substantially all of the Walmart U.S. segment s merchandise inventories. The Sam s Club segment s merchandise and merchandise in
our distribution warehouses are valued based on the weighted-average cost using the LIFO method. Inventories of foreign operations are primarily valued by the retail method of accounting, using the first-in, first-out ( FIFO ) method. At
October 31, 2008 and 2007, our inventories valued at LIFO approximate those inventories as if they were valued at FIFO.
NOTE 4. Certain Long-term Debt Transactions
In April 2008, the Company issued $1.0 billion of 4.250% Notes Due 2013 and $1.5 billion of 6.200% Notes Due 2038. Interest started accruing on such notes
on April 15, 2008. On October 15, 2008, the Company began paying interest on the notes of each series and will continue to pay interest on April 15 and October 15 of each year. The 2013 notes will mature on April 15, 2013
and the 2038 notes will mature on April 15, 2038. The notes of each such series are senior, unsecured and unsubordinated obligations of Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.
In May 2008, Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. entered into a term loan facility with a syndicate of banks. Pursuant to that facility, the Company borrowed ¥220 billion to refinance outstanding debt of its wholly-owned
subsidiary, The Seiyu, Ltd., that was scheduled to mature in December, 2008. Borrowings under such facility are senior, unsecured obligations of Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. and generally bear interest at a floating rate equal to the one, three or six
month yen London Interbank Offered Rate plus a spread of 0.35%. Such debt matures on June 26, 2011. The amount of such debt in United States dollars as reflected on the Company s Condensed Consolidated Balance Sheets at October 31,
2008 was approximately $2.2 billion. The facility is designated as a hedge of the Company s net investment in Japan.
In August 2008,
the following bonds were issued as senior, unsecured and unsubordinated obligations of Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.
(Amounts in millions)
Issue
Date
Interest
Rate
Interest
Payment
Dates
Maturity
Dates
Local Currency
Issue Amount
US Dollar
October 31, 2008
Japanese Yen Bonds - First Series
August 2008
1.720%
February 5
August 5
August 5, 2011
¥
25,000
254
Japanese Yen Bonds - Second Series
August 2008
2.010%
February 5
August 5
August 5, 2013
25,000
254
Japanese Yen Floating Rate Bonds - First Series
August 2008
6-month yen Libor + .50%
February 5
August 5
August 5, 2013
50,000
508
Total
¥
100,000
1,016
The bonds of each series are denominated and payable in Japanese yen and are designated as a hedge
of the Company s net investment in Japan.
NOTE 5. Fair Value Measurements
In September 2006, the Financial Accounting Standards Board ( FASB ) issued Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 157, Fair
Value Measurements ( SFAS 157 ). SFAS 157 defines fair value, establishes a framework for measuring fair value within generally accepted accounting principles ( GAAP ) and expands required disclosures about fair value
measurements. In November 2007, the FASB provided a one year deferral for the implementation of SFAS 157 for nonfinancial assets and liabilities. The Company adopted SFAS 157 on February 1, 2008, as required. The adoption of SFAS 157 did not
have a material impact on the Company s financial condition and results of operations.
SFAS 157 establishes a three-tier fair value hierarchy, which prioritizes the inputs used in measuring
fair value. These tiers include: Level 1, defined as observable inputs such as quoted prices in active markets; Level 2, defined as inputs other than quoted prices in active markets that are either directly or indirectly observable; and Level 3,
defined as unobservable inputs in which little or no market data exists, therefore requiring an entity to develop its own assumptions. As of October 31, 2008, the Company held certain derivative asset and liability positions that are required
to be measured at fair value on a recurring basis. The majority of the Company s derivative instruments related to interest rate swaps. The fair values of these interest rate swaps have been measured in accordance with Level 2 inputs in the
fair value hierarchy, and as of October 31, 2008, are as follows (asset/(liability)):
(Amounts in millions)
Notional Amount
October 31, 2008
Fair Value
October 31, 2008
Receive fixed-rate, pay floating-rate interest rate swaps designated as fair value hedges
5,195
223
Receive fixed-rate, pay fixed-rate cross-currency interest rate swaps designated as net investment hedges (Cross-currency notional amount: GBP
795 at 10/31/2008)
1,250
240
Receive floating-rate, pay fixed-rate interest rate swaps designated as cash flow hedges
462
(10
Total
6,907
453
In February 2007, the FASB issued Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 159,
The Fair Value Option for Financial Assets and Financial Liabilities Including an amendment of FASB Statement No. 115 ( SFAS 159 ). SFAS 159 permits companies to measure many financial instruments and certain other
items at fair value at specified election dates. The Company adopted SFAS 159 on February 1, 2008. Since the Company has not utilized the fair value option for any allowable items, the adoption of SFAS 159 did not have a material impact on the
Company s financial condition and results of operations.
NOTE 6. Segments
The Company is engaged in the operations of retail stores located in all 50 states of the United States, Argentina, Brazil, Canada, Japan, Puerto Rico and
the United Kingdom and through majority-owned subsidiaries in Central America and Mexico. The Company operates in China and India through joint ventures. The Company identifies segments in accordance with the criteria set forth in Statement of
Financial Accounting Standards No. 131, Disclosures about Segments of an Enterprise and Related Information, and is primarily based on the operations of the Company that our chief operating decision maker regularly reviews to
analyze performance and allocate resources among business units of the Company.
The Walmart U.S. segment includes the Company s mass
merchant concept in the United States under the Wal-Mart or Walmart brand, as well as walmart.com. The Sam s Club segment includes the warehouse membership clubs in the United States, as well as samsclub.com. The
International segment consists of the Company s operations outside of the 50 United States. The amounts under the caption Other in the table below relating to operating income are unallocated corporate overhead items.
The Company measures the profit of its segments as segment operating income, which is defined as income from continuing operations before net
interest expense, income taxes and minority interest and excludes unallocated corporate overhead. At February 1, 2008, the Company reclassified certain unallocated corporate expenses to be included within each segment s measurement of
segment operating income. As a result, all prior year measurements of segment operating income have been restated for comparative purposes.
Net sales by operating segment were as follows (amounts in millions):
Three Months Ended
October 31,
Nine Months Ended
October 31,
2008
2007
2008
2007
Net Sales:
Walmart U.S.
61,155
57,651
184,281
172,101
International
24,857
22,349
73,949
63,472
Sam s Club
11,622
10,826
35,018
32,526
Total Company
97,634
90,826
293,248
268,099
Segment operating income and the reconciliation to income from continuing operations before income taxes
and minority interest are as follows (amounts in millions):
Three Months Ended
October 31,
Nine Months Ended
October 31,
2008
2007
2008
2007
Operating Income:
Walmart U.S.
4,286
3,995
13,363
12,230
International
1,182
1,069
3,450
2,986
Sam s Club
365
359
1,183
1,174
Other
(541
(462
(1,575
(1,314
Operating income
5,292
4,961
16,421
15,076
Interest expense, net
(456
(460
(1,408
(1,254
Income from continuing operations before income taxes and minority interest
4,836
4,501
15,013
13,822
Goodwill is recorded on the Condensed Consolidated Balance Sheets in the operating segments as
follows (amounts in millions):
October 31,
2008
October 31,
2007
January 31,
2008
International
15,111
14,593
15,766
Sam s Club
305
305
305
Total goodwill
15,416
14,898
16,071
The decrease in the International segment s goodwill since January 31, 2008, primarily
resulted from strengthening of the U.S. dollar against all major currencies except the Japanese yen and Chinese yuan renminbi, as well as an adjustment to allocate goodwill for the sale of Gazeley Limited ( Gazeley ), an ASDA commercial
property development subsidiary in the United Kingdom, in the second quarter of fiscal 2009.
The increase in the International
segment s goodwill since October 31, 2007, resulted from the acquisition of substantially all of the outstanding common and preferred shares of our Japanese subsidiary, The Seiyu Ltd., foreign currency exchange rate fluctuations in the
Japanese yen and Chinese yuan renminbi and purchase price adjustments related to continuing the repurchase of shares of Wal-Mart de Mexico, S.A. de C.V. throughout the period, offset by an adjustment to allocate goodwill for the sale of Gazeley.
NOTE 7. Comprehensive Income (Loss)
Comprehensive income (loss) is net income plus certain other items that are recorded directly to accumulated other comprehensive income within shareholders equity. Accumulated other comprehensive income includes translation gains and
losses from fluctuation in foreign currency exchange rates and after-tax adjustments for the Company s derivative instruments and minimum pension liabilities.
Three Months Ended
October 31,
Nine Months Ended
October 31,
(Amounts in millions)
2008
2007
2008
2007
Comprehensive Income (Loss)
(276
3,536
7,255
10,266
Comprehensive income (loss) for the three and nine months ended October 31, 2008 was
adversely affected by foreign currency exchange rate fluctuations.
NOTE 8. Common Stock Dividends
On March 6, 2008, the Company s Board of Directors approved an increase in annual dividends to $0.95 per share. The annual dividend will be paid
in four quarterly installments on April 7, 2008, June 2, 2008, September 2, 2008, and January 2, 2009, to holders of record on March 14, May 16, August 15 and December 15, 2008,
respectively.
NOTE 9. Income and Other Taxes
The Company s effective tax rate was 34.9% for the three months ended October 31, 2008, compared to 34.2% for the three months ended July 31, 2008. The recent fluctuations in foreign currency exchange
rates, together with changes in the mix of income between domestic and international operations, are the main drivers of this increase. The Company s effective tax rate for the nine months ended October 31, 2008 was 34.5%. The Company
expects the fiscal 2009 annual effective tax rate to be approximately 34-35%. Significant factors that could impact the annual effective tax rate include management s assessment of certain tax matters, the composition of taxable income between
domestic and international operations and fluctuations in foreign currency exchange rates.
In determining the quarterly provision for
income taxes, the Company uses an estimated annual effective tax rate based on forecasted annual income and permanent items, statutory tax rates and tax planning opportunities in the various jurisdictions in which the Company operates. The impact of
significant discrete items is separately recognized in the quarter in which they occur.
The Company adopted the provisions of FASB
Interpretation No. 48, Accounting for Uncertainty in Income Taxes, ( FIN 48 ) effective February 1, 2007. FIN 48 clarifies the accounting for income taxes, by prescribing a minimum recognition threshold a tax position
is required to meet before being recognized in the financial statements. FIN 48 also provides guidance on derecognition, measurement, classification, interest and penalties, accounting in interim periods, disclosure and transition.
In the normal course of its business the Company provides for uncertain tax positions, and the related interest, and adjusts its unrecognized tax
benefits and accrued interest accordingly. During the third quarter of fiscal 2009, unrecognized tax benefits related to continuing operations increased by $40 million and accrued interest increased by $10 million. For the first nine months of
fiscal 2009, unrecognized tax benefits related to continuing operations increased by $20 million and accrued interest increased by $15 million. As of October 31, 2008, the Company s unrecognized tax benefits relating to continuing
operations were $888 million, of which $612 million would, if recognized, affect the Company s effective tax rate.
Additionally, at
January 31, 2008 the Company had unrecognized tax benefits of up to $1.8 billion which, if recognized, would be recorded as discontinued operations. Of this, $63 million was recognized in discontinued operations during the second quarter of
fiscal year 2009 following the resolution of a gain determination on a discontinued operation that was sold in fiscal year 2004. The balance of $1.7 billion at October 31, 2008 relates to a worthless stock deduction which the Company has
claimed for the fiscal year 2007 disposition of its German operations.
During the next twelve months, it is reasonably possible that tax
audit resolutions could reduce unrecognized tax benefits by $165 million to $235 million, either because our tax positions are sustained on audit or because the Company agrees to their disallowance. The Company does not expect any such audit
resolutions to cause a significant change in its effective tax rate.
The Company classifies interest on uncertain tax benefits as interest
expense and income tax penalties as operating, selling, general and administrative costs. At October 31, 2008, before any tax benefits, the Company had $242 million of accrued interest and penalties on unrecognized tax benefits.
The Company is subject to income tax examinations for its U.S. federal income taxes generally for the fiscal year 2008, with fiscal years 2004 through
2007 remaining open for a limited number of U.S. income tax issues. Non-U.S. income taxes are subject to income tax examination for the tax years 2002 through 2008, and state and local income taxes are open for the fiscal years 2004 through 2007
generally and for the fiscal years 1997 through 2003 for a limited number of issues.
Additionally, the Company is subject to tax
examinations for payroll, value added, sales-based and other taxes. A number of these examinations are ongoing and, in certain cases, have resulted in assessments from the taxing authorities. Where appropriate, the Company has made accruals for
these matters which are reflected in the Company s consolidated financial statements. While these matters are individually immaterial, a group of related matters, if decided adversely to the Company, may result in liability material to the
Company s financial condition or results of operations.
NOTE 10. Legal Proceedings
The Company is involved in a number of legal proceedings. In accordance with Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 5, Accounting for
Contingencies, the Company has made accruals with respect to these matters, where appropriate, which are reflected in the Company s condensed consolidated financial statements. The Company may enter into discussions regarding settlement
of these matters, and may enter into settlement agreements, if it believes settlement is in the best interest of the Company s shareholders. The matters, or groups of related matters, discussed below, if decided adversely to or settled by the
Company, individually or in the aggregate, may result in liability material to the Company s financial condition or results of operations.
Wage-and-Hour Class Actions: The Company is a defendant in numerous cases containing class-action
allegations in which the plaintiffs are current and former hourly associates who allege that the Company forced or encouraged them to work off the clock, failed to provide rest breaks or meal periods, or otherwise failed to pay them
correctly. The complaints generally seek unspecified monetary damages, injunctive relief, or both. Class or collective-action certification has yet to be addressed by the court in a majority of these cases. In the majority of wage-and-hour class
actions filed against the Company in which the courts have addressed the issue, class certification has been denied. The Company cannot reasonably estimate the possible loss or range of loss that may arise from these lawsuits, except as noted below.
One of the class-action lawsuits described above is Savaglio v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., a class-action lawsuit in which the
plaintiffs allege that they were not provided meal and rest breaks in accordance with California law, and seek monetary damages and injunctive relief. A trial on the plaintiffs claims for monetary damages concluded on December 22, 2005.
The jury returned a verdict of approximately $57 million in statutory penalties and $115 million in punitive damages. In June 2006, the judge entered an order allowing some, but not all, of the injunctive relief sought by the plaintiffs. On
December 27, 2006, the judge entered an order awarding the plaintiffs an additional amount of approximately $26 million in costs and attorneys fees. The Company believes it has substantial factual and legal defenses to the claims at
issue, and on January 31, 2007, the Company filed its Notice of Appeal. On November 19, 2008, the court of appeals issued an Order staying further proceedings in the Savaglio appeal pending the decision of the California Supreme
Court in a case involving similar issues, entitled Brinker v. Superior Court.
In another of the class-action lawsuits described
above, Braun/Hummel v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., a trial was commenced in September 2006, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The plaintiffs allege that the Company failed to pay class members for all hours worked and prevented class members from
taking their full meal and rest breaks. On October 13, 2006, the jury awarded back-pay damages to the plaintiffs of approximately $78 million on their claims for off-the-clock work and missed rest breaks. The jury found in favor of the Company
on the plaintiffs meal-period claims. On November 14, 2007, the trial judge entered a final judgment in the approximate amount of $188 million, which included the jury s back-pay award plus statutory penalties, prejudgment interest
and attorneys fees. The Company believes it has substantial factual and legal defenses to the claims at issue, and on December 7, 2007, the Company filed its Notice of Appeal.
In another of the class-action lawsuits described above, Braun v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., a trial was held in 2007 in the First Judicial District
Court for Dakota County, Minnesota, on the plaintiffs claims that class members had worked off the clock and were not provided meal and rest breaks in accordance with Minnesota law, which resulted in a verdict in favor of the class in the
approximate amount of $7 million. The trial judge then scheduled a second trial on the plaintiffs claims for punitive damages, which under Minnesota law would be payable to the class, and statutory penalties, which would be payable to the
State of Minnesota. In October 2008, the Company agreed to settle the case by paying up to approximately $54 million, part of which is to be paid to the State of Minnesota and part to the class members and their counsel. The settlement is subject to
approval by the trial court, and the exact amount that will be paid depends on the court s approval, as well as on the number and amount of claims that are submitted by class members. The court has therefore taken the second trial off the
docket and has instead scheduled a hearing on January 14, 2009, to consider preliminary approval of the settlement agreement.
Another
of the class-action lawsuits described above, Hale v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., is scheduled for jury trial beginning on June 15, 2009, in the Circuit Court of Jackson County, Missouri. The plaintiffs allege that class members worked off
the clock and were not provided meal and rest breaks in accordance with Missouri law, and seek monetary damages in an unspecified amount, plus interest and attorneys fees. The trial court granted class certification in November 2005 and the
certification was affirmed by the Missouri Court of Appeals in June 2007. The Company believes that it has substantial factual and legal defenses to the claims at issue. The Company cannot reasonably estimate the possible loss or range of loss that
may arise from this litigation.
Another of the class-action lawsuits described above, Carter v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., is scheduled
for jury trial beginning on April 13, 2009 in the Court of Common Pleas of Colleton County, South Carolina. The plaintiffs allege that class members worked off the clock and were not provided meal and rest breaks in accordance with South
Carolina law, and seek monetary damages in an unspecified amount, plus statutory penalties, punitive damages, interest, and attorneys fees. The trial court granted class certification in May 2005. The Company believes that it has substantial
factual and legal defenses to the claims at issue. The Company cannot reasonably estimate the possible loss or range of loss that may arise from this litigation.
Exempt Status Cases: The Company is currently a defendant in four putative class actions in which the plaintiffs seek class certification of various groups of salaried managers and challenge their exempt status
under state and federal laws. In one of those cases (Sepulveda v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.), class certification was denied by the trial court on May 5, 2006. On April 25, 2008, a three-judge panel of the United States Court of
Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed the trial court s ruling in part and reversed it in part, and remanded the case for further proceedings. On May 16, 2008, the Company filed a petition seeking review of that ruling by a larger panel
of the court. On October 8, 2008, the court entered an Order staying all proceedings in the Sepulveda appeal pending the final disposition of the appeal in Dukes v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., discussed below. Class certification has
not been addressed in the other cases. The Company cannot reasonably estimate the possible loss or range of loss that may arise from these lawsuits.
10
Gender Discrimination Cases: The Company is a defendant in Dukes v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.,
a class-action lawsuit commenced in June 2001 and pending in the United States District Court for the Northern District of California. The case was brought on behalf of all past and present female employees in all of the Company s retail stores
and warehouse clubs in the United States. The complaint alleges that the Company has engaged in a pattern and practice of discriminating against women in promotions, pay, training and job assignments. The complaint seeks, among other things,
injunctive relief, front pay, back pay, punitive damages and attorneys fees. On June 21, 2004, the district court issued an order granting in part and denying in part the plaintiffs motion for class certification. The class, which
was certified by the district court for purposes of liability, injunctive and declaratory relief, punitive damages and lost pay, subject to certain exceptions, includes all women employed at any Wal-Mart domestic retail store at any time since
December 26, 1998, who have been or may be subjected to the pay and management track promotions policies and practices challenged by the plaintiffs. The class as certified currently includes approximately 1.6 million present and former
female associates.
The Company believes that the district court s ruling is incorrect. On August 31, 2004, the United States
Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit granted the Company s petition for discretionary review of the ruling. On February 6, 2007, a divided three-judge panel of the Court of Appeals issued a decision affirming the district court s
certification order. On February 20, 2007, the Company filed a petition asking that the decision be reconsidered by a larger panel of the court. On December 11, 2007, the three-judge panel withdrew its opinion of February 6, 2007, and
issued a revised opinion. As a result, Wal-Mart s Petition for Rehearing En Banc was denied as moot. Wal-Mart filed a new Petition for Rehearing En Banc on January 8, 2008. If the Company is not successful in its appeal of class
certification, or an appellate court issues a ruling that allows for the certification of a class or classes with a different size or scope, and if there is a subsequent adverse verdict on the merits from which there is no successful appeal, or in
the event of a negotiated settlement of the litigation, the resulting liability could be material to the Company s financial condition or results of operations. The plaintiffs also seek punitive damages which, if awarded, could result in the
payment of additional amounts material to the Company s financial condition or results of operations. However, because of the uncertainty of the outcome of the appeal from the district court s certification decision, because of the
uncertainty of the balance of the proceedings contemplated by the district court, and because the Company s liability, if any, arising from the litigation, including the size of any damages award if plaintiffs are successful in the litigation
or any negotiated settlement, could vary widely, the Company cannot reasonably estimate the possible loss or range of loss that may arise from the litigation.
The Company is a defendant in a lawsuit that was filed by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission ( EEOC ) on August 24, 2001, in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of
Kentucky on behalf of Janice Smith and all other females who made application or transfer requests at the London, Kentucky, distribution center from 1998 to the present, and who were not hired or transferred into the warehouse positions for which
they applied. The complaint alleges that the Company based hiring decisions on gender in violation of Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act as amended. The EEOC can maintain this action as a class without certification. The EEOC seeks back pay and
front pay for those females not selected for hire or transfer during the relevant time period, plus compensatory and punitive damages and injunctive relief. The EEOC has asserted that the hiring practices in question resulted in a shortfall of 245
positions. The claims for compensatory and punitive damages are capped by statute at $300,000 per shortfall position. The amounts of back pay and front pay that are being sought have not been specified.
Hazardous Materials Investigations: On November 8, 2005, the Company received a grand jury subpoena from the United States Attorney s
Office for the Central District of California, seeking documents and information relating to the Company s receipt, transportation, handling, identification, recycling, treatment, storage and disposal of certain merchandise that constitutes
hazardous materials or hazardous waste. The Company has been informed by the U.S. Attorney s Office for the Central District of California that it is a target of a criminal investigation into potential violations of the Resource Conservation
and Recovery Act ( RCRA ), the Clean Water Act and the Hazardous Materials Transportation Statute. This U.S. Attorney s Office contends, among other things, that the use of Company trucks to transport certain returned merchandise from
the Company s stores to its return centers is prohibited by RCRA because those materials may be considered hazardous waste. The government alleges that, to comply with RCRA, the Company must ship from the store certain materials as
hazardous waste directly to a certified disposal facility using a certified hazardous waste carrier. The Company contends that the practice of transporting returned merchandise to its return centers for subsequent disposition, including
disposal by certified facilities, is compliant with applicable laws and regulations. While management cannot predict the ultimate outcome of this matter, management does not believe the outcome will have a material effect on the Company s
financial condition or results of operations.
Additionally, the U.S. Attorney s Office in the Northern District of California has
initiated its own investigation regarding the Company s handling of hazardous materials and hazardous waste and the Company has received administrative document requests from the California Department of Toxic Substances Control requesting
documents and information with respect to two of the Company s distribution facilities. Further, the Company also received a subpoena from the Los Angeles County District Attorney s Office for documents and administrative interrogatories