The
Company
and its subsidiaries are principally engaged in the continuing operations
of
retail stores located in all 50 states of the United States, Argentina, Brazil,
Canada, Puerto Rico and the United Kingdom, through joint ventures in China,
and
through majority-owned subsidiaries in Costa Rica, El Salvador, Guatemala,
Honduras and Nicaragua, Japan and Mexico. The Company identifies segments
based
on management responsibility within the United States and in total for
international units.
The
Wal-Mart
Stores segment includes the Company s supercenters, discount stores and
Neighborhood Markets in the United States as well as Walmart.com. The Sam s Club
segment includes the warehouse membership Clubs in the United States as well
as
samsclub.com. The International segment consists of the Company s operations
outside of the United States. The amounts under the caption Other in the
second table below are unallocated corporate overhead, including our real
estate
operations in the United States. For the periods prior to the Company s majority
ownership of Seiyu and CARHCO, the Company s portion of the results of our
unconsolidated minority interest in those entities was also included under
the
caption Other.
The
Company
measures the profit of its segments as segment operating income, which is
defined as income from continuing operations before net interest expense,
income
taxes and minority interest and excludes unallocated corporate overhead and
results of discontinued operations. Information on segments and the
reconciliation to income from continuing operations before income taxes,
minority interest and discontinued operations appears in the following
tables.
Net
sales by
operating segment were as follows (in millions):
Three
Months Ended
October
31,
Nine
Months Ended
October
31,
2006
2005
2006
2005
Wal-Mart
Stores
54,179
50,243
162,067
149,693
Sam s
Club
10,206
10,019
30,453
29,143
International
19,158
14,334
54,382
41,691
Total
net sales
83,543
74,596
246,902
220,527
Segment
operating income and the reconciliation to income from continuing operations
before income taxes, minority interest and discontinued operations are as
follows (in millions):
Three
Months Ended
October
31,
Nine
Months Ended
October
31,
2006
2005
2006
2005
Wal-Mart
Stores
3,639
3,312
11,780
10,610
Sam s
Club
356
342
1,076
1,008
International
997
844
2,747
2,360
Other
(527
(400
(1,538
(1,158
Operating
income
4,465
4,098
14,065
12,820
Interest
expense, net
(424
(350
(1,184
(855
Income
from continuing operations before income taxes, minority interest
and
discontinued operations
4,041
3,748
12,881
11,965
Goodwill
is
recorded on the condensed consolidated balance sheet in the operating segments
as follows (in millions):
October
31,
2006
October
31,
2005
January
31,
2006
International
12,952
10,074
11,792
Sam s
Club
305
305
305
Total
goodwill
13,257
10,379
12,097
The
change in
the International segment s goodwill since the third quarter of fiscal 2006 is
primarily the result of the acquisitions and consolidations of Seiyu, Sonae
and
CARHCO along with foreign exchange rate fluctuations.
NOTE
8. Comprehensive Income
Comprehensive
income is net income plus certain other items that are recorded directly
to
shareholders equity, which generally consist of currency translation and hedge
accounting adjustments. Comprehensive income was $2.3 billion and $2.1 billion
for the three months ended October 31, 2006 and 2005, respectively, and $8.1
billion and $6.4 billion for the nine months ended October 31, 2006 and 2005,
respectively.
NOTE
9. Common Stock Dividends
During
the
first quarter of fiscal 2007, the Company s Board of Directors approved an
increase in the Company s annual dividend to $0.67 per share. The annual
dividend is paid in four equal quarterly installments. Dividend payment dates
for fiscal 2007 are April 3, June 5, and September 5, 2006, and January 2,
2007
to holders of record on March 17, May 19, August 18 and December 15, 2006,
respectively. A $0.60 per share annual dividend was declared in the first
quarter of fiscal 2006 and paid in four equal quarterly
installments.
NOTE
10. Income Taxes
The
Company's
effective tax rate was 34.1% for the nine months ended October 31, 2006.
The
Company expects the fiscal 2007 annual effective tax rate to be approximately
34%. Significant factors that could impact the annual effective tax rate
include
management's assessment of certain tax matters, Work Opportunity Tax Credit
renewal legislation and the composition of taxable income between domestic
and
international operations.
In
determining the quarterly provision for income taxes, the Company uses an
estimated annual effective tax rate based on forecasted annual income and
permanent items, statutory tax rates and tax planning opportunities in the
various jurisdictions in which the Company operates. The impact of significant
discrete items is separately recognized in the quarter in which they
occur.
NOTE
11. Contingencies
The
Company
is involved in a number of legal proceedings. In accordance with Statement
of
Financial Accounting Standards No. 5, Accounting for Contingencies, the
Company has made accruals with respect to these matters, where appropriate,
which are reflected in the Company's condensed consolidated financial
statements. The Company may enter into discussions regarding settlement of
these
matters, and may enter into settlement agreements, if it believes settlement
is
in the best interests of the Company's shareholders. The matters, or groups
of
related matters, discussed below, if decided adversely to or settled by the
Company, individually or in the aggregate, may result in liability material
to
the Company's financial condition or results of operations.
The
Company
is a defendant in numerous cases containing class-action allegations in which
the plaintiffs are current and former hourly associates who allege that the
Company forced them to work off the clock or failed to provide work breaks, or
otherwise that they were not paid for work performed. The complaints generally
seek unspecified monetary damages, injunctive relief, or both. Class or
collective-action certification has yet to be addressed by the court in a
majority of these cases. Where it has been addressed, certification has been
denied in twelve of these cases; has been granted in whole or in part in
seven
of these cases; and has been conditionally granted for notice purposes only
in
two of these cases. In another five such cases, certification was denied
and the
case was then dismissed, and in one additional such case, certification was
granted and the case was then dismissed. The Company cannot reasonably
estimate the possible loss or range of loss which may arise from these
lawsuits.
One
of the
class-action lawsuits described above is
Savaglio v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.,
class-action lawsuit in which the plaintiffs allege that they were not provided
meal and rest breaks in accordance with California law, and seek monetary
damages and injunctive relief. A jury trial on the plaintiffs' claims for
monetary damages concluded on December 22, 2005. The jury returned a verdict
of
approximately $57 million in statutory penalties and $115 million in punitive
damages. Following a bench trial in June, the judge entered an order allowing
some, but not all, of the injunctive relief sought by the plaintiffs. The
Company believes it has substantial defenses to the claims at issue, and
intends to challenge the verdict in post-trial motions and, if necessary,
on
appeal.
In
another of
the class-action lawsuits described above,
Braun/Hummel v. Wal-Mart Stores,
a jury
trial was commenced on September 5, 2006, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
The
plaintiffs allege that the Company failed to pay class members for all hours
worked and prevented class members from taking their full meal and rest
breaks.
On
October 13, 2006, the jury awarded back-pay damages to the plaintiffs of
approximately $78 million on their claims for off-the-clock work and missed
rest
breaks. The jury found in favor of the Company on the plaintiffs meal-period
claims. The plaintiffs are now seeking an additional award of approximately
$62
million in statutory penalties, plus prejudgment interest and attorneys fees.
The
Company believes it has substantial defenses to the claims at issue, and
intends to challenge the verdict in post-trial motions and, if necessary,
on
appeal.
Another of
the
class-action lawsuits described above,
Salvas v. Wal-Mart Stores,
had
been scheduled to go to trial on October 2, 2006, before a jury in Cambridge,
Massachusetts. The plaintiffs alleged that the Company failed to pay class
members for all hours worked and prevented class members from taking their
full
meal and rest breaks, and were seeking approximately $90 million in back
pay,
plus statutory treble damages, interest and attorneys' fees. Shortly before
the scheduled trial date, however, the judge took the case off the trial
docket
in order to consider Wal-Mart s motion to decertify the class, and on November
7, 2006, the judge entered an order decertifying the class entirely. It is
anticipated that the judge will certify his ruling for an immediate appeal.
The
Company is not able to reasonably estimate the possible loss or range of
loss
which may result from this lawsuit.
putative
class action is pending in California challenging the methodology of payments
made under various associate incentive bonus plans. The court has made no
decision on class certification in this case. The Company cannot reasonably
estimate the possible loss or range of loss which may result from this
lawsuit.
The
Company
is currently a defendant in five putative class actions, which are pending
in
California, Michigan, New Mexico and Tennessee, brought on behalf of salaried
managers who challenge their exempt status under state and federal laws.
Conditional certification for notice purposes under the FLSA has been granted
in
one of these cases (Comer
v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.).
In
another, class certification has been denied (Sepulveda
v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.).
The
Company cannot reasonably estimate the possible loss or range of loss which
may
arise from these lawsuits.
The
Company
is a defendant in
Dukes v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.,
class-action lawsuit commenced in June 2001 and pending in the United States
District Court for the Northern District of California. The case was brought
on
behalf of all past and present female employees in all of the Company's retail
stores and warehouse clubs in the United States. The complaint alleges that
the
Company has engaged in a pattern and practice of discriminating against women
in
promotions, pay, training and job assignments. The complaint seeks, among
other
things, injunctive relief, front pay, back pay, punitive damages, and attorneys'
fees. Following a hearing on class certification on September 24, 2003, on
June
21, 2004, the District Court issued an order granting in part and denying
in
part the plaintiffs' motion for class certification. The class, which was
certified by the District Court for purposes of liability, injunctive and
declaratory relief, punitive damages, and lost pay, subject to certain
exceptions, includes all women employed at any Wal-Mart domestic retail store
at
any time since December 26, 1998, who have been or may be subjected to the
pay
and management track promotions policies and practices challenged by the
plaintiffs. The class as certified currently includes approximately 1.6 million
present and former female associates.
The
Company
believes that the District Court's ruling is incorrect. The United States
Court
of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has granted the Company's petition for
discretionary review of the ruling. The Court of Appeals heard oral argument
from counsel in the case on August 8, 2005. There is no indication at this
time
as to when a decision will be rendered. If the Company is not successful
in its
appeal of class certification, or an appellate court issues a ruling that
allows
for the certification of a class or classes with a different size or scope,
and
if there is a subsequent adverse verdict on the merits from which there is
no
successful appeal, or in the event of a negotiated settlement of the litigation,
the resulting liability could be material to the Company. The plaintiffs
also
seek punitive damages which, if awarded, could result in the payment of
additional amounts material to the Company. However, because of the uncertainty
of the outcome of the appeal from the District Court's certification decision,
because of the uncertainty of the balance of the proceedings contemplated
by the
District Court, and because the Company's liability, if any, arising from
the
litigation, including the size of any damages award if plaintiffs are successful
in the litigation or any negotiated settlement, could vary widely, the Company
cannot reasonably estimate the possible loss or range of loss which may arise
from the litigation.
The
Company
is a defendant in
Mauldin v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.,
class-action lawsuit that was filed on October 16, 2001, in the United States
District Court for the Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division. The
class
was certified on August 23, 2002. On September 30, 2003, the court denied
the
Company's motion to reconsider that ruling. The class is composed of female
Wal-Mart associates who were participants in the Associates Health and Welfare
Plan at any time from March 8, 2001, to the present and who were using
prescription contraceptives. The class seeks amendment of the Plan to include
coverage for prescription contraceptives, back pay for all members in the
form
of reimbursement of the cost of prescription contraceptives, pre-judgment
interest and attorneys' fees. The complaint alleges that the Company's Health
Plan violates Title VII's prohibition against gender discrimination in that
the
Health Plan's Reproductive Systems provision does not provide coverage for
prescription contraceptives. The Company cannot reasonably estimate the possible
loss or range of loss which may arise from this litigation.
The
Company
is a defendant in a lawsuit that was filed on August 24, 2001, in the United
States District Court for the Eastern District of Kentucky.
EEOC
(Janice Smith) v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.
is an
action brought by the EEOC on behalf of Janice Smith and all other females
who
made application or transfer requests at the London, Kentucky, distribution
center from 1995 to the present, and who were not hired or transferred into
the
warehouse positions for which they applied. The class seeks back pay for
those
females not selected for hire or transfer during the relevant time period.
The
class also seeks injunctive and prospective affirmative relief. The complaint
alleges that the Company based hiring decisions on gender in violation of
Title
VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act as amended. The EEOC can maintain this action
as a class without certification. The Company cannot reasonably estimate
the
possible loss or range of loss which may arise from this
litigation.
On
November
8, 2005, the Company received a grand jury subpoena from the United States
Attorney's Office for the Central District of California, seeking documents
and
information relating to the Company's receipt, transportation, handling,
identification, recycling, treatment, storage and disposal of certain
merchandise that constitutes hazardous materials or hazardous waste. The
Company
has been informed by the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Central District
of
California that it is a target of a criminal investigation into potential
violations of the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act ( RCRA ), the Clean
Water Act, and the Hazardous Materials Transportation Statute. This U.S.
Attorney's Office contends, among other things, that the use of Company trucks
to transport certain returned merchandise from the Company's stores to its
return centers is prohibited by RCRA because those materials may be considered
hazardous waste. The government alleges that, to comply with RCRA, the Company
must ship from the store certain materials as hazardous waste directly to a
certified disposal facility using a certified hazardous waste carrier. The
Company contends that the practice of transporting returned merchandise to
its
return centers for subsequent disposition, including disposal by certified
facilities, is compliant with applicable laws and regulations. The Company
cannot reasonably estimate the possible loss or range of loss which may arise
from this matter.
10
Additionally,
the U.S. Attorney's Office in the Northern District of California has initiated
its own investigation regarding the Company's handling of hazardous materials
and hazardous waste and the Company has received administrative document
requests from the California Department of Toxic Substances Control requesting
documents and information with respect to two of the Company's distribution
facilities. Further, the Company also received a subpoena from the Los Angeles
County District Attorney's Office for documents and administrative
interrogatories requesting information, among other things, regarding the
Company's handling of materials and hazardous waste. California state and
local
government authorities and the State of Nevada have also initiated
investigations into these matters. The Company is cooperating fully with
the
respective authorities. The Company cannot reasonably estimate the possible
loss
or range of loss which may arise from this matter.
NOTE
12. Recent Accounting Pronouncements
In
June 2006,
the Emerging Issues Task Force reached a consensus on Issue No. 06-3 ( EITF
06-3 ), Disclosure Requirements for Taxes Assessed by a Governmental Authority
on Revenue-Producing Transactions. The consensus allows an entity to choose
between two acceptable alternatives based on their accounting policies for
transactions in which the entity collects taxes on behalf of a governmental
authority, such as sales taxes. Under the gross method, taxes collected are
accounted for as a component of sales revenue with an offsetting expense.
Conversely, the net method allows a reduction to sales revenue. Entities
should
disclose the method selected pursuant to APB No. 22, Disclosure of Accounting
Policies. If such taxes are reported gross and are significant, entities should
disclose the amount of those taxes. The guidance should be applied to financial
reports through retrospective application for all periods presented, if amounts
are significant, for interim and annual reporting beginning February 1, 2007.
Historically, the Company has presented sales net of tax collected and will
disclose this policy in its future annual financial statements.
In
July 2006,
the Financial Accounting Standards Board ( FASB ) issued Interpretation No. 48,
Accounting for Uncertainty in Income Taxes ( FIN 48 ). FIN 48 clarifies the
accounting for income taxes, by prescribing a minimum recognition threshold
tax position is required to meet before being recognized in the financial
statements. FIN 48 also provides guidance on derecognition, measurement,
classification, interest and penalties, accounting in interim periods,
disclosure and transition. The Company will adopt FIN 48 on February 1, 2007,
as
required and for which the cumulative effect will be recorded in retained
earnings. The Company is currently evaluating the Interpretation to determine
the impact, if any, the Interpretation will have on its financial condition,
results of operations or liquidity.
In
September
2006, the FASB issued Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 157,
Fair
Value Measurements ( SFAS 157 ). This standard defines fair value, establishes
a framework for measuring fair value in generally accepted accounting principles
and expands disclosures about fair value measurements. The Company will adopt
SFAS 157 on February 1, 2008, as required. The adoption of SFAS 157 is not
expected to have a material impact on the Company s financial condition, results
of operations or liquidity.
In
September
2006, the FASB also issued Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No.
158
Employers Accounting for Defined Benefit Pension and Other Postretirement
Plans - an amendment of FASB Statements No. 87, 88, 106 and 132(R) ( SFAS
158 ). This standard requires recognition of the funded status of a benefit plan
in the statement of financial position. The Standard also requires recognition
in other comprehensive income certain gains and losses that arise during
the
period but are deferred under pension accounting rules, as well as modifies
the
timing of reporting and adds certain disclosures. The Company will adopt
the
funded status recognition and disclosure elements as of January 31, 2007,
and
measurement elements as of January 31, 2009, as required by SFAS 158. The
adoption of SFAS 158 is not expected to have a material impact on the Company s
financial condition, results of operations or liquidity.
In
September
2006, the Securities and Exchange Commission ( SEC ) issued Staff Accounting
Bulletin No. 108 Considering the Effects of Prior Year Misstatements when
Quantifying Misstatements in Current Year Financial Statements ( SAB
108 ),
in
which the Staff provides guidance on the consideration of the effects of
prior
year misstatements in quantifying current year misstatements for the purpose
of
assessing materiality.
The Company will adopt SAB 108 as of January 31, 2007, as required. The
cumulative effect, if any, of applying the provisions of SAB 108 will be
reported as an adjustment to retained earnings. The adoption of SAB 108 is
not
expected to have a material impact on the Company s financial condition, results
of operations or liquidity.
Item
2. Management s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of
Operations
This
discussion relates to Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. and its consolidated subsidiaries
(the Company ) and should be read in conjunction with our condensed
consolidated financial statements included under Part I, Item 1, of this
Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q, as well as our financial statements as of
January
31, 2006, and for the year then ended, and the related Management s Discussion
and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations both of which
are
contained in our Annual Report to Shareholders for the year ended January
31,
2006, which is included as an exhibit to our Annual Report on Form 10-K for
the
year ended January 31, 2006.
11
We
intend for
this discussion to provide the reader with information that will assist in
understanding our condensed consolidated financial statements, the changes
in
certain key items from period to period, and the primary factors that accounted
for those changes, as well as how certain accounting principles affect our
condensed consolidated financial statements. The discussion also provides
information about the financial results of the various segments of our business
to provide a better understanding of how those segments and their results
affect
the financial condition and results of operations of the Company as a
whole.
Throughout
this Management s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of
Operations, we discuss segment operating income and comparative store sales.
Segment operating income refers to income from continuing operations before
net
interest expense, income taxes and minority interest. Segment operating income
does not include unallocated corporate overhead or the results of discontinued
operations. Comparative store sales or comp sales is a measure which indicates
the performance of our existing stores by measuring the growth in sales for
such
stores for a particular period over the corresponding period in the prior
year.
Sales for stores are included in comparative store sales in the thirteenth
month
following their grand opening, expansion or relocation. Comparative store
sales
are also referred to as same-store sales by others within the retail industry.
The method of calculating comparative store sales varies across the retail
industry. As a result, our calculation of comparative store sales is not
necessarily comparable to similarly titled measures reported by other
companies.
Key
Items in the Third Quarter
Significant
financial items related to the third quarter of fiscal 2007
include:
Net
sales for the third quarter of fiscal 2007 increased 12.0% to $83.543
billion
from $74.596 billion in the third quarter of fiscal 2006.
Comparative
store sales in the United States
increased 1.2% for the quarter ended October 31, 2006. Comparative
store sales
at our Wal-Mart Stores segment increased 1.5% for the third quarter
of fiscal
2007, while Sam s Club s comparative store sales for the third quarter of
fiscal 2007 were flat, including a negative 1.8 percentage point impact
from
fuel sales.
Net
income for the current quarter increased 11.5% to $2.647 billion including
favorable after tax impact of $56 million for property insurance-related
gains
which were reported as reductions in operating expenses ($52 million
in our
Wal-Mart Stores segment and $4 million in our Sam s Club segment). In
addition, net income for the quarter ended October 31, 2005, included
three
items netting to an unfavorable after-tax impact of $80 million: approximately
$40 million of costs incurred as a result of hurricanes Katrina, Rita
and
Wilma; and in our Wal-Mart Stores segment, $69 million of expense related
to
product warranty programs, partially offset by $29 million of other
income
resulting from the VISA/MasterCard antitrust litigation
settlement.
Net
sales at our International segment increased 33.7% when compared with
the
third quarter of fiscal 2006. Third quarter fiscal 2007 sales in the
International segment include sales from the consolidation of The Seiyu,
Ltd.
( Seiyu ) and Central American Retail Holding Company ( CARHCO ) and the
acquisition of Sonae Distribui o Brasil S.A. ( Sonae ). These entities
contributed 18.6 percentage points to the increase in the International
segment net sales in the third quarter of fiscal
2007.
Total
assets increased 14.7% to $151.1 billion at
October 31, 2006 when compared to October 31, 2005. During the first
nine
months of fiscal 2007, we made $11.4 billion of capital
expenditures.
During
the third quarter of fiscal 2007, we closed on the dispositions of
our South
Korean and German operations. Each disposition has been accounted
for as
discontinued operations in our condensed consolidated financial statements
for
all periods presented. For further details of these transactions,
see Note 4
to our condensed consolidated financial
statements.
Acquisitions
and Discontinued Operations
As
discussed
in Notes 4 and 5 to our condensed consolidated financial statements, the
Company
has acquired or increased its ownership in several entities and disposed
of its
operations in South Korea and Germany since the third quarter of fiscal 2006.
As
a result, operations for Seiyu, Sonae and CARHCO are now consolidated as
majority-owned subsidiaries using December 31 fiscal year-ends. In addition,
the
operations in South Korea and Germany are now reported as discontinued
operations.
12
Results
of Operations
The
following
discussion of our Results of Operations is based on our continuing operations
and excludes any discussion of our discontinued operations of South Korea
and
Germany.
Quarter
ended October 31, 2006
The
Company
and each of its operating segments had net sales for the quarters ended October
31, 2006 and 2005 as follows (dollars in millions):
Quarter
ended
October
31, 2006
Quarter
ended
October
31, 2005
Net
sales
Percent
of
total
Net
sales
Percent
of
total
Percent
increase
Wal-Mart
Stores
54,179
64.9
50,243
67.4
7.8
Sam s
Club
10,206
12.2
10,019
13.4
1.9
International
19,158
22.9
14,334
19.2
33.7
Total
net sales
83,543
100.0
74,596
100.0
12.0
The
increase
in our net sales for the quarter ended October 31, 2006 resulted primarily
from
our expansion programs, acquisition activity, and a comparative store sales
increase of 1.2% in the United States.
The
increase
in the International segment s net sales as a percentage of total net sales is
largely due to the acquisitions and consolidations of Seiyu, CARHCO and
Sonae.
Additionally, the decrease in the Sam s Club segment s net sales as a percentage
of total net sales resulted from the more rapid development of new stores
in the
Wal-Mart Stores and International segments than the Sam s Club segment. The
decrease in Wal-Mart Stores segment s net sales as a percentage of total net
sales is due to lower positive comparative store sales for the third quarter
of
fiscal 2007 as compared to the prior year period and to the significant increase
in the International segment s net sales.
Our
total
gross profit as a percentage of sales (our gross margin ) increased from 23.2%
in the third quarter of fiscal 2006 to 23.7% during the third quarter of
fiscal
2007. The increase is primarily due to positive gross margin growth in the
International and Wal-Mart Stores segments.
Operating,
selling, general and administrative expenses ( operating expenses ) as a
percentage of net sales were 19.4% for the third quarter of fiscal 2007,
up from
18.7% in the corresponding period in fiscal 2006. The increase of operating
expenses as a percentage of net sales was primarily due to: the impact of
the
acquisitions and consolidations of Seiyu, CARHCO and Sonae;
higher
utility
costs across all segments; and higher maintenance and repair expenses of
the
Wal-Mart Stores segment.
Other
income,
net, in the third quarter of fiscal 2007 increased $123 million from the
third
quarter of fiscal 2006. The increase was due to other income from the newly
consolidated operations of the Seiyu and Sonae acquisitions, the continued