The
Company and its subsidiaries are principally engaged in the operation of retail
stores located in the United States, Argentina, Brazil, Canada, Germany, South
Korea, Puerto Rico and the United Kingdom, through joint ventures in China,
and
through a majority-owned subsidiary in Mexico. The Company identifies segments
based on management responsibility within the United States and in total for
international units.
The
Wal-Mart Stores segment includes the Company s Supercenters, Discount Stores and
Neighborhood Markets in the United States as well as Walmart.com. The SAM S CLUB
segment includes the warehouse membership Clubs in the United States as well
as
samsclub.com. The International segment consists of the Company s operations in
Argentina, Brazil, Canada, China, Germany, Mexico, South Korea, Puerto Rico
and
the United Kingdom. The amounts under the caption Other in the following table
are unallocated corporate overhead, including our real estate operations in
the
United States. The Company s portion of the results of our unconsolidated
minority interest in Seiyu and CARHCO are also included under the caption
Other.
The
Company measures the profit of its segments as segment operating income, which
is defined as income before net interest expense, income taxes and minority
interest. Information on segments and the reconciliation to income before income
taxes and minority interest appears in the following tables.
Net
sales
by operating segment were as follows (in millions):
Three
Months Ended
October
31,
Nine
Months Ended
October
31,
2005
2004
2005
2004
Wal-Mart
Stores
50,243
45,888
149,693
136,373
SAM S
CLUB
10,019
9,082
29,143
27,139
International
15,174
13,550
44,319
39,493
Total
net sales
75,436
68,520
223,155
203,005
Segment
operating income and the reconciliation to income before income taxes and
minority interest are as follows (in millions):
Three
Months Ended
October
31,
Nine
Months Ended
October
31,
2005
2004
2005
2004
Wal-Mart
Stores
3,312
3,115
10,610
9,921
SAM S
CLUB
342
306
1,008
925
International
797
698
2,214
2,009
Other
(402
(335
(1,163
(1,062
Operating
income
4,049
3,784
12,669
11,793
Interest
expense, net
349
241
851
689
Income
before income taxes and
minority interest
3,700
3,543
11,818
11,104
Goodwill
is recorded on the balance sheet in the operating segments as follows (in
millions):
October
31,
2005
October
31,
2004
January
31,
2005
International
$10,162
$9,886
$10,498
SAM S
CLUB
305
305
305
Total
goodwill
10,467
10,191
10,803
The
change in the International segment s goodwill since October 31, 2004, is
primarily the result of foreign exchange rate fluctuations and certain purchase
accounting and other adjustments.
NOTE
7. Comprehensive Income
Comprehensive
income is net income plus certain other items that are recorded directly to
shareholders equity, which generally consist of foreign currency translation
and hedge accounting. Comprehensive income was $2.1 billion and $2.5 billion
for
the three months ended October 31, 2005 and 2004, respectively, and $6.4 billion
and $7.6 billion for the nine months ended October 31, 2005 and 2004,
respectively.
NOTE
8. Common Stock Dividends
During
the first quarter of fiscal 2006, the Company s Board of Directors declared an
annual dividend of $0.60 per share on shares of the Company s common stock. The
fiscal 2006 dividend is payable in four equal quarterly installments on April
4,
June 6, and September 6, 2005 and January 3, 2006 to holders of record on March
18, May 20, August 19 and December 16, 2005, respectively. A $0.52 per share
annual dividend was declared in the first quarter of fiscal 2005 and paid in
four equal quarterly installments during fiscal 2005.
NOTE
9. Income Taxes
In
determining the quarterly provision for income taxes for fiscal 2006, the
Company uses an estimated annual effective tax rate of 34.6% based on expected
annual income, statutory tax rates and tax planning opportunities available
in
the various jurisdictions in which the Company operates. Significant discrete
items are separately recognized in the income tax provision in the quarter
in
which they occur. Currently, no repatriation of cash is planned under the
American Jobs Creation Act.
Favorable
discrete items recorded in the third quarter of fiscal 2006 caused the Company s
effective tax rate for the quarter to be 33.9%. With the impact of the discrete
items recorded in the nine months ended October 31, 2005, the full year
effective tax rate is currently forecasted to be approximately 33.9%, although
there may be volatility from discrete items occurring in the fourth quarter
of
fiscal 2006.
NOTE
10. Contingencies
The
Company is involved in a number of legal proceedings, which include consumer,
employment, tort and other litigation. In accordance with Statement of Financial
Accounting Standards No. 5, Accounting for Contingencies, the Company has made
accruals with respect to these lawsuits, where appropriate, which are reflected
in the Company s consolidated financial statements. The Company may enter into
discussions regarding settlement of these lawsuits, and may enter into
settlement agreements, if it believes settlement is in the best interests of
the
Company's shareholders. The lawsuits, or groups of related lawsuits, discussed
below, if decided adversely to or settled by the Company, individually or in
the
aggregate, may result in liability material to the Company's financial condition
or results of operations.
The
Company is a defendant in numerous cases containing class-action allegations
in
which the plaintiffs have brought claims under the Fair Labor Standards Act
( FLSA ), corresponding state statutes, or other laws. The plaintiffs in these
lawsuits are current and former hourly Associates who allege, among other
things, that the Company forced them to work off the clock, or failed to
provide work breaks, or otherwise claim they were not paid for work performed.
The complaints generally seek unspecified monetary damages, injunctive relief,
or both. Class certification has yet to be addressed in a majority of the cases.
Class certification has been denied or overturned in cases pending in Arizona,
Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Louisiana, Maryland, Michigan, Nevada,
New
Jersey, North Carolina, Ohio, Texas, West Virginia, and Wisconsin. Some or
all
of the requested classes have been certified in cases pending in California,
Colorado, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Missouri, New Mexico, Oregon, and
Washington. Conditional certifications for notice purposes under the FLSA have
been allowed in cases in Georgia, Michigan, and Texas. The Company cannot
estimate the possible loss or range of loss which may arise from these
lawsuits.
The
Company is a defendant in Savaglio
v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.,
class-action lawsuit in which the plaintiffs allege that they were not provided
meal and rest breaks in accordance with California law, and seek monetary
damages and injunctive relief. The trial began on September 6, 2005, in the
Superior Court of Alameda County, California. The Company believes that it
has
substantial factual and legal defenses to the allegations at issue. If a
judgment is entered against the Company on the claims asserted, however, it
is
estimated that the damages could be approximately $66 million, exclusive of
attorneys' fees, interest, and punitive damages, if any.
putative class action is pending in California challenging the methodology
of
payments made under various Associate incentive bonus plans, and a second
putative class action in California asserts that the Company has omitted to
include bonus payments in calculating Associates' regular rate of pay for
purposes of determining overtime. As to the first case (Cruz
v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.),
the
Company cannot estimate the possible loss or range of loss which may arise.
The
parties have entered into an agreement to settle the second case (Fries
v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.),
which
must be approved by the court in order to become effective. If approved by
the
court, the settlement will include all class members who do not opt out of
the
settlement class. The amount to be paid by Wal-Mart under the settlement will
not have a material impact on the Company's financial condition or results
of
operations.
The
Company is currently a defendant in four putative class actions brought on
behalf of assistant store managers who challenge their exempt status under
state
and federal laws, which are pending in California, Michigan, New Mexico, and
Tennessee. Conditional certification for notice purposes under FLSA has been
granted in one of these cases (Comer
v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.).
Otherwise, no determination has been made as to class certification in any
of
these cases. The Company cannot estimate the possible loss or range of loss
which may arise from these lawsuits.
The
Company is a defendant in
Dukes v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.,
class-action lawsuit commenced in June 2001 and pending in the United States
District Court for the Northern District of California. The case was brought
on
behalf of all past and present female employees in all of the Company's retail
stores and wholesale clubs in the United States. The complaint alleges that
the
Company has engaged in a pattern and practice of discriminating against women
in
promotions, pay, training and job assignments. The complaint seeks, among other
things, injunctive relief, front pay, back pay, punitive damages, and attorneys'
fees. Following a hearing on class certification on September 24, 2003, on
June
21, 2004, the District Court issued an order granting in part and denying in
part the plaintiffs' motion for class certification. The class, which was
certified by the District Court for purposes of liability, injunctive and
declaratory relief, punitive damages, and lost pay, subject to certain
exceptions, includes all women employed at any Wal-Mart domestic retail store
at
any time since December 26, 1998, who have been or may be subjected to the
pay
and management track promotions policies and practices challenged by the
plaintiffs. The class as certified currently includes approximately 1.6 million
present and former female Associates.
The
Company believes that the District Court's ruling is incorrect. The United
States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has granted the Company's petition
for discretionary review of the ruling. The Court of Appeals heard oral argument
from counsel in the case on August 8, 2005. There is no indication at this
time
as to when a decision will be rendered. If the Company is not successful in
its
appeal of class certification, or an appellate court issues a ruling that allows
for the certification of a class or classes with a different size or scope,
and
if there is a subsequent adverse verdict on the merits from which there is
no
successful appeal, or in the event of a negotiated settlement of the litigation,
the resulting liability could be material to the Company. The plaintiffs also
seek punitive damages which, if awarded, could result in the payment of
additional amounts material to the Company. However, because of the uncertainty
of the outcome of the appeal from the District Court's certification decision,
because of the uncertainty of the balance of the proceedings contemplated by
the
District Court, and because the Company's liability, if any, arising from the
litigation, including the size of any damages award if plaintiffs are successful
in the litigation or any negotiated settlement, could vary widely, the Company
cannot reasonably estimate the possible loss or range of loss which may arise
from the litigation.
The
Company is a defendant in
Mauldin v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.,
class-action lawsuit that was filed on October 16, 2001, in the United States
District Court for the Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division. The
class
was certified on August 23, 2002. On September 30, 2003, the court denied the
Company's motion to reconsider that ruling. The class is composed of female
Wal-Mart Associates who were participants in the Associates Health and Welfare
Plan at any time from March 8, 2001, to the present and who were using
prescription contraceptives. The class seeks amendment of the Plan to include
coverage for prescription contraceptives, back pay for all members in the form
of reimbursement of the cost of prescription contraceptives, pre-judgment
interest, and attorneys' fees. The complaint alleges that the Company's Health
Plan violates Title VII's prohibition against gender discrimination in that
the
Health Plan's Reproductive Systems provision does not provide coverage for
prescription contraceptives. The Company cannot estimate the possible loss
or
range of loss which may arise from this litigation.
The
Company is a defendant in a lawsuit that was filed on August 24, 2001, in the
United States District Court for the Eastern District of Kentucky.
EEOC
(Janice Smith) v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.
is an
action brought by the EEOC on behalf of Janice Smith and all other females
who
made application or transfer requests at the London, Kentucky, Distribution
Center from 1995 to the present, and who were not hired or transferred into
the
warehouse positions for which they applied. The class seeks back pay for those
females not selected for hire or transfer during the relevant time period.
The
class also seeks injunctive and prospective affirmative relief. The complaint
alleges that the Company based hiring decisions on gender in violation of Title
VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act as amended. The EEOC can maintain this action
as a class without certification. The Company cannot estimate the possible
loss
or range of loss which may arise from this litigation.
Item
2. Management s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of
Operations
This
discussion relates to Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. and its consolidated subsidiaries
(the Company ) and should be read in conjunction with our financial statements
included under Part I, Item 1, of this Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q and our
financial statements as of January 31, 2005, and the year then ended, and
Management s Discussion and Analysis of Results of Operations and Financial
Condition both contained in our Annual Report to Shareholders for the year
ended
January 31, 2005, which is included as an exhibit to our Annual Report on Form
10-K for the year ended January 31, 2005.
We
intend
for this discussion to provide the reader with information that will assist
in
understanding our financial statements, the changes in certain key items in
those financial statements from period to period, and the primary factors that
accounted for those changes, as well as how certain accounting principles affect
our financial statements. The discussion also provides information about the
financial results of the various segments of our business to provide a better
understanding of how those segments and their results affect the financial
condition and results of operations of the Company as a whole.
Throughout
this Management s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of
Operations, we discuss segment operating income and comparative store sales.
Segment operating income refers to income before net interest expense, income
taxes and minority interest. Segment operating income does not include
unallocated corporate overhead. Comparative store sales is a measure which
indicates the performance of our existing stores by measuring the growth in
sales for such stores for a particular period over the corresponding period
in
the prior year. We consider comparative store sales to be sales at stores that
were open as of February 1st of the prior fiscal year and have not been expanded
or relocated since that date. Stores that were expanded or relocated during
that
period are not included in the calculation. Comparative store sales is also
referred to as same-store sales by others within the retail industry. The
method of calculating comparative store sales varies across the retail industry.
As a result, our calculation of comparative store sales is not necessarily
comparable to similarly titled measures reported by other
companies.
Key
Items in the Third Quarter
Significant
financial items
related to the third quarter of fiscal 2006 include:
Net
sales for the third quarter of fiscal 2006 increased 10.1% to $75.4
billion from $68.5 billion in the third quarter of fiscal
2005.
Net
income increased 3.8% to $2.4 billion, or $0.57 per share, in the
third
quarter of fiscal 2006. Net income for the third quarter of fiscal
2006
included three items netting to an unfavorable after tax impact of
$80
million or $0.02 per share: approximately $40 million of costs incurred
as
a result of hurricanes Katrina, Rita and Wilma; and in our Wal-Mart
Stores
segment, $69 million of expense from adjustments to our product warranty
liabilities partially offset by $29 million of other income resulting
from
the Visa MasterCard antitrust litigation
settlement.
Comparative
store sales in the United States increased 3.8% for the quarter ended
October 31, 2005. Comparative store sales at our Wal-Mart Stores
and SAM S
CLUB segments increased 2.9% and 8.1%, respectively, in the third
quarter
of fiscal 2006. Fuel sales at SAM S CLUB contributed 2.8 percentage points
to that segment s comparative store sales
increase.
When
compared with the third quarter of fiscal 2005, our Wal-Mart Stores,
SAM S
CLUB and International segment operating income for the third quarter
of
fiscal 2006 increased 6.3%, 11.8% and 14.2%, respectively. Our SAM S CLUB
and International segments grew segment operating income faster than
segment net sales. Segment operating income at our Wal-Mart Stores
segment
grew slower than the growth in the segment s net sales primarily because
of the net impact of the hurricanes, our warranty liabilities adjustment
and our recovery in the Visa MasterCard
settlement.
Total
assets increased 10.7% to $131.8 billion at October 31, 2005 when
compared
with October 31, 2004. During the first nine months of fiscal 2006,
we
made $10.4 billion of capital
expenditures.
In
September 2005, we purchased a 33.3% interest in Central American
Retail
Holding Company ( CARHCO ), a retailer with more than 360 supermarkets and
other stores in five Central American countries. Also during the
quarter,
we announced our intention to purchase an additional interest in
The
Seiyu, Ltd. ( Seiyu ) on December 21, 2005, for an additional 67.5
billion investment (approximately $584 million using the exchange
rate in
effect at October 31, 2005). This transaction will make us the majority
owner of Seiyu and is subject to the approval of Seiyu s shareholders and
other conditions.
Results
of Operations
Quarter
ended October 31, 2005
The
Company and each of its operating segments had net sales for the quarters ended
October 31, 2005 and 2004 as follows (dollars in millions):
Quarter
ended
October
31, 2005
Quarter
ended
October
31, 2004
Net
sales
Percent
of
total
Net
sales
Percent
of
total
Percent
increase
Wal-Mart
Stores
50,243
66.6
45,888
66.9
9.5
SAM S
CLUB
10,019
13.3
9,082
13.3
10.3
International
15,174
20.1
13,550
19.8
12.0
Total
net sales
75,436
100.0
68,520
100.0
10.1
The
increase in our net sales for the quarter ended October 31, 2005 resulted from
our expansion programs and a comparative store sales increase of 3.8% in the
United States.
The
increase in the International segment s net sales as a percentage of total net
sales and the corresponding decrease in the Wal-Mart Stores segment s percentage
of total sales are largely due to the $464 million favorable impact of foreign
exchange on the International segment s net sales in the third quarter of fiscal
2006.
Our
total
gross profit as a percentage of sales (our gross margin ) decreased from 23.3%
in the third quarter of fiscal 2005 to 23.1% during the third quarter of fiscal
2006. This decrease was primarily the result of the previously mentioned
warranty liabilities adjustment and the impact of rising fuel and transportation
costs on our cost of sales.
Operating,
selling, general and administrative expenses ( operating expenses ) as a
percentage of net sales were 18.8% for the third quarter of fiscal 2006, down
from 18.9% in the corresponding period in fiscal 2005. This decrease was
primarily due to lower payroll costs during the third quarter of fiscal 2006.
The decrease was partially offset by costs associated with hurricanes Katrina,
Rita and Wilma and increases in utility and maintenance and repair
costs.
Other
income, net, as a percentage of net sales in the third quarter of fiscal 2006
remained relatively unchanged from the third quarter of fiscal 2005.
Interest,
net, increased as a percentage of net sales in the third quarter of fiscal
2006
when compared with the third quarter of fiscal 2005 as a result of higher
borrowing levels in fiscal 2006 and the impact of rising interest rates on
our
floating rate debt and commercial paper.
Our
effective income tax rate for the third quarter of fiscal 2006 was 33.9% which
compares with 34.1% in the third quarter of fiscal 2005. The effective tax
rate
for the third quarter of fiscal 2006 was less than the Company s underlying
estimated annual effective tax rate of 34.6% due to favorable discrete items
recognized in the quarter.
Net
income for the third quarter of fiscal 2006 increased 3.8% over the third
quarter of fiscal 2005.
10
Nine
months ended October 31, 2005
The
Company and each of its operating segments had net sales for the nine months
ended October 31, 2005 and 2004 as follows (in millions):
Nine
months ended
October
31, 2005
Nine
months ended
October
31, 2004
Net
sales
Percent
of
total
Net
sales
Percent
of
total
Percent
increase
Wal-Mart
Stores
149,693
67.1
136,373
67.2
9.8
SAM S
CLUB
29,143
13.1
27,139
13.4
7.4
International
44,319
19.8
39,493
19.4
12.2
Total
net sales
223,155
100.0
203,005
100.0
9.9
The
increase in our net sales resulted from our expansion programs and a comparative
store sales increase in the United States of 3.4% for the nine months ended
October 31, 2005.
The
increase in the International segment s net sales as a percentage of total net
sales is largely due to the $1.5 billion favorable impact of foreign exchange
on
the International segment s net sales in the nine months ended October 31, 2005.
Additionally, the decrease in the SAM S CLUB segment s net sales as a percentage
of total net sales resulted from the more rapid development of new stores in
the
Wal-Mart Stores and International segments than the SAM S CLUB
segment.
Gross
margin increased from 23.1% in the nine months ended October 31, 2004, to 23.2%
during the nine months ended October 31, 2005. Because the Wal-Mart Stores
segment and International segment net sales yield higher gross margins than
does
the SAM S CLUB segment, the change in percent of total net sales for the
Wal-Mart Stores and International segments had a favorable impact on the
Company s total gross margin. The increase in gross margin for the first nine
months of fiscal 2006 occurred despite the impact of the third quarter warranty
liabilities adjustment.
Operating
expenses as a percentage of net sales were 18.6% for the nine months ended
October 31, 2005, up from 18.4% in the nine months ended October 31, 2004.
This
increase was primarily due to increases in utility, maintenance and repair
costs
as a percentage of net sales partially offset by a decrease in payroll costs
as
a percentage of net sales.
Other
income, net, as a percentage of net sales in the first nine months of fiscal
2006 was relatively unchanged from the corresponding period in fiscal 2005.
Interest,
net, increased as a percentage of net sales in the nine months ended October
31,
2005, when compared with the nine months ended October 31, 2004, as a result
of
higher borrowing levels in fiscal 2006 and the impact of rising interest rates
on our floating rate debt and commercial paper.
Our
effective income tax rate for the nine months ended October 31, 2005, was 33.6%
which compares with 34.7% in the nine months ended October 31, 2004. The
effective tax rate for the nine months ended October 31, 2005, was less than
the
Company s underlying estimated annual effective tax rate of 34.6% due to
favorable discrete items recognized in that period, including non-cash tax
adjustments in the first quarter of $77 million resulting from the Company's
assessment of the favorable outcome of certain tax matters.
Net
income for the nine months ended October 31, 2005, increased 7.6% over the
nine
months ended October 31, 2004.
11
Wal-Mart
Stores Segment
Quarter
ended October 31, 2005
Quarter
ended
October
31,
Segment
net
sales
(in
millions)
Segment
net
sales
increase
from
prior
fiscal
year
third
quarter
Segment
operating
income
(in
millions)
Segment
operating
income
increase
from
prior fiscal
year
third
quarter
Segment
operating
income
as a
percentage
of
segment
net
sales
2005
$ 50,243
9.5%
$ 3,312
6.3%
6.6%
2004
$ 45,888
8.3%
$ 3,115
5.0%
6.8%
The
third
quarter fiscal 2006 net sales increase for the Wal-Mart Stores segment resulted
from our continued expansion activities within the segment and sales increases
in comparable stores. Expansion since October 31, 2004 has consisted of the
opening of 27 Discount Stores, 20 Neighborhood Markets and 87 Supercenters.
Additionally, 156 Supercenters have been expanded, relocated or converted from
existing Discount Stores since October 31, 2004. The comparative store sales
increase for the segment was 2.9% for the third quarter of fiscal 2006.
For
the
segment, operating income as a percentage of segment net sales declined due
to a
decrease in gross margin, which was partially offset by improvements in both
operating expenses and other income as a percentage of net sales. The decrease
in gross margin for the quarter occurred primarily due to rising fuel and
transportation costs and the unfavorable impact of an adjustment to our product
warranty liabilities. Additionally, gross margin decreased due to the impact
of
food sales increasing at a faster rate than the sales of general merchandise
and
specialty areas. Food sales typically generate lower gross margins than general
merchandise or specialty sales. Our
specialty area includes portions of the business that require specific product
knowledge or individualized service such as our Tire & Lube Express,
pharmacies, vision centers and one hour photo. Operating expenses as a
percentage of segment net sales decreased 0.09%, primarily as a result of lower
payroll and accident costs, offset by higher utility costs. We recorded the
impact of the Visa MasterCard antitrust litigation settlement in other income
which benefited segment operating income in the third quarter of fiscal
2006.
We
anticipate that high fuel costs and fuel surcharges will continue to exert
pressure on our gross margin. Additionally, we anticipate that the impact of
higher fuel costs on our customers will continue to place pressure on our
Wal-Mart Stores segment s net sales.
Nine
months ended October 31, 2005
Nine
months ended
October
31,
Segment
net
sales
(in
millions)
Segment
net
sales
increase
from
prior
fiscal
year
period