UNITED STATES
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
FORM 10-Q
(Mark One)
QUARTERLY REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
For the quarterly period ended March 31, 2020
or
TRANSITION REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
For the transition period from to
Commission file number 1-442
THE BOEING COMPANY
(Exact name of registrant as specified in its charter)
Delaware
91-0425694
(State or other jurisdiction of
incorporation or organization)
(I.R.S. Employer Identification No.)
100 N. Riverside Plaza,
Chicago,
IL
60606-1596
(Address of principal executive offices)
(Zip Code)
(312)
544-2000
(Registrant s telephone number, including area code)
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant (1) has filed all reports required to be filed by Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 during the preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to file such reports), and (2) has been subject to such filing requirements for the past 90 days. Yes No
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant has submitted electronically every Interactive Data File required to be submitted pursuant to Rule 405 of Regulation S-T ( 232.405/ of this chapter) during the preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to submit such files). Yes No
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a large accelerated filer, an accelerated filer, a non-accelerated filer, a smaller reporting company, or an emerging growth company. See the definitions of large accelerated filer, accelerated filer, smaller reporting company, and "emerging growth company" in Rule 12b-2 of the Exchange Act. (Check one):
Large Accelerated Filer
Accelerated filer
Non-accelerated filer
Smaller reporting company
Emerging growth company
If an emerging growth company, indicate by check mark if the registrant has elected not to use the extended transition period for complying with any new or revised financial accounting standards provided pursuant to Section 13(a) of the Exchange Act.
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a shell company (as defined in Rule 12b-2 of the Exchange Act).
Yes No
Securities registered pursuant to Section 12(b) of the Act:
Title of each class
Trading Symbol(s)
Name of each exchange on which registered
Common Stock, $5.00 Par Value
BA
New York Stock Exchange
As of April 22, 2020, there were 564,325,344 shares of common stock, $5.00 par value, issued and outstanding.
THE BOEING COMPANY
FORM 10-Q
For the Quarter Ended March 31, 2020
INDEX
Part I. Financial Information (Unaudited)
Page
Item 1.
Financial Statements
Condensed Consolidated Statements of Operations
Condensed Consolidated Statements of Comprehensive Income
Condensed Consolidated Statements of Financial Position
Condensed Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows
Condensed Consolidated Statements of Equity
Summary of Business Segment Data
Note 1 - Basis of Presentation
Note 2 - Acquisitions and Joint Ventures
Note 3 - Goodwill and Acquired Intangibles
Note 4 - Earnings Per Share
Note 5 - Income Taxes
11
Note 6 - Allowance for Losses on Financial Assets
11
Note 7 - Inventories
11
Note 8 - Contracts with Customers
12
Note 9 - Customer Financing
13
Note 10 - Investments
15
Note 11 - Commitments & Contingencies
15
Note 12 - Arrangements with Off-Balance Sheet Risk
20
Note 13 - Debt
21
Note 14 - Postretirement Plans
21
Note 15 - Share-Based Compensation and Other Comprehensive Arrangements
21
Note 16 - Shareholders' Equity
22
Note 17 - Derivative Financial Instruments
23
Note 18 - Fair Value Measurements
24
Note 19 - Legal Proceedings
26
Note 20 - Segment and Revenue Information
26
Report of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm
30
Forward-Looking Statements
31
Item 2.
Management s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations
33
Consolidated Results of Operations and Financial Condition
33
Commercial Airplanes
39
Defense, Space & Security
42
Global Services
44
Boeing Capital
45
Liquidity and Capital Resources
46
Off-Balance Sheet Arrangements
47
Contingent Obligations
47
Non-GAAP Measures
48
Item 3.
Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk
49
Item 4.
Controls and Procedures
50
Part II. Other Information
Item 1.
Legal Proceedings
51
Item 1A.
Risk Factors
51
Item 2.
Unregistered Sales of Equity Securities and Use of Proceeds
53
Item 3.
Defaults Upon Senior Securities
53
Item 4.
Mine Safety Disclosures
53
Item 5.
Other Information
53
Item 6.
Exhibits
54
Signature
55
Table of Contents
Part I. Financial Information
Item 1. Financial Statements
The Boeing Company and Subsidiaries
Condensed Consolidated Statements of Operations
(Unaudited)
(Dollars in millions, except per share data)
Three months ended March 31
2020
2019
Sales of products
$14,191
$20,225
Sales of services
2,717
2,692
Total revenues
16,908
22,917
Cost of products
(14,713
(16,238
Cost of services
(2,043
(2,389
Boeing Capital interest expense
(12
(18
Total costs and expenses
(16,768
(18,645
140
4,272
(Loss)/income from operating investments, net
(2
20
General and administrative expense
(873
(1,184
Research and development expense, net
(672
(866
Gain on dispositions, net
54
108
(Loss)/earnings from operations
(1,353
2,350
Other income, net
112
106
Interest and debt expense
(262
(123
(Loss)/earnings before income taxes
(1,503
2,333
Income tax benefit/(expense)
862
(184
Net (loss)/earnings
(641
2,149
Less: net loss attributable to noncontrolling interest
(13
Net (loss)/earnings attributable to Boeing Shareholders
($628
$2,149
Basic (loss)/earnings per share
($1.11
$3.79
Diluted (loss)/earnings per share
($1.11
$3.75
Weighted average diluted shares (millions)
565.9
572.4
See Notes to the Condensed Consolidated Financial Statements.
Table of Contents
The Boeing Company and Subsidiaries
Condensed Consolidated Statements of Comprehensive Income
(Unaudited)
(Dollars in millions)
Three months ended March 31
2020
2019
Net (loss)/earnings
($641
$2,149
Other comprehensive (loss)/income, net of tax:
Currency translation adjustments
(77
Unrealized gain on certain investments, net of tax of $0 and $0
Unrealized (loss)/gain on derivative instruments:
Unrealized (loss)/gain arising during period, net of tax of $77 and ($3)
(275
11
Reclassification adjustment for losses/(gains) included in net earnings, net of tax of ($1) and $1
(2
Total unrealized (loss)/gain on derivative instruments, net of tax
(273
Defined benefit pension plans and other postretirement benefits:
Amortization of prior service credits included in net periodic pension cost, net of tax of $6 and $6
(23
(23
Amortization of actuarial losses included in net periodic pension cost, net of tax of ($53) and ($32)
193
118
Pension and postretirement cost related to our equity method investments, net of tax of $0 and ($2)
Total defined benefit pension plans and other postretirement benefits, net of tax
170
103
Other comprehensive (loss)/income, net of tax
(180
114
Comprehensive (loss)/income, net of tax
(821
2,263
Less: Comprehensive loss related to noncontrolling interest
(13
Comprehensive (loss)/income attributable to Boeing Shareholders, net of tax
($808
$2,263
See Notes to the Condensed Consolidated Financial Statements.
Table of Contents
The Boeing Company and Subsidiaries
Condensed Consolidated Statements of Financial Position
(Unaudited)
(Dollars in millions, except per share data)
March 31
2020
December 31
2019
Assets
Cash and cash equivalents
$15,039
$9,485
Short-term and other investments
488
545
Accounts receivable, net
3,211
3,266
Unbilled receivables, net
9,365
9,043
Current portion of customer financing, net
149
162
Inventories
80,020
76,622
Other current assets, net
2,739
3,106
Total current assets
111,011
102,229
Customer financing, net
2,116
2,136
Property, plant and equipment, net of accumulated depreciation of $19,591 and $19,342
12,405
12,502
Goodwill
8,057
8,060
Acquired intangible assets, net
3,256
3,338
Deferred income taxes
678
683
Investments
1,124
1,092
Other assets, net of accumulated amortization of $611 and $580
4,428
3,585
Total assets
$143,075
$133,625
Liabilities and equity
Accounts payable
$14,963
$15,553
Accrued liabilities
21,483
22,868
Advances and progress billings
52,883
51,551
Short-term debt and current portion of long-term debt
5,173
7,340
Total current liabilities
94,502
97,312
Deferred income taxes
336
413
Accrued retiree health care
4,483
4,540
Accrued pension plan liability, net
15,962
16,276
Other long-term liabilities
3,398
3,422
Long-term debt
33,754
19,962
Total liabilities
152,435
141,925
Shareholders equity:
Common stock, par value $5.00 1,200,000,000 shares authorized; 1,012,261,159 shares issued
5,061
5,061
Additional paid-in capital
6,595
6,745
Treasury stock, at cost - 447,947,807 and 449,352,405 shares
(54,842
(54,914
Retained earnings
49,854
50,644
Accumulated other comprehensive loss
(16,333
(16,153
Total shareholders equity
(9,665
(8,617
Noncontrolling interests
305
317
Total equity
(9,360
(8,300
Total liabilities and equity
$143,075
$133,625
See Notes to the Condensed Consolidated Financial Statements.
Table of Contents
The Boeing Company and Subsidiaries
Condensed Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows
(Unaudited)
(Dollars in millions)
Three months ended March 31
2020
2019
Cash flows operating activities:
Net (loss)/earnings
($641
$2,149
Adjustments to reconcile net earnings to net cash provided by operating activities:
Non-cash items
Share-based plans expense
55
47
Depreciation and amortization
556
521
Investment/asset impairment charges, net
26
34
Customer financing valuation adjustments
249
Gain on dispositions, net
(54
(108
Other charges and credits, net
97
74
Changes in assets and liabilities
Accounts receivable
(54
206
Unbilled receivables
(402
(183
Advances and progress billings
1,337
1,857
Inventories
(2,973
(2,725
Other current assets
328
164
Accounts payable
(1,030
1,624
Accrued liabilities
(583
(919
Income taxes receivable, payable and deferred
(892
116
Other long-term liabilities
(69
(281
Pension and other postretirement plans
(179
(188
Customer financing, net
23
152
Other
153
(1
Net cash (used)/provided by operating activities
(4,302
2,788
Cash flows investing activities:
Property, plant and equipment additions
(428
(501
Property, plant and equipment reductions
58
110
Acquisitions, net of cash acquired
(276
Contributions to investments
(244
(457
Proceeds from investments
227
366
Other
(9
Net cash used by investing activities
(379
(767
Cash flows financing activities:
New borrowings
17,433
5,237
Debt repayments
(5,854
(4,374
Contributions from noncontrolling interests
Stock options exercised
21
42
Employee taxes on certain share-based payment arrangements
(162
(233
Common shares repurchased
(2,341
Dividends paid
(1,158
(1,161
Net cash provided/(used) by financing activities
10,280
(2,823
Effect of exchange rate changes on cash and cash equivalents, including restricted
(47
Net increase/(decrease) in cash & cash equivalents, including restricted
5,552
(801
Cash & cash equivalents, including restricted, at beginning of year
9,571
7,813
Cash & cash equivalents, including restricted, at end of period
15,123
7,012
Less restricted cash & cash equivalents, included in Investments
84
176
Cash and cash equivalents at end of period
$15,039
$6,836
See Notes to the Condensed Consolidated Financial Statements.
Table of Contents
The Boeing Company and Subsidiaries
Condensed Consolidated Statements of Equity
For the three months ended March 31, 2020 and 2019
(Unaudited)
Boeing shareholders
(Dollars in millions, except per share data)
Common
Stock
Additional
Paid-In
Capital
Treasury Stock
Retained
Earnings
Accumulated Other Comprehensive Loss
Non-
controlling
Interests
Total
Balance at January 1, 2019
$5,061
$6,768
($52,348
$55,941
($15,083
$71
$410
Net earnings
2,149
2,149
Other comprehensive income, net of tax of ($30)
114
114
Share-based compensation and related dividend equivalents
47
47
Treasury shares issued for stock options exercised, net
(36
77
41
Treasury shares issued for other share-based plans, net
(206
(18
(224
Common shares repurchased
(2,341
(2,341
Changes in noncontrolling interests
36
36
Balance at March 31, 2019
$5,061
$6,573
($54,630
$58,090
($14,969
$107
$232
Balance at December 31, 2019
$5,061
$6,745
($54,914
$50,644
($16,153
$317
($8,300
Impact of ASU 2016-13
(162
(162
Balance at January 1, 2020
$5,061
$6,745
($54,914
$50,482
($16,153
$317
($8,462
Net loss
(628
(13
(641
Other comprehensive income, net of tax of $29
(180
(180
Share-based compensation and related dividend equivalents
55
55
Treasury shares issued for stock options exercised, net
(16
36
20
Treasury shares issued for other share-based plans, net
(189
36
(153
Changes in noncontrolling interests
Balance at March 31, 2020
$5,061
$6,595
($54,842
$49,854
($16,333
$305
($9,360
See Notes to the Condensed Consolidated Financial Statements.
Table of Contents
The Boeing Company and Subsidiaries
Notes to Condensed Consolidated Financial Statements
Summary of Business Segment Data
(Unaudited)
(Dollars in millions)
Three months ended March 31
2020
2019
Revenues:
Commercial Airplanes
$6,205
$11,822
Defense, Space & Security
6,042
6,587
Global Services
4,628
4,619
Boeing Capital
65
66
Unallocated items, eliminations and other
(32
(177
Total revenues
$16,908
$22,917
(Loss)/earnings from operations:
Commercial Airplanes
($2,068
$1,173
Defense, Space & Security
(191
852
Global Services
708
653
Boeing Capital
24
20
Segment operating (loss)/profit
(1,527
2,698
Unallocated items, eliminations and other
(173
(712
FAS/CAS service cost adjustment
347
364
(Loss)/earnings from operations
(1,353
2,350
Other income, net
112
106
Interest and debt expense
(262
(123
(Loss)/earnings before income taxes
(1,503
2,333
Income tax benefit/(expense)
862
(184
Net (loss)/earnings
(641
2,149
Less: Net loss attributable to noncontrolling interest
(13
Net (loss)/earnings attributable to Boeing Shareholders
($628
$2,149
This information is an integral part of the Notes to the Condensed Consolidated Financial Statements. See Note 20 for further segment results.
Table of Contents
The Boeing Company and Subsidiaries
Notes to the Condensed Consolidated Financial Statements
(Dollars in millions, except otherwise stated)
(Unaudited)
Note 1 Basis of Presentation
The condensed consolidated interim financial statements included in this report have been prepared by management of The Boeing Company (herein referred to as Boeing , the Company , we , us , or our ). In the opinion of management, all adjustments (consisting of normal recurring accruals) necessary for a fair presentation are reflected in the interim financial statements. The results of operations for the period ended March 31, 2020 are not necessarily indicative of the operating results for the full year. The interim financial statements should be read in conjunction with the audited Consolidated Financial Statements, including the notes thereto, included in our 2019 Annual Report on Form 10-K. Certain amounts in prior periods have been adjusted to conform with the current year presentation.
Liquidity Matters
The global outbreak of COVID-19 coupled with the ongoing grounding of the 737 MAX airplane is having a significant adverse impact on our business and is expected to significantly reduce revenue, earnings and operating cash flow in future quarters. The aerospace industry is facing an unprecedented shock to demand for air travel which creates a tremendous challenge for our customers, our business and the entire aerospace manufacturing and services sector. We currently expect it will take 2-3 years for travel to return to 2019 levels and a few years beyond that for the industry to return to long-term trend growth. There is significant uncertainty with respect to when commercial air traffic levels will begin to recover, and whether and at what point capacity will return to and/or exceed pre-COVID-19 levels.
During the first quarter of 2020, net cash used by operating activities was $4.3 billion and we expect negative operating cash flows in future quarters until deliveries resume and ramp up. At March 31, 2020, cash and short-term investments totaled $15.5 billion. Our debt balance totaled $38.9 billion at March 31, 2020 up from $27.3 billion at December 31, 2019. The major credit rating agencies downgraded our short term and long term credit ratings during the first quarter of 2020 and there is risk for further downgrades. At March 31, 2020, debt includes $4.7 billion of commercial paper down from $6.1 billion at December 31, 2019. Commercial paper at March 31, 2020 includes $2.3 billion, $0.5 billion and $1.9 billion maturing in the second, third and fourth quarter of 2020, respectively. In the current environment, we may have limited future access to the commercial paper market. In addition, we have term notes of $350 million maturing in the fourth quarter of 2020. At March 31, 2020, trade payables included $4.5 billion payable to suppliers who have elected to participate in supply chain financing programs compared with $5.2 billion at December 31, 2019. In future quarters, access to supply chain financing could be curtailed if our credit ratings are further downgraded. At March 31, 2020 and December 31, 2019 we had $9.6 billion of unused borrowing capacity on revolving credit agreements. We anticipate that these credit lines will primarily serve as back-up liquidity to support our general corporate borrowing needs. We plan to negotiate extending it in the fourth quarter of 2020 when $3.2 billion of the $9.6 billion comes up for renewal.
We are taking a number of actions to improve liquidity. We had paused our open market share repurchase program since last year, and in March 2020 our Board of Directors terminated its prior authorization to repurchase shares of the Company s outstanding common stock. In March 2020, we also suspended the declaration and/or payment of dividends until further notice. We have also taken actions to reduce production rates in our commercial business to reflect the COVID-19 impact on the industry. We have furloughed certain employees and recently announced a voluntary employee layoff program which we plan to implement in the second quarter of 2020. We are also planning to further reduce our workforce by the end of this year through a combination of attrition and involuntary layoffs, as necessary. We are reducing discretionary spending as well as reducing or deferring research and development and capital expenditures. We are also working with our customers and supply chain to accelerate receipts and conserve cash. For example, the United States Department of Defense has taken steps to work with its industry partners to increase liquidity in the form of increased progress payment rates and reductions in withholds among other initiatives. We are also deferring certain tax payments pursuant to the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act.
Table of Contents
Notwithstanding the actions described above to improve liquidity, we expect negative operating cash flows in 2020 and will need to obtain additional financing to fund our operations and obligations. The COVID-19 crisis is constraining the credit and capital markets and our ability to access credit markets may be reduced. We believe, based on an assessment of current market conditions, that there are sufficient sources of liquidity available to us that will enable us to fund our ongoing operations. Sources we are evaluating include funding options from the public and private markets, as well as from the U.S. government via the U.S. Treasury and various Federal Reserve programs. We currently plan to raise additional liquidity in the second quarter, which, together with other actions we are taking to improve liquidity, we expect will provide us with sufficient liquidity to fund our operations and obligations.
Based on our current best estimates of market demand, planned production rates, timing of cash receipts and expenditures, our ability to successfully implement actions to improve liquidity as well our ability to access additional liquidity, we believe it is probable that we will be able to fund our operations for the foreseeable future.
Standards Issued and Implemented
In the first quarter of 2020, we adopted ASU 2016-13, Financial Instruments - Credit Losses (Topic 326): Measurement of Credit Losses on Financial Instruments (ASU 2016-13), using a modified retrospective method, which resulted in the recognition of allowances for credit losses on our Condensed Consolidated Statement of Financial Position as of January 1, 2020 and a $162 cumulative-effect adjustment to retained earnings to align our credit loss methodology with the new standard. The standard replaces the incurred loss impairment methodology under Topic 310 with a methodology that reflects expected credit losses and requires the use of a forward-looking expected credit loss model for accounts receivables, loans, and certain other financial assets. See Note 6 and 9 for additional disclosures.
In the first quarter of 2020, we also adopted ASU 2017-04, Intangibles-Goodwill and Other (Topic 350): Simplifying the Test for Goodwill Impairment (ASU 2017-04). See Note 3 for additional disclosures.
Significant Accounting Policies - Update
Our significant accounting policies are described in "Note 1: Summary of Significant Accounting Policies" of our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2019. Our updated significant accounting policies described below reflect the impact of adopting Topic 326.
Allowances for losses on certain financial assets
We establish allowances for credit losses on accounts receivable, unbilled receivables, customer financing receivables, and certain other financial assets. The adequacy of these allowances are assessed quarterly through consideration of factors including, but not limited to, customer credit ratings, bankruptcy filings, published or estimated credit default rates, age of the receivable, expected loss rates and collateral exposures. We assign internal credit ratings for all customers and determine the creditworthiness of each customer based upon publicly available information and information obtained directly from our customers. Our rating categories are comparable to those used by major credit rating agencies.
Use of Estimates
The preparation of financial statements in conformity with U.S. generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) requires management to make estimates and assumptions that affect the reported amounts of assets and liabilities and disclosure of contingent assets and liabilities at the date of the financial statements and the reported amounts of revenues and expenses during the reporting period. We believe that the accounting estimates and assumptions made by management are appropriate given the increased uncertainties surrounding the severity and duration of the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic, however actual results could differ materially from those estimates.
Changes in estimated revenues, cost of sales and the related effect on operating income are recognized using a cumulative catch-up adjustment which recognizes in the current period the cumulative effect of the changes on current and prior periods based on a long-term contract s percentage-of-completion. When the
Table of Contents
current estimates of total sales and costs for a long-term contract indicate a loss, a provision for the entire reach-forward loss on the long-term contract is recognized.
Net cumulative catch-up adjustments to prior years' revenue and earnings, including certain reach-forward losses, across all long-term contracts were as follows:
(In millions - except per share amounts)
Three months ended March 31
2020
2019
(Decrease)/increase to Revenue
($434
$160
(Decrease)/increase to (Loss)/earnings from operations
($839
$147
(Decrease)/increase to Diluted EPS
($0.63
$0.24
Note 2 Acquisitions and Joint Ventures
Strategic Partnership with Embraer
During the first quarter of 2019, we entered into definitive transaction documents with respect to a strategic partnership with Embraer S.A. (Embraer). The partnership contemplated the establishment of joint ventures that included the commercial aircraft and services operations of Embraer, of which we were expected to acquire an 80 percent ownership stake for $4,200, as well as a joint venture to promote and develop new markets for the C-390 Millennium.
The transaction documents permitted either party to terminate the proposed partnership beginning on April 24, 2020, provided that certain closing conditions were not met. Based on Embraer s failure to satisfy required closing conditions, Boeing has exercised its contractual termination right. We would have been required to pay a termination fee of $100 had the transaction been terminated due to a failure to obtain antitrust approvals. Because the transaction was terminated due to a failure by Embraer to meet other closing conditions, we do not expect to be required to pay a termination fee in connection with the termination of the transaction. Boeing and Embraer will arbitrate their dispute over Boeing s termination of the agreement.
Note 3 Goodwill and Acquired Intangibles
In the first quarter of 2020, we also adopted ASU 2017-04, Intangibles-Goodwill and Other (Topic 350): Simplifying the Test for Goodwill Impairment. The standard simplifies the quantitative impairment test from a two-step process to a one-step process. The quantitative test is performed by comparing the carrying value of net assets to the estimated fair value of the related operations. If the fair value is determined to be less than carrying value, the shortfall up to the carrying value of the goodwill represents the amount of goodwill impairment. The standard continues to permit a company to test goodwill for impairment by performing a qualitative assessment or using the quantitative test.
The COVID-19 pandemic was a triggering event for testing whether goodwill recorded by our Commercial Airplanes and Commercial Services reporting units is impaired. At March 31, 2020, Commercial Airplanes has $1,313 of goodwill and Commercial Services has $3,052. We performed a qualitative assessment and determined it is not more likely than not that the fair values of our Commercial Airplane and Commercial Services reporting units were less than their carrying values as of March 31, 2020. We will continue to monitor the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic in future quarters. Changes in our forecasts or further decreases in the value of our common stock could cause book values to exceed fair values which may result in goodwill impairment charges in future periods.
Note 4 Earnings Per Share
Basic and diluted earnings per share are computed using the two-class method, which is an earnings allocation method that determines earnings per share for common shares and participating securities. The undistributed earnings are allocated between common shares and participating securities as if all earnings
Table of Contents
had been distributed during the period. Participating securities and common shares have equal rights to undistributed earnings.
Basic earnings per share is calculated by taking net earnings, less earnings available to participating securities, divided by the basic weighted average common shares outstanding.
Diluted earnings per share is calculated by taking net earnings, less earnings available to participating securities, divided by the diluted weighted average common shares outstanding.
The elements used in the computation of basic and diluted earnings per share were as follows: