United States was the target of severe terrorist
attacks that involved the use of U.S. commercial aircraft manufactured by the
Company. These attacks resulted in a significant loss of life and property,
and caused major disruptions in business activities and in the U.S. economy
overall.
To address the widespread impact of the attacks, the Emerging Issues Task
Force (EITF) released Issue No. 01-10, "Accounting for the Impact of
Terrorist Attacks of September 11, 2001." This issue specifically prohibits
treating costs and losses resulting from the events of September 11, 2001,
as extraordinary items; however, it observes that any portion of these
costs and losses deemed to be unusual or infrequently occurring should be
presented as a separate line item in income from continuing operations.
For the quarter ended September 30, 2001, the Company recorded an initial
charge of $100 in the caption 'Special charges due to events of
September 11, 2001'. This charge related to certain severance costs that
were probable and estimable, and are expected to be principally incurred
by year-end 2001. The employment reductions resulted from the decrease in
aircraft demand, which directly related to the attacks of
September 11, 2001.
The Company has undertaken an assessment of other losses and costs it
expects to incur in relation to the attacks. These costs are not yet
reasonably estimable due to the period of time required for resolution.
The Company expects many of these costs to become estimable within the
next three to twelve months, and will continue to be recognized as a
separate component of earnings from operations entitled 'Special charges
due to events of September 11, 2001'. These losses and costs are expected
to relate principally to additional employee severance and out-placement,
vendor termination, valuation of receivables, impairment of assets,
inventory impairment, guarantees extended by the Company and certain
other items.
Note 2 - Accounting for the Impact of the September 11, 2001, Terrorist
Attacks (continued)
As stated in Note 1 of the Company's 2000 Annual Report, cost of sales for
the commercial aircraft programs is determined under the program method of
accounting based on estimated average total cost and revenue for the current
program quantity. The estimated program average costs and revenues are
reviewed and reassessed quarterly. The Company expects that the events of
September 11, 2001, will result in a decrease in deliveries and demand for
the commercial aircraft programs that will impact the cost and revenue
estimates for the applicable program quantities. The Company expects to
reflect the estimate adjustments attributable to the events of
September 11, 2001, as they become reasonably estimable over the next five
quarters.
Note 3 - Acquisitions
On October 6, 2000, the Company acquired the Hughes Electronics Corporation
(Hughes) space and communications and related businesses. The acquisition
was accounted for under the purchase method, by which the purchase price was
allocated to the net assets acquired based on preliminary estimates of their
fair values. The original purchase price was $3,849, initial goodwill was
valued at $740 and the other intangible assets were valued at $631. During
the period from acquisition to the third quarter of 2001, the Company
completed its assessment of the net assets acquired and goodwill was increased
to a balance of $2,205. The majority of the goodwill adjustments relate to
claims submitted to Hughes for resolution as contractual purchase price
contingencies. The Company anticipates finalizing the Hughes purchase price
allocation during 2002, at the conclusion of arbitration procedures related
to these contingencies. Other adjustments were recorded to reflect finalization
of fair value assessments for the net assets acquired and the impact of the
Company's accounting policies on acquired balances.
The purchase price and related allocation, reflecting adjustments made through
September 30, 2001, were as follows:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Working capital $ (940)
Property, plant and equipment 875
Prepaid pension assets 626
Other assets 54
Goodwill 2,205
Other acquired intangibles 647
In-process research and development 500
Retiree health care (118)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Purchase price $3,849
===============================================================================
Note 3 - Acquisitions (continued)
In July 2001, the Financial Accounting Standards Board issued two new
pronouncements: Statement of Financial Accounting Standard (SFAS) No. 141,
"Business Combinations," and SFAS No. 142, "Goodwill and Other Intangible
Assets." The Company is required to adopt SFAS No. 141 for all business
combinations completed after June 30, 2001. This standard requires that
business combinations initiated after June 30, 2001, be accounted for under
the purchase method. Goodwill and other intangible assets that resulted from
business combinations before July 1, 2001, must be reclassified to conform to
the requirements of SFAS No. 142, as of the statement adoption date.
Additionally, the Company will be required to adopt SFAS No. 142 at the
beginning of 2002 for all goodwill and other intangible assets recognized
in the Company's statement of financial position as of January 1, 2002.
This statement changes the accounting for goodwill from an amortization method
to an impairment-only approach. Amortization of goodwill, including goodwill
recorded in past business combinations, will cease upon adoption of this
standard. The standard is immediately applicable for any goodwill acquired
after June 30, 2001. Goodwill and intangible assets acquired after
June 30, 2001, should be tested for impairment and written down and charged
to results of operations only in the periods in which the recorded value of
goodwill and certain intangibles is more than its fair value. The Company is
evaluating the impact of the adoption of this standard and has not yet
determined the effect, if any, that this statement will have on its financial
position and results of operations.
Note 4 - Earnings per Share
The weighted average number of shares outstanding (in millions) used to compute
earnings per share are as follows:
Nine months ended Three months ended
September 30 September 30
---------------- ------------------
2001 2000 2001 2000
---- ---- ---- ----
Basic shares 821.7 864.4 804.4 858.2
Diluted shares 837.4 873.5 814.7 873.3
Basic earnings per share are calculated based on the weighted average number of
shares outstanding, excluding treasury shares and the outstanding shares held by
the ShareValue Trust. Diluted earnings per share are calculated based on that
same number of shares plus additional dilutive shares representing stock
distributable under stock option and stock unit plans computed using the
treasury stock method, plus contingently issuable shares from other share-based
plans on an as-if converted basis.
Note 5 - Income Taxes
The effective tax rate of 21.1% for the first nine months of 2001 is principally
due to a one-time benefit of $343 reflecting a settlement with the Internal
Revenue Service (IRS) relating to research credit claims on McDonnell Douglas
Corporation fixed-price government contracts applicable to the 1986-1992
federal income tax returns.
Note 5 - Income Taxes (continued)
Absent this settlement, the effective tax rate for the first nine months
would have been 30.6%. The 30.6% effective tax rate differs from the federal
statutory rate of 35% due to Foreign Sales Corporation (FSC) tax benefits,
extra-territorial income exclusion, tax credits, state income taxes and the
non-deductibility of certain goodwill, primarily the goodwill associated with
the acquisition of Rockwell International Corporation in 1996. Income tax
payments, net of refunds and settlements, were $747 and $362 for the nine
months ended September 30, 2001 and 2000. Payments for the nine months ended
September 30, 2001, included approximately $900 due principally to the
closeout of contracts accounted for under the completed contract method for
tax purposes.
In December 1996, The Boeing Company filed suit in the U.S. District Court for
the Western District of Washington for the refund of over $400 in federal income
taxes and related interest. The suit challenged the IRS method of allocating
research and development costs for the purpose of determining tax incentive
benefits on export sales through the Company's Domestic International Sales
Corporation (DISC) and its Foreign Sales Corporation for the years 1979
through 1987. In September 1998, the District Court granted the Company's
motion for summary judgment. The U.S. Department of Justice appealed this
decision. On August 2, 2001, The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth
Circuit reversed the District Court's summary judgment. The Company has fully
provided for any potential earnings impact that may result from this decision.
The Company has filed a petition for rehearing with the Ninth Circuit Court
of Appeals.
Note 6 - Accounts Receivable
Accounts receivable consisted of the following:
September 30 December 31
2001 2000
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
U.S. Government contracts $2,427 $2,693
Other 2,377 2,235
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
$4,804 $4,928
===============================================================================
Note 7 - Inventories
Inventories consisted of the following:
September 30 December 31
2001 2000
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Commercial aircraft programs and
long-term contracts in progress $ 20,362 $ 19,399
Commercial spare parts, general
stock materials and other 2,018 1,972
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
22,380 21,371
Less advances and progress billings (14,604) (14,577)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
$ 7,776 $ 6,794
===============================================================================
Note 7 - Inventories (continued)
Inventory costs at September 30, 2001, included unamortized tooling of $889 and
$351 relating to the 777 and Next Generation 737 programs, and excess deferred
production costs of $930 and $509 relating to the 777 and Next Generation 737
programs. There were no significant deferred production costs or unamortized
tooling associated with the 717 program.
Note 8 - Customer and Commercial Financing
Customer and commercial financing consisted of the following:
September 30 December 31
2001 2000
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Aircraft financing
Notes receivable $1,070 $ 593
Investment in sales-type/financing leases 2,393 1,119
Operating lease equipment, at cost,
less accumulated depreciation of $320 and $305 3,303 3,098
Commercial equipment financing
Notes receivable 931 915
Investment in sales-type/financing leases 879 697
Operating lease equipment, at cost,
less accumulated depreciation of $90 and $95 803 710
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Less valuation allowance (161) (173)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
$9,218 $6,959
===============================================================================
Financing for aircraft is collateralized by security in the related asset, and
historically the Company has not experienced difficulty in accessing such
collateral when necessary. Commercial equipment financing also includes amounts
attributable to regional aircraft, principally with fewer than 80 seats.
The change in the valuation allowance for the first nine months of 2001
consisted of the following:
Valuation
Allowance
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Beginning balance - December 31, 2000 $(173)
Charged to costs and expenses (15)
Reduction in customer and commercial financing assets 27
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ending balance - September 30, 2001 $(161)
===============================================================================
10
Note 9 - Accounts Payable and Other Liabilities
Accounts payable and other liabilities consisted of the following:
September 30 December 31
2001 2000
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Accounts payable $ 5,285 $ 5,040
Accrued compensation and employee benefit costs 3,043 2,938
Lease and other deposits 357 731
Dividends payable 149
Other 3,844 3,121
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
$12,529 $11,979
===============================================================================
Note 10 - Deferred Lease Income
The Company entered into an agreement with the United Kingdom Royal Air Force
(UKRAF) to lease four C-17 transport aircraft, delivered during the second and
third quarters of 2001. The lease term is seven years, at the end of which the
UKRAF has the right to purchase the aircraft for a stipulated value, continue
the lease for two additional years, or return the aircraft. Concurrent with the
negotiation of this lease, the Company and the UKRAF arranged to assign the
contractual lease payments to an independent financial institution. The Company
received proceeds from the financial institution in consideration of the
assignment of the future lease receivables from the UKRAF. The assignment of
lease receivables is non-recourse to the Company. The proceeds represent the
present value of the assigned total lease receivables discounted at a rate of
6.6%. The C-17 deliveries are accounted for as operating leases.
10
11
Note 11 - Debt
Short- and long-term debt consisted of the following:
September 30 December 31
2001 2000
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Non-recourse debt and notes
Enhanced Equipment Trust Certificates $ 635 $ -
9.9% - 14.3% notes due through 2010 67 74
Unsecured debentures and notes
$174, 8 3/8% due Feb. 15, 2001 174
$49, 7.565% due Mar. 30, 2002 48 49
$120, 9.25% due Apr. 1, 2002 120 120
$300, 6 3/4% due Sep. 15, 2002 299 299
$300, 6.35% due Jun. 15, 2003 300 300
$200, 7 7/8% due Feb. 15, 2005 205 206
$300, 6 5/8% due Jun. 1, 2005 295 294
$250, 6.875% due Nov. 1, 2006 249 248
$175, 8 1/10% due Nov. 15, 2006 175 175
$350, 9.75% due Apr. 1, 2012 348 348
$400, 8 3/4% due Aug. 15, 2021 398 398
$300, 7.95% due Aug. 15, 2024 300 300
$250, 7 1/4% due Jun. 15, 2025 247 247
$250, 8 3/4% due Sep. 15, 2031 248 248
$175, 8 5/8% due Nov. 15, 2031 173 173
$300, 6 5/8% due Feb. 15, 2038 300 300
$100, 7.50% due Aug. 15, 2042 100 100
$175, 7 7/8% due Apr. 15, 2043 173 173
$125, 6 7/8% due Oct. 15, 2043 125 125
Senior debt securities
2.7% - 9.2% due through 2012 3,359 1,547
Senior medium-term notes
2.7% - 7.6% due through 2017 2,159 1,775
Subordinated medium-term notes
6.0% - 8.3% due through 2012 20 25
Capital lease obligations due through 2021 312 315
Commercial paper 862 651
Other notes 136 135
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
$11,653 $8,799
===============================================================================
Of the debt balances reported above, $6,303 and $4,318 are attributed to
Boeing Capital Corporation (BCC), a wholly owned subsidiary of the Company,
for September 30, 2001, and December 31, 2000.
The Company has $3,000 currently available under credit line agreements with a
group of commercial banks. The Company has complied with the restrictive
covenants contained in various debt agreements. Total debt interest, including
amounts capitalized, was $489 and $388 for the nine months ended
September 30, 2001 and 2000. Interest payments were $478 and $459 for the same
respective periods.
On February 16, 2001, BCC filed a public shelf registration of $5,000 with the
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). From this $5,000 shelf, BCC received
proceeds on March 8, 2001, from the issuance of $750 in 6.10% senior notes due
2011. On May 10, 2001, BCC received proceeds from the issuance of $1,000 in
5.65% senior notes due 2006.
11
12
Note 11 - Debt (continued)
On May 24, 2001, American Airlines issued Enhanced Equipment Trust Certificates
(EETC), and the Company through BCC received proceeds attributable to 32 MD-83
aircraft owned by BCC and on lease to American Airlines. The effective interest
rates of these non-recourse borrowings range from 6.82% to 7.69%.
Short-term debt and the current portion of long-term debt as of
September 30, 2001, consisted of the following: $869 of senior debt securities,
senior medium-term notes, subordinated medium-term notes, $862 of commercial
paper, $420 of unsecured debentures and notes, $37 of capital lease
obligations, $68 of non-recourse debt and notes, and $91 of other notes.
12
13
Note 12 - Shareholders' Equity
Changes in shareholders' equity for the nine month periods ended September 30,
2001 and 2000, consisted of the following:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2001 2000
(Shares in thousands) Shares Amount Shares Amount
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Common stock
Beginning balance - January 1 1,011,870 $ 5,059 1,011,870 $ 5,059
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ending balance - September 30 1,011,870 $ 5,059 1,011,870 $ 5,059
===============================================================================
Additional paid-in capital
Beginning balance - January 1 $ 2,693 $ 1,684
Share-based compensation 279 193
Treasury shares issued for stock plans, net (66) (174)
Tax benefit related to stock plans 13 21
ShareValue Trust market value adjustment (1,262) 833
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ending balance - September 30 $ 1,657 $ 2,557
===============================================================================
Treasury stock
Beginning balance - January 1 136,385 $(6,221) 102,357 $(4,161)
Treasury shares issued for
stock plans, net (2,698) 122 (3,976) 153
Treasury shares acquired 40,734 (2,417) 19,295 (894)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ending balance - September 30 174,421 $(8,516) 117,676 $(4,902)
===============================================================================
Retained earnings
Beginning balance - January 1 $12,090 $10,487
Net earnings 2,727 1,647
Cash dividends declared (291) (252)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ending balance - September 30 $14,526 $11,882
===============================================================================
Accumulated other comprehensive income
Beginning balance - January 1 $ (2) $ 6
Losses on certain investments, net of tax (6) (11)
Losses on derivative instruments, net of tax (67)
Foreign currency translation adjustment (13) 5
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ending balance - September 30 $ (88) $ 0
===============================================================================
Unearned compensation
Beginning balance - January 1 $ (7) $ (12)
Amortization and forfeitures 3 3
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ending balance - September 30 $ (4) $ (9)
===============================================================================
ShareValue Trust
Beginning balance - January 1 39,156 $(2,592) 38,696 $(1,601)
Shares acquired from dividend reinvestment,
net of fees 356 380
Market value adjustment 1,262 (833)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ending balance - September 30 39,512 $(1,330) 39,076 $(2,434)
===============================================================================
13
14
Note 12 - Shareholders' Equity (continued)
For the nine months ended September 30, 2001 and 2000, comprehensive income and
net earnings differed only by the changes in accumulated other comprehensive
income shown above.
Note 13 - Share-Based Compensation
Share-based plans expense consisted of the following:
Nine months ended Three months ended
September 30 September 30
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2001 2000 2001 2000
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Performance shares $168 $ 91 $60 $33
ShareValue Trust 54 54 18 18
Stock options, other 57 48 20 15
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
$279 $193 $98 $66
===============================================================================
Note 14 - General and Administrative Expense
The Company has issued 7,477,518 stock units as of September 30, 2001, that
are convertible to either stock or a cash equivalent, of which 6,549,986 are
vested, and the remainder vest with employee service. These stock units
principally represent a method of deferring employee compensation by which a
liability is established based upon the current stock price. An expense or
reduction in expense is recognized associated with the change in that
liability balance and is recorded against general and administrative expense.
For the nine months ended September 30, 2001, general and administrative
expense related to deferred stock compensation was decreased by $198.
Note 15 - Derivatives and Hedging Activities
As of January 1, 2001, the Company adopted SFAS No. 133, "Accounting for
Derivative Instruments and Hedging Activities," as amended. This standard
requires that all derivative instruments, such as interest rate swap contracts
and other derivative contracts, be recognized in the financial statements and
measured at fair value regardless of the purpose or intent for holding them.
Changes in the fair value of derivative financial instruments are either
recognized periodically in income or shareholders' equity (as a component of
accumulated other comprehensive income), depending on whether the derivative
is being used to hedge changes in fair value or cash flows. The adoption of
SFAS No. 133 resulted in a transition gain of $1 on the consolidated
statements of operations shown under the caption 'Cumulative effect of
accounting changes, net', and a loss of $11 (net of tax of $7) recorded to
accumulated other comprehensive income.
14
15
Note 15 - Derivatives and Hedging Activities (continued)
Use of Derivative Financial Instruments
The Company uses derivative financial instruments principally to manage the
risk that changes in interest rates will affect either the fair value of its
debt obligations or the amount of its future interest payments and to manage
currency and price risk associated with forecasted transactions. On a limited
basis, the Company enters into derivative instruments that are not eligible
for hedge accounting under SFAS No. 133. The following is a summary of the
Company's risk management strategies and the effect of these strategies on
the consolidated financial statements.
Interest Rate Risk Management
The Company uses interest rate swap contracts to adjust the amount of total
debt that is subject to variable and fixed interest rates. Pursuant to SFAS
No. 133, the Company accounts for its interest rate swap contracts
differently depending upon whether the contract receives hedge accounting
treatment and upon the nature of the exposure being hedged. Interest rate
swap contracts are entered into with a number of major financial institutions
in order to minimize counterparty credit risk.
Interest rate swap contracts under which the Company agrees to pay variable
rates of interest are generally designated as hedges of changes in the fair
value of the Company's fixed-rate debt obligations. At September 30, 2001,
the Company held eleven interest rate swaps that are accounted for as fair
value hedges. During the quarter ended September 30, 2001, the Company had
no terminated interest rate swaps and entered into no additional interest
rate swaps that are accounted for as fair value hedges.
Interest rate swap contracts under which the Company agrees to pay fixed
rates of interest are generally designated as hedges of changes in the
amount of future cash flows associated with the Company's interest payments
on variable-rate debt obligations. At September 30, 2001, the Company held
two interest rate swaps that are accounted for as cash flow hedges. During
the quarter ended September 30, 2001, the Company had no terminated interest
rate swaps and entered into one additional interest rate swap that is
accounted for as a cash flow hedge.
As of September 30, 2001, interest rate swaps were reflected at a fair value
of $110 in other assets and $21 in other liabilities. Related amounts were
reflected in accumulated other comprehensive income of $10 ($7 after tax),
underlying long-term senior debt of $92 and net other expense of $2. During
the next twelve months, the Company expects to reclassify to expense $3 from
the amount recorded in accumulated other comprehensive income and recognize
income of $11 related to the basis adjustment of certain underlying liabilities.
The Company also entered into forward-starting interest rate swap agreements
to effectively lock in the cost of funding a firmly committed lease for which
payment terms are fixed in advance of funding. This hedge relationship mitigates
the changes in fair value of the hedged portion of the firm commitment caused by
changes in interest rates. The interest rate swap during the commitment period
does not match that of the firmly committed lease payments as a result of the
forward-starting period. Therefore, in addition to identifying the specific
firmly committed cash flows being hedged, it is necessary to specify that only a
percentage thereof is being hedged during the commitment period.
15
16
Note 15 - Derivatives and Hedging Activities (continued)
This hedge ratio is updated periodically during the commitment period and, as
necessary, the forward-starting swap is redesignated prospectively as a hedge
of a new percentage of the identified firmly committed cash flows. At the end
of each quarter, the cumulative change in fair value of the forward-starting
swap is compared to that of the hedged portion of the lease commitment. Any
net changes in fair value of the hedged portion of the firm commitment and the
interest rate swap are reported in earnings as ineffectiveness. For the nine
months ended September 30, 2001, total ineffectiveness of $1 in income
resulted from firm commitment income of $15 offset by the interest rate swap
expense of $14.
Commodity Derivatives
The Company uses commodity derivatives such as fixed-price purchase
commitments to hedge against potentially unfavorable price changes for items
used in production.
On June 29, 2001, the Derivatives Implementation Group, in support of the
Financial Accounting Standards Board, issued Statement 133 Implementation
Issue C15, "Scope Exceptions: Normal Purchases and Normal Sales Exception
for Option-Type Contracts and Forward Contracts in Electricity." This
Implementation Issue concluded that the normal purchases and normal sales
exceptions as described in SFAS No. 133, applied to electricity contracts
only to the extent that the power purchaser is an entity engaged in selling
electricity to retail or wholesale customers. The effective date of this
implementation guidance for the Company was July 1, 2001.
The Company entered into certain commitments to purchase electricity at fixed
prices over a three-year period. As a result of Implementation Issue C15, these
commitments are deemed to be derivatives and are stated at fair value on the
statement of financial position. These derivatives qualify for cash flow hedge
treatment, with the initial valuation resulting in an unrecognized loss in
accumulated other comprehensive income of $84 (net of tax of $49). For the
three month period ended September 30, 2001, these derivatives resulted in
expense of $12. During the next twelve months, the Company expects to
reclassify to expense $22 from the amount recorded in accumulated other
comprehensive income attributable to these derivatives.
Foreign Currency Exchange Derivatives
The Company has foreign currency forward contracts that were entered into to
hedge receipt and expenditure commitments made in foreign currencies. As of
September 30, 2001, the notional amount of foreign currency forward contracts
accounted for as cash flow hedges was $362. These hedges are carried at market
value, resulting in $34 recorded in other assets and $10 recorded in other
liabilities, offset by a net gain in accumulated other comprehensive income
($15 net of tax).
Derivative Financial Instruments Not Receiving Hedge Treatment
The Company also holds other interest rate swaps and interest exchange
agreements. Economically, the intent of these interest rate swaps is to
"hedge" the exposure created by the interest exchange agreements.
16
17
Note 15 - Derivatives and Hedging Activities (continued)
However, because the exposure being hedged is a derivative instrument, this
relationship does not qualify for hedge accounting under SFAS No. 133. As a
result, changes in fair value of both instruments are immediately recognized
in income. For the nine months ended September 30, 2001, these interest rate
swaps resulted in expense of $14 and the interest exchange agreements
resulted in income of $12.
The Company uses derivatives in the form of convertible debt and warrants
in certain transactions to enhance the income potential in financing
transactions. As of September 30, 2001, the conversion feature of the
convertible debt and warrants were reflected at a fair value of $6 in other
assets. These were initially recorded together based on their fair values as
a discount to notes receivable of $20. The remaining portion of the
conversion feature of the convertible debt and warrants had a decrease
in fair value, resulting in $2 recorded as a reduction in other
income for the nine months ended September 30, 2001.
At September 30, 2001, the Company has foreign currency forward contracts
with a notional value of $200 that were not accounted for as hedges and
carried at market value, resulting in $34 recorded in other liabilities.
The Company realized a pretax loss of $11 attributable to these forward
contracts during the nine months ended September 30, 2001.
Other derivatives held by the Company include a forward-starting interest
rate swap that is not accounted for as a hedge, and as of September 30, 2001,
other assets included $18 as a result of marking to market this interest rate
swap. Accumulated other comprehensive income included a gain of $9 (net of
tax of $5) attributable to this swap due to the transition adjustment
resulting from implementation of SFAS No. 133, as amended. This transition
adjustment is amortized to other income over a period of 13 years.
The Company believes that it is unlikely that any of its counterparties
will be unable to perform under the terms of derivative financial instruments.
Note 16 - Contingencies
Various legal proceedings, claims and investigations related to products,
contracts and other matters are pending against the Company. Most
significant legal proceedings are related to matters covered by insurance.
Major contingencies are discussed below.
The Company is subject to U.S. Government investigations of its
practices from which civil, criminal or administrative proceedings
could result. Such proceedings could involve claims by the Government
for fines, penalties, compensatory and treble damages, restitution and/or
forfeitures. Under government regulations, a company, or one or more
of its operating divisions or subdivisions, can also be suspended or
debarred from government contracts, or lose its export privileges,
based on the results of investigations. The Company believes, based
upon all available information, that the outcome of any such government
disputes and investigations will not have a material adverse effect on
its financial position or continuing operations.
17
18
Note 16 - Contingencies (continued)
In 1991, the U.S. Navy notified McDonnell Douglas (now a subsidiary of
the Company) and General Dynamics Corporation (the "Team") that it was
terminating for default the Team's contract for development and initial
production of the A-12 aircraft. The Team filed a legal action to contest
the Navy's default termination, to assert its rights to convert the
termination to one for "the convenience of the Government," and to obtain
payment for work done and costs incurred on the A-12 contract but not paid
to date. As of September 30, 2001, inventories included approximately $582
of recorded costs on the A-12 contract, against which the Company has
established a loss provision of $350. The amount of the provision, which was
established in 1990, was based on McDonnell Douglas's belief, supported by
an opinion of outside counsel, that the termination for default would be
converted to a termination for convenience, and that the upper range of
possible loss on termination for convenience was $350.
On August 31, 2001, the U.S. Court of Federal Claims issued a decision after
trial upholding the Government's default termination of the A-12 contract on
the ground that the Team could not meet the revised contract schedule
unilaterally imposed by the Government after the Government had waived the
original schedule. The court did not, however, enter a judgment for the
Government on its claim that the Team be required, as a consequence of the
alleged default, to repay progress payments that had not been liquidated by
deliveries at the time of termination. These unliquidated progress payments
total $1,350. On October 4, 2001, the court confirmed that it would not be
entering judgment in favor of the Government in the amount of these
unliquidated progress payments. This is the latest decision relating to
long-running litigation resulting from the A-12 contract termination in 1991,
and follows an earlier trial court decision in favor of the contractors and
reversal of that initial decision on appeal.
The Company believes, supported by an opinion of outside counsel, that the
trial court's rulings with respect to the enforceability of the unilateral
schedule and the termination for default are contrary to law and fact. The
Company believes the decision raises valid issues for appeal and intends to
pursue its right to the appeal.
If, contrary to the Company's belief, the decision of the trial court on
termination were sustained on appeal, the Company would incur an additional
loss of approximately $275, consisting principally of remaining inventory
costs and adjustments. And if, contrary to the Company's belief, the appeals
court further held that a money judgment should be entered against the Team
in the amount of the unliquidated progress payments, the Team would be
required to pay the Government $1,350 plus statutory interest from February
1991 (currently totaling approximately $900). Under this outcome, the
Company would be obligated to pay one half of these amounts. The additional
loss to the Company would total approximately $1,400 in pretax charges,
consisting principally of the repayment obligations and the remaining
inventory costs and adjustments.
The Company believes that the loss provision established by McDonnell
Douglas in 1990 continues to provide adequately for the reasonably possible
reduction in value of A-12 net contracts in process as of September 30, 2001.
Final resolution of the A-12 litigation will depend upon the outcome of
further proceedings or possible negotiations with the Government.
18
19
Note 16 - Contingencies (continued)
On October 31, 1997, a federal securities lawsuit was filed against the
Company in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington,
in Seattle. The lawsuit names as defendants the Company and three of its
then executive officers. Additional lawsuits of a similar nature have been
filed in the same court. These lawsuits were consolidated on
February 24, 1998. The lawsuits generally allege that the defendants
desired to keep the Company's share price as high as possible in order to
ensure that the McDonnell Douglas shareholders would approve the merger
and, in the case of the individual defendants, to benefit directly from
the sale of Boeing stock during the period from April 7, 1997 through
October 22, 1997. By order dated May 1, 2000, the Court certified two
subclasses of plaintiffs in the action: a. all persons or entities who
purchased Boeing stock or call options or who sold put options during the
period from July 21, 1997 through October 22, 1997, and b. all persons or
entities who purchased McDonnell Douglas stock on or after April 7, 1997,
and who held such stock until it converted to Boeing stock pursuant to the
merger. The plaintiffs sought compensatory damages and treble damages. On
September 17, 2001, the Company reached agreement with class counsel to
settle the lawsuit for $92.5. The settlement will have no effect on the
Company's earnings, cash flow or financial position, as it is within
insurance limits. The settlement is conditioned on notice to the class
members and Court approval, which is expected to occur in 2002.
On October 19, 1999, an indictment was returned by a federal grand jury
sitting in the District of Columbia charging that McDonnell Douglas
Corporation (MDC), a wholly owned subsidiary of the Company, and MDC's
Douglas Aircraft Company division, conspired to and made false statements
and concealed material facts on export license applications and in
connection with export licenses, and possessed and sold machine tools
in violation of the Export Administration Act. The indictment also charged
one employee with participation in the alleged conspiracy. The indictment
has since been dismissed as against this employee. That dismissal was
affirmed by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit on May 8, 2001.
The indictment relates to the sale and export to China in 1993-1995 of
surplus, used machine tools sold by Douglas Aircraft Company to China
National Aero-Technology Import and Export Corporation for use in
connection with the MD-80/90 commercial aircraft Trunkliner Program
in China.
As a result of the indictment, the Department of State has discretion
to deny defense-related export privileges to MDC or a division or
subsidiary of MDC. The agency exercised that discretion on
January 5, 2000, by establishing a "denial policy" with respect to
defense-related exports of MDC and its subsidiaries. Most of MDC's major
existing defense programs were, however, excepted from that policy due
to overriding U.S. foreign policy and national security interests. Other
exceptions have been granted. There can, however, be no assurance as to
how the Department will exercise its discretion as to program or
transaction exceptions for other programs or future defense-related
exports. In addition, the Department of Commerce has authority to
temporarily deny other export privileges to, and the Department of
Defense has authority to suspend or debar from contracting with the
military departments, MDC or a division or subsidiary of MDC. Neither
agency has taken action adverse to MDC or its divisions or subsidiaries
thus far.
19
20
Note 16 - Contingencies (continued)
Based upon all available information, the Company does not expect actions
that would have a material adverse effect on its financial position or
continuing operations. In the unanticipated event of a conviction, MDC
would be subject to Department of State and Department of Commerce denials
or revocations of MDC export licenses. MDC also would be subject to
Department of Defense debarment proceedings.
On February 25, 2000, a purported class action lawsuit alleging gender
discrimination and harassment was filed against The Boeing Company, Boeing
North American, Inc., and McDonnell Douglas Corporation. The complaint, filed
with the United States District Court in Seattle, alleges that the Company has
engaged in a pattern and practice of unlawful discrimination, harassment and
retaliation against females over the course of many years. The complaint,
Beck v. Boeing, names 28 women who have worked for Boeing in the Puget Sound
area; Wichita, Kansas; St. Louis, Missouri; and Tulsa, Oklahoma. On
March 15, 2000, an amended complaint was filed naming an additional 10
plaintiffs, including the first from California. The lawsuit attempts to
represent all women who currently work for the Company, or who have worked
for the Company in the past several years.
The Company has denied the allegation that it has engaged in any unlawful
"pattern and practice." Plaintiffs' motion for class certification was filed
in May 2001. The class they sought included salaried employees in Puget Sound,
Wichita, St. Louis, and Long Beach, and hourly employees in Puget Sound,
Wichita, and St. Louis.
On October 19, 2001, the court granted class certification to a segment of
the population sought by the plaintiffs. The court ruled that the action
could proceed on the basis of two limited subclasses: a. all non-executive
salaried women (including engineers) in the Puget Sound area, and b. all
hourly women covered by the Machinists' Bargaining Agreement in the Puget
Sound area. The claims to be litigated are alleged gender discrimination in
compensation and promotion. The court also held that the plaintiffs could not
seek back pay. Rather, should liability be found, the potential remedies
include some form of injunctive relief and the potential of punitive damages.
The Company intends to continue its aggressive defense of this case.
20
21
Note 17 - Business Segment Data
Segment information for revenues, earnings, and research and development
consisted of the following: Nine months ended Three months ended
September 30 September 30
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2001 2000 2001 2000
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Revenues:
Commercial Airplanes $25,714 $22,512 $ 7,954 $ 7,461
Military Aircraft and Missiles 9,005 8,764 3,289 2,826
Space and Communications 7,456 5,071 2,691 1,614
Customer and Commercial Financing 616 504 176 160
Other 288 209 122 79
Accounting differences/eliminations (583) (432) (545) (263)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Operating revenues $42,496 $36,628 $13,687 $11,877
===============================================================================
Earnings from operations:
Commercial Airplanes $ 2,650 $ 1,880 $ 835 $ 739
Military Aircraft and Missiles 1,068 907 412 367
Space and Communications 395 41 181 5
Customer and Commercial Financing 434 358 107 121
Other (227) (33) (101) (10)
Accounting differences/eliminations (267) (360) (253) (113)
Share-based plans (279) (193) (98) (66)
Unallocated expense (123) (254) (17) (178)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Earnings from operations 3,651 2,346 1,066 865
Other income, principally interest 280 343 28 121
Interest and debt expense (477) (320) (157) (110)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Earnings before income taxes 3,454 2,369 937 876
Income taxes 728 722 287 267
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net earnings before cumulative effect
of accounting change $ 2,726 $ 1,647 $ 650 $ 609
===============================================================================
Research and development:
Commercial Airplanes $ 622 $ 394 $ 237 $ 131
Military Aircraft and Missiles 198 187 75 64
Space and Communications 375 407 127 146
Other 203 36 76 20
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total research and development expense $ 1,398 $ 1,024 $ 515 $ 361
===============================================================================
In the first quarter of 2001, the Company adjusted the segment classification
of certain business activities. The Company established an 'Other' segment
classification which principally includes the activities of Connexion by
BoeingSM, a two-way data communications service for global travelers; Air
Traffic Management, a business unit developing new approaches to a global
solution to address air traffic management issues; and Phantom Works, an
advanced research and development organization focused on innovative
technologies, improved processes and the creation of new products. The
2000 results have been reclassified to conform to the revised segment
classifications. 21
22
Note 17 - Business Segment Data (continued)
For internal reporting purposes, the Company records Commercial Airplanes
segment revenues and operating profits for airplanes transferred to other
segments, and such transfers may include airplanes accounted for as operating
leases that are considered transferred to the Customer and Commercial
Financing segment. The revenues for these transfers are eliminated in the
'Accounting differences/eliminations' caption. In the event an airplane
accounted for as an operating lease is subsequently sold, the 'Accounting
differences/eliminations' caption would reflect the recognition of revenue
and operating profit for the consolidated financial statements.
In the second quarter of 2001, concurrent with an asset purchase agreement
of Trans World Airlines by American Airlines, 32 MD-83s previously accounted
for as operating leases were accounted for as sales-type leases, with no gain
or loss recorded. Accordingly, the 'Accounting differences/eliminations'
caption reflected $792 of revenue in the second quarter of 2001 related to
this transaction.
The $100 charge recognized in the third quarter of 2001 related to the caption
'Special Charges due to the events of September 11, 2001' in the consolidated
statements of operations is included in the 'Unallocated expense' caption.
For internal reporting purposes, the Company recorded Military Aircraft and
Missiles segment revenues and operating profit relating to the delivery of
C-17 transport aircraft described in Note 10. The transaction was treated
as a transfer to the 'Other' segment, where the related lease income and
expense will be recorded.
The Company records cost of sales for 7-series commercial airplane programs
under the program method of accounting described in Note 1 of the Company's
2000 Annual Report. For internal measurement purposes, the Commercial
Airplanes segment records cost of sales based on the cost of specific units
delivered, and to the extent that inventoriable costs exceed estimated
revenues, a loss is not recognized until delivery is made, which is not in
accordance with generally accepted accounting principles. For the 717 program
and certain commercial modification programs, the cost of the specific units
delivered is reduced, on a per-unit basis, by the amount previously recognized
for forward losses. Proceeds from certain Commercial Airplanes segment
suppliers attributable to participation in development efforts are accounted
for as a reduction in the cost of inventory received from the supplier under
the program accounting method, and as an expense reduction in the period the
proceeds are received for internal measurement purposes. These adjustments
between the internal measurement method and the program accounting method are
included in the 'Accounting differences/eliminations' caption of net earnings.
These adjustments totaled $(483) and $(545) for the nine months ended