United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
reversed a March 31, 1998, judgment of the United States Court of Federal Claims
for the Team. The 1998 judgment was based on a determination that the Government
had not exercised the required discretion before issuing a termination for
default. It converted the termination to a termination for convenience, and
determined the Team was entitled to be paid $1,200, plus statutory interest from
June 26, 1991, until paid. The Court of Appeals remanded the case to the Court
of Federal Claims for a determination as to whether the Government is able to
sustain the burden of showing a default was justified and other proceedings.
Final resolution of the A-12 litigation will depend on the outcome of such
litigation and possible further appeals or negotiations with the Government.
In the Company's opinion, the loss provision continues to provide adequately for
the reasonably possible reduction in value of A-12 net contracts in process as
of March 31, 2001, as a result of a termination of the contract for the
convenience of the Government. The Company has been provided with an opinion of
outside counsel that (i) the Government's termination of the contract for
default was contrary to law and fact, (ii) the rights and obligations of the
Company are the same as if the termination had been issued for the convenience
of the Government, and (iii) subject to prevailing on the issue that the
termination is properly one for the convenience of the Government, the probable
recovery by the Company is not less than $250.
14
15
Note 14 - Contingencies (continued)
On October 31, 1997, a federal securities lawsuit was filed against the Company
in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington, in Seattle.
The lawsuit names as defendants the Company and three of its then executive
officers. Additional lawsuits of a similar nature have been filed in the same
court. These lawsuits were consolidated on February 24, 1998. The lawsuits
generally allege that the defendants desired to keep the Company's share price
as high as possible in order to ensure that the McDonnell Douglas
shareholders would approve the merger and, in the case of the individual
defendants, to benefit directly from the sale of Boeing stock during the period
from April 7, 1997 through October 22, 1997. By order dated May 1, 2000, the
Court certified two subclasses of plaintiffs in the action: a. all persons or
entities who purchased Boeing stock or call options or who sold put options
during the period from July 21, 1997 through October 22, 1997, and b. all
persons or entities who purchased McDonnell Douglas stock on or after April 7,
1997 and who held such stock until it converted to Boeing stock pursuant to the
merger. The plaintiffs seek compensatory damages and treble damages. The action
is currently set for trial on March 7, 2002. The Company believes that the
allegations are without merit and that the outcome of these lawsuits will not
have a material adverse effect on its earnings, cash flow or financial position.
On October 19, 1999, an indictment was returned by a federal grand jury sitting
in the District of Columbia charging that McDonnell Douglas Corporation (MDC), a
wholly owned subsidiary of the Company, and MDC's Douglas Aircraft Company
division, conspired to and made false statements and concealed material facts on
export license applications and in connection with export licenses, and
possessed and sold machine tools in violation of the Export Administration Act.
The indictment also charged one employee with participation in the alleged
conspiracy. The indictment has since been dismissed as against this employee,
but that dismissal is the subject of a pending appeal by the government to the
U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit. The indictment relates to the sale
and export to China in 1993-1995 of surplus, used machine tools sold by Douglas
Aircraft Company to China National Aero-Technology Import and Export Corporation
for use in connection with the MD-80/90 commercial aircraft Trunkliner Program
in China.
As a result of the indictment, the Department of State has discretion to deny
defense-related export privileges to MDC or a division or subsidiary of MDC. The
agency exercised that discretion on January 5, 2000, by establishing a "denial
policy" with respect to defense-related exports of MDC and its subsidiaries.
Most of MDC's major existing defense programs were, however, excepted from that
policy due to overriding U.S. foreign policy and national security interests.
Other exceptions may be granted. There can, however, be no assurance as to how
the Department will exercise its discretion as to program or transaction
exceptions for other programs or future defense-related exports. In addition,
the Department of Commerce has authority to temporarily deny other export
privileges to, and the Department of Defense has authority to suspend or debar
from contracting with the military departments, MDC or a division or subsidiary
of MDC. Neither agency has taken action adverse to MDC or its divisions or
subsidiaries thus far. Based upon all available information, the Company does
not expect actions that would have a material adverse effect on its financial
position or continuing operations. In the unanticipated event of a conviction,
MDC would be subject to Department of State and Department of Commerce denials
or revocations of MDC export licenses. MDC also would be subject to Department
of Defense debarment proceedings.
15
16
Note 14 - Contingencies (continued)
On February 25, 2000, a purported class action lawsuit alleging gender
discrimination and harassment was filed against The Boeing Company, Boeing North
American, Inc., and McDonnell Douglas Corporation. The complaint, filed with the
United States District Court in Seattle, alleges that the Company has engaged in
a pattern and practice of unlawful discrimination, harassment and retaliation
against females over the course of many years. The complaint, Beck v. Boeing,
names 28 women who have worked for Boeing in the Puget Sound area; Wichita,
Kansas; St. Louis, Missouri; and Tulsa, Oklahoma. On March 15, an amended
complaint was filed naming an additional 10 plaintiffs, including the first from
California. The lawsuit attempts to represent all women who currently work for
the Company, or who have worked for the Company in the past several years.
The Company has denied the allegation that it has engaged in any unlawful
"pattern and practice" and believes that the plaintiffs cannot satisfy the
rigorous requirements necessary to achieve the class action status they seek.
Plaintiffs' motion for class certification will be filed by early May 2001. The
Company intends to vigorously contest this lawsuit.
16
17
Note 15 - Business Segment Data
Segment information for revenues, earnings, and research and development
consisted of the following:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Three months ended
March 31
2001 2000
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Revenues:
Commercial Airplanes $ 8,443 $5,171
Military Aircraft and Missiles 2,427 2,846
Space and Communications 2,246 1,659
Customer and Commercial Financing 206 167
Other 71 61
Accounting differences/eliminations (100) 6
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Operating revenues $13,293 $9,910
===============================================================================
Earnings from operations:
Commercial Airplanes $ 860 $ 259
Military Aircraft and Missiles 246 294
Space and Communications 84 60
Customer and Commercial Financing 142 107
Other (51) 2
Accounting differences/eliminations 25 (48)
Share-based plans (82) (60)
Unallocated expense (6) (58)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Earnings from operations 1,218 556
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other income, principally interest 235 149
Interest and debt expense (148) (103)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Earnings before income taxes 1,305 602
Income taxes 69 184
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net earnings before cumulative effect of
accounting change $1,236 $ 418
===============================================================================
Research and development:
Commercial Airplanes $ 195 $ 103
Military Aircraft and Missiles 53 61
Space and Communications 123 124
Other 51
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total research and development expense $ 422 $ 288
===============================================================================
17
18
Note 15 - Business Segment Data (continued)
In the first quarter of 2001, the Company adjusted the segment classification of
certain business activities. The Company established an "Other" segment classi-
fication which principally includes the activities of Connexion by BoeingSM, a
two-way data communications service for global travelers; Air Traffic Manage-
ment, a business unit developing new approaches to a global solution to address
air traffic management issues; and Phantom Works, an advanced research and
development organization focused on innovative technologies, improved processes
and the creation of new products. First quarter 2000 results have been
reclassified to conform to the revised segment classifications.
For internal reporting purposes, the Company records Commercial Airplanes
segment revenues and operating profits for airplanes transferred to other
segments, and such transfers may include airplanes accounted for as operating
leases that are considered transferred to the Customer and Commercial Financing
segment. The revenues for these transfers are eliminated in the 'Accounting
differences/eliminations' caption. In the event an airplane accounted for as an
operating lease is subsequently sold, the 'Accounting differences/eliminations'
caption would reflect the recognition of revenue and operating profit for the
consolidated financial statements.
The Company records cost of sales for 7-series commercial airplane programs
under the program method of accounting described in Note 1 to the audited
consolidated financial statements included in the Company's 2000 Annual Report.
For internal measurement purposes, the Commercial Airplanes segment records cost
of sales based on the cost of specific units delivered, and to the extent that
inventoriable costs exceed estimated revenues, a loss is not recognized until
delivery is made, which is not in accordance with generally accepted accounting
principles. For the 717 program, the cost of the specific units delivered is
reduced, on a per-unit basis, by the amount previously recognized for forward
losses. Proceeds from certain Commercial Airplanes segment suppliers attribut-
able to participation in development efforts are accounted for as a reduction in
the cost of inventory received from the supplier under the program accounting
method, and as an expense reduction in the period the proceeds are received
for internal measurement purposes. These adjustments between the internal
measurement method and the program accounting method are included in the
'Accounting differences/eliminations' caption of net earnings. These adjustments
totaled $(111) and $(78) for the three months ended March 31, 2001 and 2000.
The 'Accounting differences/eliminations' caption of net earnings also includes
the impact of cost measurement differences between generally accepted accounting
principles and federal cost accounting standards. This includes the following:
the differences between pension costs recognized under SFAS No. 87, Employers'
Accounting for Pensions, and under federal cost accounting standards,
principally on a funding basis; the differences between retiree health care
costs recognized under SFAS No. 106, Employers' Accounting for Postretirement
Benefits Other Than Pensions, and under federal cost accounting standards,
principally on a cash basis; and the differences in timing of cost recognition
related to certain activities, such as facilities consolidation, undertaken as a
result of mergers and acquisitions whereby such costs are expensed under
generally accepted accounting principles and deferred under federal cost
accounting standards. Additionally, the amortization of costs capitalized in
accordance with SFAS No. 34, Capitalization of Interest Cost, is included in the
'Accounting differences/eliminations' caption.
The costs attributable to share-based plans are not allocated. Other unallocated
costs include corporate costs not allocated to the operating segments, including
goodwill amortization resulting from acquisitions prior to 1998.
18
19
===============================================================================
|Forward-Looking Information Is Subject to Risk and Uncertainty |
| |
|Certain statements in this report contain "forward-looking" information that |
|involves risk and uncertainty, including projections for income recognition |
|in connection with interest rate swaps, deliveries, launches, cash |
|requirements and/or loan guarantees in connection with the Sea Launch joint |
|venture, estimated tax payments, and other trend projections. This |
|forward-looking information is based upon a number of assumptions including |
|assumptions regarding global economic conditions, earnings, government |
|policies and actions; successful negotiation of contracts with the Company's |
|labor unions and regulatory approvals. Actual future results and trends may |
|differ materially depending on a variety of factors, including the Company's |
|successful execution of internal performance plans, production rate increases|
|and decreases, production system initiatives, timing of product deliveries |
|and launches, supplier contract negotiations, asset management plans, acqui- |
|sition and divestiture plans, procurement plans, and other cost-reduction |
|efforts; the actual outcomes of certain pending sales campaigns and U. S. and|
|foreign government procurement activities; acceptance of new products and |
|services; product performance risks; the cyclical nature of some of the |
|Company's businesses; volatility of the market for certain products and |
|services; domestic and international competition in the defense, space and |
|commercial areas; continued integration of acquired businesses; uncertainties|
|associated with regulatory certifications of the Company's commercial |
|aircraft by the U.S. Government and foreign governments; other regulatory |
|uncertainties; collective bargaining labor disputes; performance issues with |
|key suppliers, subcontractors and customers; governmental export and import |
|policies; factors that result in significant and prolonged disruption to air |
|travel worldwide; global trade policies; worldwide political stability; |
|domestic and international economic conditions; price escalation trends; the |
|outcome of political and legal processes, including uncertainty regarding |
|government funding of certain programs; changing priorities or reductions in |
|the U.S. Government or foreign government defense and space budgets; |
|termination of government contracts due to unilateral government action or |
|failure to perform; legal, financial and governmental risks related to |
|international transactions; legal proceedings; and other economic, political |
|and technological risks and uncertainties. Additional information regarding |
|these factors is contained in the Company's SEC filings, including, without |
|limitation and the Company's Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended |
|December 31, 2000. |
===============================================================================
19
20
Item 2. Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results
of Operations
Results of Operations
Revenues
--------
Sales of $13.3 billion for the first three months of 2001 were 34% higher than
sales for the comparable period of 2000. For the first three months of 2001, a
total of 122 commercial aircraft were delivered, compared with 75 for the same
period in 2000. The commercial aircraft deliveries in first quarter 2000 were
impacted by a 40-day work stoppage due to a strike by the Society of
Professional Engineering Employees in Aerospace (SPEEA). Approximately 530
commercial aircraft deliveries are currently projected for the full year 2001,
compared with 489 in 2000.
Commercial jet aircraft deliveries were as follows:
Three months ended
March 31
-------------------------------------------------
Model 2001 2000
-------------------------------------------------
717 7 (1) 3 (1)
737 Classic - 2
737 Next-Generation 72* 39*
747 7 4**
757 8 10
767 10 5
777 16 10
MD-11 2 2
-------------------------------------------------
Total 122 75
=================================================
*Includes one C-40 Aircraft
**Includes one Airborne Laser 747
Commercial jet aircraft deliveries included deliveries under operating lease,
which are identified by parentheses in the table above. Aircraft accounted for
as operating leases have minimal revenues recorded at the time of delivery.
20
21
Military Aircraft and Missiles segment deliveries included the following:
Three months ended
March 31
------------------------------------------------
Model 2001 2000
------------------------------------------------
C-17 2 3
F-15 - 4
F/A-18C/D - 6
F/A-18E/F 7 4
T-45TS 4 4
CH-47 2 1
AH-64 Intl (New Builds) 2 2
Space and Communications segment deliveries included the following:
Three months ended
March 31
------------------------------------------------
Model 2001 2000
------------------------------------------------
Delta II - 2
Delta III - -
Satellites 1 -
Earnings
--------
Net earnings for the first quarter of 2001 were $1,237 million, compared with
$418 million for the same period in 2000. The first quarter 2001 results
included a non-recurring earnings tax benefit resulting from a final agreement
with the Internal Revenue Service primarily regarding previously filed claims
for refund of research and development tax credits. These claims dealt primarily
with historical fixed-price development program expenses incurred by McDonnell
Douglas from 1986 to 1992. The agreement with the IRS resulted in financial
recognition during the quarter of $343 million of tax credit and $210 million
($132 million after-tax) of related interest income.
Research and development expense totaled $422 million for the quarter, compared
with $288 million for the same period of 2000. Commercial Airplanes segment
research and development expense of $195 million reflects an increase over the
$103 million expense for the first quarter of 2000 which was also affected by
the SPEEA work stoppage. Space and Communications segment research and
development expense of $123 million for the first quarter is in line with the
spending levels for the same period in 2000. Research and development in the
other segment relates principally to Connexion by BoeingSM.
21
22
In December 1996, The Boeing Company filed suit in the U.S. District Court for
the Western District of Washington for the refund of over $400 million in
federal income taxes and related interest. The suit challenged the IRS method of
allocating research and development costs for the purpose of determining tax
incentive benefits on export sales through the Company's Domestic International
Sales Corporation (DISC) and its Foreign Sales Corporation (FSC) for the years
1979 through 1987. In September 1998, the Company's position prevailed when the
District Court granted the Company's motion for summary judgment. The U.S.
Department of Justice has appealed this decision. If the Company were to
prevail, the refund would include interest computed to the payment date. The
issue could affect tax computations for subsequent years; however, the financial
impact would depend on the final resolution of audits for those years.
In response to an adverse World Trade Organization (WTO) finding relative to the
U.S. FSC tax provisions, the U.S. repealed FSC and enacted replacement
legislation (Extraterritorial Income Exclusion Act of 2000). The European Union
has filed a WTO challenge to the new law. It is not possible to predict what
impact, if any, this issue will have on future earnings pending final resolution
of the challenge.
The Company has significant financing assets and off-balance-sheet commitments
that are impacted by the market value of various jet aircraft. The Company
believes that it has appropriately assessed the impact of aircraft market values
on accounting for such commitments and financing assets. A significant
deterioration in the market value, however, could result in the requirement to
adjust related reserves. The Company will continue to monitor this market.
Operating Earnings
------------------
Commercial Airplanes
First quarter 2001 commercial jet aircraft deliveries totaled 122 compared with
75 during the same period in 2000. Commercial Airplanes segment first quarter
2001 operating earnings, based on the unit cost of airplanes delivered, were
$860 million, compared with $259 million for the same period in 2000. The
overall Commercial Airplanes segment operating profit margin was approximately
10.2% for the first quarter of 2001, compared with 5.0% for the same period in
2000. The first quarter 2001 margin increase over the same period in 2000
primarily reflects the effects of a work stoppage in 2000 and continued
improvement in the production process offset by increased research and
development expense.
Commercial Airplanes segment earnings, as determined under generally accepted
accounting principles (GAAP) and including intercompany transactions, reflect
the program method of accounting and incorporate a portion of the 'Accounting
differences/eliminations' caption as discussed in Note 16. Commercial Airplanes
segment earnings under GAAP were $749 million and $181 million for the first
quarter 2001 and 2000. The GAAP determined segment margin of 8.9% in 2001
compares with 3.5% for the same three-month period in 2000. In addition to the
impacts to the segment margins identified above, the improving GAAP earnings and
margins reflect the impact of additional units within the accounting quantity
for the Next-Generation 737 and the 777. The Next-Generation 737 program
accounting quantity was 1,800 units as of March 31, 2001, and 1,400 units as of
March 31, 2000. The 777 program accounting quantity was 600 units as of March
31, 2001, and 500 units as of March 31, 2000.
22
23
As of March 31, 2001, the Company had cumulatively delivered 51 717 program
aircraft. The 717 program is accounted for under the program method of
accounting described in Note 1 to the audited consolidated financial statements
in the Company's 2000 Annual Report. The Company has established the program
accounting quantity at 200 units. The Company will record 717 deliveries on a
break-even basis until such time as program reviews indicate positive gross
profit within the program accounting quantity. Such program reviews could
include revised assumptions of revenues and costs, or an increase in the program
quantity if warranted by additional program orders. The Company has significant
exposures related to the 717 program, principally attributable to pricing
pressures and the slow buildup of firm orders.
As a result of the asset purchase agreement between TWA and American Airlines
discussed in Note 4, American Airlines has assumed the lease of 15 717s and
committed to take delivery, under lease, of an additional 15 717s. These lease
terms are of a shorter duration than the terms originally contracted with TWA.
During the first quarter of 2001, Commercial Airplanes announced plans to focus
its product development activities on a faster, longer-range sonic cruiser
airplane.
Military Aircraft and Missiles
First quarter 2000 segment revenues and operating earnings have been restated to
reclassify Phantom Works activity from the Military Aircraft and Missiles
segment to the Other segment. See Note 16.
Military Aircraft and Missiles segment first quarter 2001 operating earnings
were $246 million, compared with $294 million for the same period in 2000. The
operating margin of 10.1% for first quarter 2001 compares with a first quarter
2000 margin of 10.3%. The lower earnings in first quarter 2001 reflect fewer C-
17 and F-15 deliveries and the end of F/A-18C/D production.
On February 5, 2001, the Boeing JSF X-32A concept demonstrator completed flight
testing. The flight test program successfully demonstrated the program's ability
to meet all government test objectives as well as provided many additional
capabilities. On March 29, the Boeing JSF X-32B demonstrator successfully
completed its first flight, entering a four month test program to validate the
Boeing approach to short-takeoff and vertical landing (STOVL) flight.
Space and Communications
The Space and Communications segment had operating earnings of $84 million for
the first quarter of 2001, compared with operating earnings of $60 million in
the same period in 2000. The increase from 2000 was primarily a result of the
acquisition of Boeing Satellite Systems in the fourth quarter of 2000.
During the quarter, the Company successfully completed extended duration testing
on the RS-68 engine for the Delta IV, and the first Delta IV commercial launch
customer was announced. On March 18, 2001, a Boeing Satellite Systems 702
satellite was successfully launched by Sea Launch, a joint venture of which
Boeing is a 40% partner.
23
24
The Company continues to monitor the impact of the softening satellite launch
market on the Delta III program and the Sea Launch venture. The Company
continues to monitor potential exposures for the Delta III program by assessing
the estimated revenues attributable to future Delta III launches, including
revenue for launch positions that are currently unsold, along with assessing
inventory and supplier commitments. The next Delta III launch is anticipated for
2003.
The Company has ongoing financial exposure due to the Sea Launch venture. This
financial exposure primarily results from company guarantees extended on
partnership loans. The Company's maximum exposure to credit related losses
associated with Sea Launch credit guarantees is $373 million.
The Company projects that the Sea Launch joint venture may require additional
infusions from the partners in the near term. This would be expected to result
in additional cash requirements and-or loan guarantees imposed on the Company.
Customer and Commercial Financing
Revenues consist principally of interest from financing receivables and lease
income from operating lease equipment. Segment earnings additionally reflect
depreciation on leased equipment and expenses attributable to potentially
uncollectible receivables. No interest expense on debt is included in Customer
and Commercial Financing segment earnings reflected in Note 15; however, $74
million of first quarter 2001 interest expense is associated with debt relating
to financing activities.
Operating earnings for the Customer and Commercial Financing segment were $142
million for first quarter 2001, compared with $107 million for first quarter
2000, exclusive of interest expense. The increase was due principally to an
increase in financing assets.
On January 10, 2001, TWA and certain of its domestic subsidiaries filed
voluntary petitions in the U.S. District Court in Wilmington, Delaware, for
relief under Chapter 11 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code. On April 9, 2001, TWA
received final approval from the Court for an asset purchase agreement with
American Airlines. Under this agreement, American Airlines as lessee has assumed
various aircraft leases from TWA whereby the Company is the lessor. The
restructured lease payments from American Airlines are at rates that are lower
than those contracted with TWA; however, none of the associated leased assets
have been deemed to be impaired.
Liquidity and Capital Resources
-------------------------------
The Company's financial liquidity position as of March 31, 2001, included cash
and short-term investments totaling $1.6 billion. During the first three months
of 2001, the Company repurchased 2.2 million shares for $131 million under an 85
million share repurchase plan.
Excluding Boeing Capital Corporation (BCC), a financing subsidiary wholly owned
by the Company, total long-term debt is at 27% of total shareholders' equity
plus debt. The consolidated long-term debt, including BCC, is at 42% of total
shareholders' equity plus debt. Revolving credit line agreements with a group
of major banks, totaling $3.0 billion, remain available but unused.
24
25
The Company believes its internally generated liquidity, together with access to
external capital resources, will be sufficient to satisfy existing commitments
and plans, and also to provide adequate financial flexibility to take advantage
of potential strategic business opportunities should they arise. During the
second quarter of 2001, the Company projects it will make a tax payment of
approximately $1 billion due to, among other factors, the closeout of contracts
accounted for under the completed contract method for tax purposes.
Backlog
-------
Contractual backlog of unfilled orders (which excludes purchase options and
announced orders for which definitive contracts have not been executed, and
unobligated U.S. Government contract funding) was as follows (dollars in
billions):
March 31 December 31
------------------------------------------------------------
2001 2000
------------------------------------------------------------
Commercial Airplanes $ 88.6 $ 89.8
Military Aircraft and Missiles 20.4 17.1
Space and Communications 15.1 13.7
------------------------------------------------------------
Total contractual backlog $124.1 $120.6
============================================================
Unobligated U.S. Government contract funding not included in backlog totaled
$29.2 billion at March 31, 2001, compared with $31.3 billion at December 31,
2000.
Item 3. Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk
The Company has financial instruments that are subject to interest rate risk,
principally short-term investments, fixed-rate notes receivable attributable to
customer financing, and debt obligations issued at a fixed rate. Historically,
the Company has not experienced material gains or losses due to interest rate
changes when selling short-term investments or fixed-rate notes receivable.
Additionally, the Company uses interest rate swaps to manage exposure to
interest rate changes. Based on the current holdings of short-term investments
and fixed-rate notes, as well as underlying swaps, the exposure to interest rate
risk is not material. Fixed-rate debt obligations issued by the Company are
generally not callable until maturity.
The Company is subject to foreign currency exchange rate risk relating to
receipts from customers and payments to suppliers in foreign currencies. As a
general policy, the Company substantially hedges foreign currency commitments of
future payments and receipts by purchasing foreign currency-forward contracts.
As of January 1, 2001, the Company adopted Statement of Financial Accounting
Standards (SFAS) No. 133, Accounting for Derivative Instruments and Hedging
Activities, as amended. As of March 31, 2001, the notional value of such deriva-
tives was $463 million, with a net unrealized loss of $32 million. Additionally,
the Company had foreign currency forward contracts with a notional value of $231
million that were carried at market value. The Company realized a net loss of $5
million attributable to these forward contracts during the quarter.
Less than two percent of receipts and expenditures are contracted in foreign
currencies, and the market risk exposure relating to currency exchange is not
material.
25
26
PART II - OTHER INFORMATION
Item 1. Legal Proceedings
Various legal proceedings, claims and investigations related to products,
contracts and other matters are pending against the Company. Most significant
legal proceedings are related to matters covered by insurance. Major
contingencies are discussed below.
The Company is subject to U.S. Government investigations of its practices from
which civil, criminal or administrative proceedings could result. Such
proceedings could involve claims by the Government for fines, penalties,
compensatory and treble damages, restitution and/or forfeitures. Under
government regulations, a company, or one or more of its operating divisions or
subdivisions, can also be suspended or debarred from government contracts, or
lose its export privileges, based on the results of investigations. The Company
believes, based upon all available information, that the outcome of any such
government disputes and investigations will not have a material adverse effect
on its financial position or continuing operations.
In 1991, the U.S. Navy notified the Company and General Dynamics Corporation
(the Team) that it was terminating for default the Team's contract for
development and initial production of the A-12 aircraft. The Team filed a legal
action to contest the Navy's default termination, to assert its rights to
convert the termination to one for "the convenience of the Government," and to
obtain payment for work done and costs incurred on the A-12 contract but not
paid to date. As of March 31, 2001, inventories included approximately $581
million of recorded costs on the A-12 contract, against which the Company has
established a loss provision of $350 million. The amount of the provision, which
was established in 1990, was based on the Company's belief, supported by an
opinion of outside counsel, that the termination for default would be converted
to a termination for convenience, that the Team would establish a claim for
contract adjustments for a minimum of $250 million, that there was a range of
reasonably possible results on termination for convenience, and that it was
prudent to provide for what the Company then believed was the upper range of
possible loss on termination for convenience, which was $350 million.
On July 1, 1999, the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
reversed a March 31, 1998, judgment of the United States Court of Federal Claims
for the Team. The 1998 judgment was based on a determination that the Government
had not exercised the required discretion before issuing a termination for
default. It converted the termination to a termination for convenience, and
determined the Team was entitled to be paid $1,200 million, plus statutory
interest from June 26, 1991, until paid. The Court of Appeals remanded the case
to the Court of Federal Claims for a determination as to whether the Government
is able to sustain the burden of showing a default was justified and other
proceedings. Final resolution of the A-12 litigation will depend on the outcome
of such litigation and possible further appeals or negotiations with the
Government.
In the Company's opinion, the loss provision continues to provide adequately for
the reasonably possible reduction in value of A-12 net contracts in process as
of March 31, 2001, as a result of a termination of the contract for the
convenience of the Government. The Company has been provided with an opinion of
outside counsel that (i) the Government's termination of the contract for
default was contrary to law and fact, (ii) the rights and obligations of the
Company are the same as if the termination had been issued for the convenience
of the Government, and (iii) subject to prevailing on the issue that the
26
27
termination is properly one for the convenience of the Government, the probable
recovery by the Company is not less than $250 million.
On October 31, 1997, a federal securities lawsuit was filed against the Company
in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington, in Seattle.
The lawsuit names as defendants the Company and three of its then executive
officers. Additional lawsuits of a similar nature have been filed in the same
court. These lawsuits were consolidated on February 24, 1998. The lawsuits
generally allege that the defendants desired to keep the Company's share price
as high as possible in order to ensure that the McDonnell Douglas shareholders
would approve the merger and, in the case of the individual defendants,
to benefit directly from the sale of Boeing stock during the period from April
7, 1997 through October 22, 1997. By order dated May 1, 2000, the Court
certified two subclasses of plaintiffs in the action: a. all persons or entities
who purchased Boeing stock or call options or who sold put options during the
period from July 21, 1997 through October 22, 1997, and b. all persons or
entities who purchased McDonnell Douglas stock on or after April 7, 1997 and who
held such stock until it converted to Boeing stock pursuant to the merger. The
plaintiffs seek compensatory damages and treble damages. The action is currently
set for trial on March 7, 2002. The Company believes that the allegations are
without merit and that the outcome of these lawsuits will not have a material
adverse effect on its earnings, cash flow or financial position.
On October 19, 1999, an indictment was returned by a federal grand jury sitting
in the District of Columbia charging that McDonnell Douglas Corporation (MDC), a
wholly owned subsidiary of the Company, and MDC's Douglas Aircraft Company
division, conspired to and made false statements and concealed material facts on
export license applications and in connection with export licenses, and
possessed and sold machine tools in violation of the Export Administration Act.
The indictment also charged one employee with participation in the alleged
conspiracy. The indictment has since been dismissed as against this employee,
but that dismissal is the subject of a pending appeal by the government to the
U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit. The indictment relates to the sale
and export to China in 1993-1995 of surplus, used machine tools sold by Douglas
Aircraft Company to China National Aero-Technology Import and Export Corporation
for use in connection with the MD-80/90 commercial aircraft Trunkliner Program
in China.
As a result of the indictment, the Department of State has discretion to deny
defense-related export privileges to MDC or a division or subsidiary of MDC. The
agency exercised that discretion on January 5, 2000, by establishing a "denial
policy" with respect to defense-related exports of MDC and its subsidiaries.
Most of MDC's major existing defense programs were, however, excepted from that
policy due to overriding U.S. foreign policy and national security interests.
Other exceptions may be granted. There can, however, be no assurance as to how
the Department will exercise its discretion as to program or transaction
exceptions for other programs or future defense-related exports. In addition,
the Department of Commerce has authority to temporarily deny other export
privileges to, and the Department of Defense has authority to suspend or debar
from contracting with the military departments, MDC or a division or subsidiary
of MDC. Neither agency has taken action adverse to MDC or its divisions or
subsidiaries thus far. Based upon all available information, the Company does
not expect actions that would have a material adverse effect on its financial
position or continuing operations. In the unanticipated event of a conviction,
MDC would be subject to Department of State and Department of Commerce denials
or revocations of MDC export licenses. MDC also would be subject to Department
of Defense debarment proceedings.
27
28
On February 25, 2000, a purported class action lawsuit alleging gender
discrimination and harassment was filed against The Boeing Company, Boeing North
American, Inc., and McDonnell Douglas Corporation. The complaint, filed with the
United States District Court in Seattle, alleges that the Company has engaged in
a pattern and practice of unlawful discrimination, harassment and retaliation
against females over the course of many years. The complaint, Beck v. Boeing,
names 28 women who have worked for Boeing in the Puget Sound area; Wichita,
Kansas; St. Louis, Missouri; and Tulsa, Oklahoma. On March 15, an amended
complaint was filed naming an additional 10 plaintiffs, including the first from
California. The lawsuit attempts to represent all women who currently work for
the Company, or who have worked for the Company in the past several years.
The Company has denied the allegation that it has engaged in any unlawful
"pattern and practice" and believes that the plaintiffs cannot satisfy the
rigorous requirements necessary to achieve the class action status they seek.
Plaintiffs' motion for class certification will be filed by early May 2001. The
Company intends to vigorously contest this lawsuit.
28
29
Item 4. Submission of Matters to a Vote of Security Holders
(a) The Company's Annual Meeting of Shareholders was held on
April 30, 2001.
(b) At the Annual Meeting, in an uncontested election, three nominees
of the Board of Directors were elected directors for three-year
terms expiring on the date of the annual meeting in 2004. The
votes were as follows:
For Withheld
----------- ----------
John H. Biggs 700,108,597 18,470,619
John E. Bryson 691,211,109 27,368,108
Rozanne L. Ridgway 690,828,326 27,750,891
The terms of the following directors continued after the annual
meeting:
Philip M. Condit Paul E. Gray John M. Shalikashvili
Kenneth M. Duberstein John F. McDonnell Harry C. Stonecipher
John F. Fery Lewis E. Platt
(c) The results of voting on Proposals 2 through 9 were as follows:
2. A shareholder proposal requesting the Company to disclose all
significant promises made to foreign governments or foreign
firms in connection with foreign military sales, intended to
offset the U.S. dollar cost of weapons purchased by foreign
nations.
Number of % of Eligible % of Votes % of Votes
Votes Votes Present For or Against
----------- ------------- ---------- --------------
For 37,586,524 4.51% 6.27% 6.51%
Against 539,596,943 64.72% 89.97% 93.49%
Abstain 22,546,468 2.70% 3.76%
Broker non-votes 118,849,280 14.25%
3. A shareholder proposal requesting the Board of Directors to
report on the Company's involvement in miliary activities
in space.
Number of % of Eligible % of Votes % of Votes
Votes Votes Present For or Against
----------- ------------- ---------- --------------
For 51,847,856 6.22% 8.65% 9.13%
Against 516,334,383 61.93% 86.09% 90.87%
Abstain 31,547,696 3.78% 5.26%
Broker non-votes 118,849,280 14.25%
29
30
4. A shareholder proposal requesting the Board to institute a
special Executive Compensation Review to find ways to link
compensation of its key executives with corporate social
performance.
Number of % of Eligible % of Votes % of Votes
Votes Votes Present For or Against
----------- ------------- ---------- --------------
For 59,785,413 7.17% 9.97% 10.27%
Against 522,474,003 62.66% 87.12% 89.73%
Abstain 17,470,519 2.10% 2.91%
Broker non-votes 118,849,280 14.25%
5. A shareholder proposal requesting the Board to adopt a simple
majority vote on all issues submitted for shareholder vote.
Number of % of Eligible % of Votes % of Votes
Votes Votes Present For or Against
----------- ------------- ---------- --------------
For 284,235,748 34.09% 47.39% 48.43%
Against 302,698,080 36.30% 50.47% 51.57%
Abstain 12,796,107 1.53% 2.13%
Broker non-votes 118,849,280 14.25%
6. A shareholder proposal requesting the Board to adopt annual
election of all directors as corporate policy.
Number of % of Eligible % of Votes % of Votes
Votes Votes Present For or Against
----------- ------------- ---------- --------------
For 270,249,844 32.41% 45.06% 45.97%
Against 317,614,189 38.09% 52.96% 54.03%
Abstain 11,865,903 1.42% 1.98%
Broker non-votes 118,849,280 14.25%
7. A shareholder proposal asking the Board of Directors to give all
non-represented employees a choice of pension plans at the time
of termination or retirement.
Number of % of Eligible % of Votes % of Votes
Votes Votes Present For or Against
----------- ------------- ---------- --------------
For 52,305,988 6.27% 8.72% 8.95%
Against 532,071,551 63.81% 88.72% 91.05%
Abstain 15,352,396 1.84% 2.56%
Broker non-votes 118,849,280 14.25%
30
31
8. A shareholder proposal requesting the Board to adopt a
shareholder advisory vote on the members of the audit
committee.
Number of % of Eligible % of Votes % of Votes
Votes Votes Present For or Against
----------- ------------- ---------- --------------
For 56,381,591 6.76% 9.40% 9.64%
Against 528,286,074 63.36% 88.09% 90.36%
Abstain 15,062,271 1.81% 2.51%
Broker non-votes 118,849,280 14.25%
9. A shareholder proposal recommending that the Company not present
to shareholders any stock option proposal that could make the
Company's total stock option dilution greater than its industry
peer group.
Number of % of Eligible % of Votes % of Votes
Votes Votes Present For or Against
----------- ------------- ---------- --------------
For 70,100,037 8.41% 11.69% 11.96%
Against 516,019,042 61.89% 86.04% 88.04%
Abstain 13,610,856 1.63% 2.27%
Broker non-votes 118,849,280 14.25%
Item 6. Exhibits and Reports on Form 8-K
(a) Exhibits
(15) Letter from independent accountants regarding unaudited
interim financial information. Filed herewith.
(27) Financial Data Schedule for the three-month period ending
March 31, 2001. Filed herewith.
(b) Reports on Form 8-K
No reports on Form 8-K were filed during the quarter covered
by this report.
- - - - - - -
31
32
REVIEW BY INDEPENDENT PUBLIC ACCOUNTANTS
The condensed consolidated statement of financial position as of March 31, 2001,
the condensed consolidated statements of operations for the three-month period
ended March 31, 2001 and 2000, and the condensed consolidated statements of cash
flows for the three-month period ended March 31, 2001 and 2000, have been
reviewed by the registrant's independent accountants, Deloitte & Touche LLP,
whose report covering their review of the financial statements follows.
32
33
INDEPENDENT ACCOUNTANTS' REVIEW REPORT
Board of Directors and Shareholders
The Boeing Company
Seattle, Washington
We have reviewed the accompanying condensed consolidated statement of financial
position of The Boeing Company and subsidiaries (the "Company") as of March 31,
2001, and the related condensed consolidated statements of operations and cash
flows for the three-month periods ended March 31, 2001 and 2000. These financial
statements are the responsibility of the Company's management.
We conducted our review in accordance with standards established by the American
Institute of Certified Public Accountants. A review of interim financial
information consists principally of applying analytical procedures to financial
data and of making inquiries of persons responsible for financial and accounting
matters. It is substantially less in scope than an audit conducted in accordance
with auditing standards generally accepted in the United States of America, the
objective of which is the expression of an opinion regarding the financial
statements taken as a whole. Accordingly, we do not express such an opinion.
Based on our review, we are not aware of any material modifications that should
be made to such condensed consolidated financial statements for them to be in
conformity with accounting principles generally accepted in the United States of
America.
We have previously audited, in accordance with auditing standards generally
accepted in the United States of America, the consolidated statement of
financial position of the Company as of December 31, 2000, and the related