Apple
Corps Ltd. v. Apple Computer, Inc.; Apple Computer, Inc. v.
Apple Corps Ltd.
Plaintiff Apple Corps filed this action on July 4,
2003 in the High Court of Justice, Chancery Division, in London alleging that
the Company has breached a 1991 agreement that resolved earlier trademark
litigation between the parties regarding use of certain Apple marks. Plaintiff
seeks an injunction, unspecified damages, and other relief. The Company filed a
motion on October 13, 2003, challenging jurisdiction in the U.K. The Court
denied this motion on April 7, 2004. The Company filed an appeal of the
Court s decision but subsequently withdrew the appeal. In November 2004,
Plaintiff served the Company with an Amended Bill of Particulars and on December 23,
2004, the Company filed a Defence. On November 24, 2005, Plaintiff filed a
Re-Amended Bill of Particulars and the Company filed its Defence on December 16,
2005. Trial took place from March 29, 2006 through April 5, 2006. The
parties await a ruling.
On October 8, 2003, the Company filed a lawsuit
against Apple Corps in the United States District Court for the Northern
District of California requesting a declaratory judgment that the Company has
not breached the 1991 agreement. Apple Corps challenged jurisdiction in the
California case but the Court denied that challenge on March 25, 2004.
Apple Corps subsequently prevailed on a motion to stay the California case
during the pendency of the U.K. action. The Company has dismissed the
California lawsuit without prejudice.
Bader v.
Anderson; Bader v. Apple Computer, Inc. et al.
Plaintiff filed this purported shareholder derivative
action against the Company and each of its current executive officers and
members of its Board of Directors on May 19, 2005 in Santa Clara County
Superior Court asserting claims for breach of fiduciary duty, material
misstatements and omissions, and violations of California Businesses and
Professions Code 17200 (unfair competition). Plaintiff alleges that the
Company s March 14, 2005, proxy statement was false and misleading for
failure to disclose certain information relating to the Apple Computer, Inc.
Performance Bonus Plan, which was approved by shareholders at the annual
meeting held on April 21, 2005. Plaintiff, who ostensibly brings suit on
the Company s behalf, has made no demand on the Board of Directors and alleges
that such demand is excused. Plaintiff seeks injunctive and other relief for
purported injury to the Company. On July 27, 2005, Plaintiff filed an
amended complaint alleging that, in addition to the purported derivative
claims, adoption of the
bonus plan and distribution of the proxy statement describing that plan also
inflicted injury on her directly as an individual shareholder. On January 10,
2006, the Court sustained defendants demurrer to the amended complaint, with
leave to amend. Plaintiff filed a second amended complaint on February 7,
2006. The Company filed a demurrer to that complaint on April 20, 2006 and
a hearing is scheduled for June 13, 2006.
Baghdasarian,
et al. v. Apple Computer, Inc.
Plaintiffs filed this action
in Los Angeles County Superior Court on October 31, 2005, on behalf of a
purported nationwide class of all purchasers of all Apple wireless
products (router, modem, or adaptor) sold at any time. The complaint alleges
that the Company misrepresented the transmission rates of these products. The complaint
alleges causes of action for breach of express warranty and for violations of
the Consumer Legal Remedies Act, California Business & Professions
Code 17200 (unfair competition) and California Business & Professions
Code 17500 (false advertising). The complaint seeks damages and equitable
remedies. The Company filed an answer denying all allegations and asserting
numerous affirmative defenses to the complaint on December 15, 2005.
Birdsong v. Apple Computer, Inc.; Patterson v. Apple
Computer, Inc.
These federal court
complaints allege that the Company s iPod music players, and the ear bud
headphones sold with them, are inherently defective in design and are sold
without adequate warnings concerning the risk of noise-induced hearing loss by
iPod users. The Birdsong action was initially filed on January 30, 2006 in
the United States Antitrust Court for the Western District of Louisiana on
behalf of a purported Louisiana class of iPod purchasers and alleges
violations of the Louisiana Products Liability Act, breaches of implied
warranties, unjust enrichment and negligent misrepresentation. The Patterson
action was filed on January 31, 2006 in the United States Antitrust Court
for the Northern District of California on behalf of a purported class of
all iPod purchasers within the four-year period before January 31, 2006. That
action alleges breaches of implied and express warranties, violations of
California Business & Professions Code 17200 (unfair competition),
California Business & Professions Code 17500 (false advertising), the
Consumer Legal Remedies Act, breaches of express and implied warranties,
negligent misrepresentation and unjust enrichment. The Birdsong action has been
transferred to the Northern District of California and assigned to the same
judge as in Patterson. The Company s responses to the Birdsong and Patterson
complaints are not yet due.
36
similar complaint, Royer-Brennan v. Apple Computer, Inc.
and Apple Canada, Inc., was filed in Montreal, Quebec, Canada,
on February 1, 2006, seeking authorization to institute a class action
on behalf of iPod purchasers in Quebec. Preliminary motions must be filed by May 5,
2006.
Branning
et al. v. Apple Computer, Inc.
Plaintiffs originally filed this purported class action
in San Francisco County Superior Court on February 17, 2005. The initial
complaint alleged violations of California Business & Professions Code
17200 (unfair
competition) and violation of the Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA) regarding
a variety of purportedly unfair and unlawful conduct including, but not limited
to, allegedly selling used computers as new and failing to honor warranties. Plaintiffs
also brought causes of action for misappropriation of trade secrets, breach of
contract, and violation of the Song-Beverly Act. Plaintiffs requested
unspecified damages and other relief. On May 9, 2005, the Court granted
the Company s motion to transfer the case to Santa Clara County Superior Court.
On May 2, 2005, Plaintiffs filed an amended complaint adding two new named
plaintiffs and three new causes of action including a claim for treble damages
under the Cartwright Act (California Business & Professions Code 16700 et seq.) and a claim for false
advertising. The Company filed a demurrer to the amended complaint, which the
Court sustained in its entirety on November 10, 2005. The Court granted
Plaintiffs leave to amend and they filed an amended complaint on December 29,
2005. Plaintiffs amended complaint
added three plaintiffs and alleged many of the same factual claims as the
previous complaints, such as alleged selling of used equipment as new, alleged
failure to honor warranties and service contracts for the consumer plaintiffs,
and alleged fraud related to the opening of the Apple Retail stores. Plaintiffs continued to assert causes of
action for unfair competition ( 17200), violations of the CLRA, breach of
contract, misappropriation of trade secrets, violations of the Cartwright Act
and alleged new causes of action for fraud, conversion and breach of the
implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. The Company filed a
demurrer to the amended complaint on January 31, 2006, which the Court
sustained on March 3, 2006 on sixteen of seventeen causes of action.
Butzer, et al. v.
Apple Computer, Inc.; Wirges v. Apple Computer, Inc.; Blackwell v.
Apple Computer, Inc.
Plaintiffs filed the Butzer
action on August 23, 2005, in the United States District Court for the
Northern District of California, San Jose Division, on behalf of a purported
nationwide class of all purchasers of the Company s PowerBook G4 portable
computers. The complaint alleges defects in the memory of the computers. The
complaint alleges that this purported defect extends to other series of
the Company s portables and states that plaintiffs reserve the right to amend
the complaint to include these other series. Plaintiffs assert claims for
alleged violations of California Business & Professions Code 17200
(unfair competition), California Business & Professions Code 17500
(false advertising), the Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA) and the
Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act. The complaint seeks remedies including
restitution and/or damages and injunctive relief. The Wirges action was filed
on January 20, 2006 in the United States District Court for the Eastern
District of Arkansas, also on behalf of a purported nationwide class, and makes
similar allegations. Plaintiffs assert claims for breach of warranties,
violation of the Magnuson Moss Act, strict products liability and unjust
enrichment. The complaint seeks restitution, damages and other remedies. The
Blackwell action was filed on February 10, 2006, on behalf of a purported
nationwide class, and makes identical allegations to those made in the Butzer
case. Plaintiffs assert claims for breach of express and implied warranties,
violation of the California CLRA, violation of the California Song-Beverly Act,
false advertising and unfair competition. The complaint seeks restitution, an
injunction and other remedies. The Company filed an answer to the Butzer
complaint on October 19, 2005 denying all material allegations and
asserting numerous affirmative defenses. The case is in discovery. The Company
filed an answer to the Wirges action on February 28, 2006. The Company has
filed a motion to transfer the Wirges case to the Northern District of
California. The Company filed an answer to the Blackwell complaint on March 15,
2006 denying all material allegations and asserting numerous affirmative
defenses.
Compression Labs, Inc. v. Apple Computer, Inc.,
et al.; Apple v. Compression Labs, Inc., et al.
Plaintiff Compression Labs, Inc. filed this
patent infringement action on April 22, 2004 against the Company and
twenty-seven other defendants in the United States District Court for the
Eastern District of Texas, Marshall Division, alleging infringement of U.S.
patent 4,698,672 (the 672 patent). Plaintiff alleges that the Company
infringes the patent by complying with the JPEG standard as defined by CCITT
Recommendation T.81 entitled Information Technology Digital Compression and
Coding of Continuous Tone Still Images Requirements and Guidelines. Plaintiff
seeks unspecified damages and other relief.
On July 2, 2004, the Company and several other
defendants in the Texas action filed a lawsuit in the United States District
Court in Delaware against Compression Labs, Inc. and two other companies,
requesting a declaratory
37
judgment of non-infringement, invalidity, implied license
and unenforceability with respect to the 672 patent. Additional actions
regarding this patent have been filed in other jurisdictions. On February 16,
2005, the Panel on Multi-District Litigation (MDL) granted a petition filed by
certain defendants seeking coordination and transfer of all of these cases to
one court for pre-trial proceedings. The MDL Panel has transferred all of the
cases to the Northern District of California. The defendants in the Texas and
Delaware actions had filed motions to dismiss prior to the transfer and both
motions are still pending. A Markman hearing took place on March 9, 2006
and the parties await a ruling.
Contois Music Technology
LLC v. Apple Computer, Inc.
Plaintiff Contois Music
Technology ( Contois ) filed this action on June 13, 2005 in the
United States District Court for Vermont, alleging infringement by the Company
of U.S. Patent No. 5,864,868, entitled Computer Control System and User
Interface for Media Playing Devices. The complaint, which was served on October 4,
2005, seeks unspecified damages and other relief. The Company filed an answer
on November 23, 2005 denying all material allegations and asserting
numerous affirmative defenses. A Markman hearing is scheduled for June 13,
2006.
Two similar complaints
relative to iPod battery life, Wolfe v. Apple and Hirst v. Apple, were filed in Toronto, Ontario, Canada on August 15,
2005 and September 12, 2005, respectively. Both actions define the
purported class as a national class consisting of all persons in
Canada who have purchased or who own an iPod. In addition, a similar complaint
regarding iPod battery life, Hamiliton v. Apple
Computer, Inc. and Apple Canada, Inc.
was filed in Calgary, Alberta, Canada on October 5, 2005, purportedly on
behalf of all purchasers of iPods in Alberta, Canada. That complaint has not
been served. A motion for certification is set for June 9, 2006.
Davis v.
Apple Computer, Inc.
Plaintiff filed this purported class action in
San Francisco County Superior Court on December 5, 2002, alleging that the
Company engaged in unfair and deceptive business practices relating to its
AppleCare Extended Service and Warranty Plan. Plaintiff asserts causes of
action for violation of California Business & Professions Code 17200 (unfair competition),
California Business & Professions Code 17500 (false advertising), breach of the Song-Beverly Warranty
Act, intentional misrepresentation and concealment. Plaintiff requests
unspecified damages and other relief. The Company filed a demurrer and motion
to strike which were granted, in part, and Plaintiff filed an amended
complaint. The Company filed an answer on April 17, 2003 denying all
allegations and asserting numerous affirmative defenses. Plaintiff subsequently
amended his complaint. On October 29, 2003, the Company filed a motion to
disqualify Plaintiff s counsel in his role as counsel to the purported class and
to the general public. The Court granted the motion but allowed Plaintiff to
retain substitute counsel. Plaintiff did engage new counsel for the general
public, but not for the class. The Company moved to disqualify Plaintiff s new
counsel and to have the Court dismiss the general public claims for equitable
relief. The Court declined to disqualify Plaintiff s new counsel or to dismiss
the equitable claims, but did confirm that the class action claims are
dismissed. The Company appealed the ruling and the case was stayed pending the
outcome of the appeal. The Court of Appeals denied the appeal on August 17,
2005, affirming the trial court s decision. The Company filed a Petition for
review with the California Supreme Court, which was denied on November 23,
2005. The case has been remanded back to the trial court.
European
Commission Investigation
The European Commission has notified the Company that
it is investigating certain matters relating to the iTunes Music Store in the
European Union (EU). The European Commission is investigating claims made by
Which?, a United Kingdom (UK) consumer association, that the Company is
violating EU competition law by charging more for online music in the UK than
in Eurozone countries and preventing UK consumers from purchasing online music
from the iTunes Music Store for Eurozone countries. The Which? claims were
originally lodged with the UK Office of Fair Trading, which subsequently
referred them to the European Commission. The European Commission is
investigating the charges under Articles 81 and 82 of the European Commission
Treaty.
Gillis
et al. v. Apple Computer, Inc.
Plaintiffs
filed this purported class action on December 23, 2005 in San Diego
County Superior Court alleging that the Company has misrepresented the hard
drive capacity of two Powerbook G4 computers: the 12 inch, 1.5 GHz computer
with 512 MB of memory and a 100GB hard drive; and the 15 inch, 1.67 GHz
computer with 1GB of memory and a 100GB hard drive. Plaintiffs allege that the
Company s standard disclosure on its packaging regarding hard drive size was
not present on the packaging for these two models. The complaint alleges
violations of the California Business & Profession Code 17200 (unfair
competition), California Business & Profession Code 17500 (false
advertising), the Consumer Legal Remedies Act, and causes of action for deceit
and negligent
38
misrepresentation.
Plaintiffs seek restitution and other relief. On February 28, 2006, the
Company filed a demurrer and a motion to strike. The Company withdrew the
demurrer and motion to strike per stipulations and await an amended complaint.
Goldberg, et al. v. Apple Computer, Inc., et
al. (f.k.a. Dan v. Apple Computer, Inc. )
Plaintiffs filed this purported class action on September 22,
2003 in Los Angeles County Superior Court against the Company and other members
of the computer industry on behalf of an alleged nationwide class of
purchasers of certain computer hard drives. The case alleges violations of
California Business and Professions Code 17200 (unfair competition), the Consumer Legal Remedies Act and
false advertising related to the size of the drives. Plaintiffs allege that
calculation of hard drive size using the decimal method misrepresents the
actual size of the drive. The complaint seeks restitution and other relief.
Plaintiffs filed an amended complaint on March 30, 2004 and the Company
filed an answer on September 23, 2004, denying all allegations and
asserting numerous affirmative defenses. Defendants filed a motion to strike
portions of the complaint based on sales by resellers and filed a motion for
judgment on the pleadings based upon Proposition 64. The Court granted both
motions at a hearing on April 6, 2005. Plaintiffs thereafter filed an
amended complaint on May 6, 2005. The Defendants filed a demurrer on June 6,
2005, which was heard on August 22, 2005. The Court granted the demurrer
in part and denied it in part. Plaintiffs filed an amended complaint and the
Company filed an answer on December 15, 2005 denying all allegations and
asserting numerous assertive defenses.
Honeywell International, Inc., et al. v.
Apple Computer, Inc., et al.
Plaintiffs Honeywell International, Inc. and
Honeywell Intellectual Properties, Inc. filed this action on October 6,
2004 in the United States District Court in Delaware alleging infringement by
the Company and other defendants of U.S. patent 5,280,371 entitled Directional
Diffuser for a Liquid Crystal Display. Plaintiffs seek unspecified damages and
other relief. The Company filed an answer on December 21, 2004 denying all
material allegations and asserting numerous affirmative defenses. The Company
has tendered the case to several LCD manufacturer suppliers. On May 18,
2005 the Court stayed the case against the Company and the other
non-manufacturer defendants. Plaintiffs filed an amended complaint on November 7,
2005 adding additional defendants and expanding the scope of the accused
products. Given the stay, the Company s response to the amended complaint is
not yet due.
Lenzi v. Apple Canada, Inc.
(filed June 7, 2005, Superior Court, Montreal, Quebec)
Plaintiff filed a purported class action
allegedly on behalf of Quebec customers claiming false advertising and breach
of warranty relating to iPod battery life. Plaintiff sought authorization to institute a class action
on behalf of Generations 1, 2 and 3 iPod owners in Quebec. On February 2,
2006, the Court dismissed Plaintiff s motion for authorization to institute a class action.
Plaintiff has appealed this ruling.
MacTech Systems v. Apple Computer, Inc.;
Macadam v. Apple Computer, Inc.; Computer International, Inc. v.
Apple Computer, Inc.; Elite Computers and Software, Inc. v.
Apple Computer, Inc.; The Neighborhood Computer Store v. Apple
Computer, Inc.; MacAccessory Center, Inc. v. Apple Computer, Inc.;
Creative Online Computer Services, Inc., DBA MacOnline v. Apple Computer, Inc.;
MacGuys, Inc. v. Apple Computer, Inc. (all in Santa
Clara County Superior Court)
Eight resellers filed similar lawsuits against the
Company between late 2002 and early 2006 for various causes of action including
breach of contract, fraud, negligent and intentional interference with economic
relationship, negligent misrepresentation, trade libel, unfair competition and
false advertising. Plaintiffs request unspecified damages and other relief. The
Company answered the Computer International complaint on November 12,
2003, denying all allegations and asserting numerous affirmative defenses. The
Company filed an answer in the Macadam case on December 3, 2004 denying
all allegations and asserting numerous defenses. Three of the other Plaintiffs
filed amended complaints on February 7, 2005, and on March 16, 2005
the Company filed answers to these claims denying all allegations and asserting
numerous affirmative defenses. A sixth Plaintiff, MacAccessory Center, filed a
complaint on February 23, 2005. The Company filed an answer to this
complaint on April 20, 2005 denying all allegations and asserting numerous
affirmative defenses. On February 28, 2006, MacGuys and Creative Online
filed complaints against the Company. The Company s responses to these
complaints are not yet due. All of these cases with the exception of Macadam
are in discovery and are coordinated (along with the Branning class action)
in Santa Clara Superior Court. The cases (except Branning, MacGuys and Creative
Online) are set for trial on November 27, 2006. On December 19, 2005,
Tom Santos, Macadam s principal and an original Plaintiff in the Macadam case,
filed a Fifth Amended Complaint on his own behalf (not on behalf of Macadam)
alleging fraud, violations of California Business & Professional Code
17200 (unfair competition), California Business & Professional Code
39
17500 (false advertising) and the Consumer Legal
Remedies Act. The Company filed a demurrer to Santos amended complaint and a
special motion to strike the defamation cause of action on January 20,
2006. Those motions were heard on February 17, 2006, and the Court
sustained the demurrer without leave to amend as to one cause of action,
overruled the demurrer as to one cause of action and sustained the demurrer
with leave to amend as to two causes of action. The Court also denied the
special motion to strike. Santos has not yet filed a further amended complaint.
The Company also filed a cross complaint against Santos on January 20,
2006 alleging violations of California Business & Professional Code 17200,
fraud and deceit, breach of contract, and violation of California Penal Code 502.
On October 1, 2003, one of the reseller
Plaintiffs, Macadam, was deauthorized as an Apple reseller. Macadam filed a
motion for a temporary order to reinstate it as a reseller, which the Court
denied. The Court denied Macadam s motion for a preliminary injunction on December 19,
2003. On December 6, 2004 Macadam filed for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy in the
Northern District of California, which placed a stay on the litigation as to
Macadam only. The Company filed a claim in the bankruptcy proceedings on February 16,
2005. The Macadam bankruptcy case was converted to Chapter 7 (liquidation) on April 29,
2005. The Company has reached a tentative settlement of the Macadam case with
the Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Trustee. The Bankruptcy Court denied, without
prejudice, the Trustee s motion to approve that settlement on April 7,
2006. We expect the Trustee to re-file the motion to approve the settlement
with further support.
Macsolutions
Inc. v. Apple Computer, Inc.
Plaintiff Macsolutions, Inc.,
an Apple authorized reseller, filed this lawsuit against the Company on January 20,
2006 alleging breach of contract, fraud, misappropriation of trade secrets,
intentional interference with economic advantage, violation of the Cartwright
Act, violation of California Business & Professions Code 17200 (unfair business practices) and
fraudulent concealment. The factual allegations in this complaint are similar
to those in the eight other reseller cases and the Branning class action.
Principally, Plaintiffs allege that the Company has treated Macsolutions
unfairly compared to other resellers, that the Company has competed unfairly in
opening the Apple Retail stores, and has allegedly sold used goods as new. The
Company s response is not yet due.
Premier International
Associates LLC v. Apple Computer, Inc.
Plaintiff Premier
International Associates LLC filed this action on November 3, 2005 in the
United States District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, Marshall
Division, alleging infringement by the Company of U.S. Patents 6,243,725 and
6,763,345 both entitled List Building System.
The complaint seeks unspecified damages and other relief. The Company
filed an answer on January 13, 2006 denying all material allegations and
asserting numerous affirmative defenses. The Company also asserted counter
claims for a declaratory judgment of noninfringement and invalidity.
Quantum Technology
Management, Ltd. v. Apple Computer, Inc.
Plaintiff filed this action
on December 21, 2005 in the United States Court for the District of
Maryland against the Company and Fingerworks Ltd., alleging infringement of
U.S. Patent number 5,730,165 entitled Time Domain Capacitive Field Detector. The complaint seeks unspecified damages and
other relief. The Company s response is not yet due.
Slattery
v. Apple Computer, Inc.
Plaintiff filed this purported class action on January 3,
2005 in the United States District Court for the Northern District of
California alleging various claims including alleged unlawful tying of music
purchased on the iTunes Music Store with the purchase of iPods and vice versa
and unlawful acquisition or maintenance of monopoly market power. Plaintiff s
complaint alleged violations of 1 and 2 of the Sherman Act (15 U.S.C. 1 and 2), California
Business and Professions Code 16700
et seq. (the Cartwright Act), California Business and Professions Code 17200 (unfair competition), common
law unjust enrichment and common law monopolization. Plaintiff seeks
unspecified damages and other relief. The Company filed a motion to dismiss on February 10,
2005. On September 9, 2005, the Court denied the motion in part and
granted it in part. Plaintiff filed an amended complaint on September 23,
2005 and the Company filed an answer on October 18, 2005. On May 8,
2006, the Court will hear Plaintiff s motion for leave to file a second amended
complaint that substitutes two new plaintiffs for Slattery.
St-Germain v. Apple Canada, Inc.
Plaintiff filed this case in
Montreal, Quebec, Canada, on August 5, 2005, seeking authorization to
institute a class action for the refund by the Company of the Canadian
Private Copying Levy that was applied to the iPod purchase
40
price in Quebec between December 12,
2003 and December 14, 2004 but later declared invalid by the Canadian
Court. The Company has completed a refund program for this levy. A class certification
hearing took place January 13, 2006. On February 24, 2006 the Court
granted class certification and notice was published during the last week
of March 2006.
Teleshuttle
Technologies, LLC and BTG International Inc. v. Microsoft Corporation
and Apple Computer, Inc.
Plaintiffs filed this case on July 20, 2004 in
United States District Court for the Northern District of California alleging
infringement of U.S. patent 6,557,054, entitled Method and System for
Distributing Updates by Presenting Directory of Software Available for User
Installation That is Not Already Installed on User Station. Plaintiffs filed
an amended complaint on September 7, 2004, adding a second patent, U.S.
patent 6,769,009 entitled Method and System for Selecting a Personalized Set
of Information Channels. Plaintiffs seek unspecified damages and other relief.
The Company filed an answer on October 18, 2004, denying all material
allegations and asserting numerous affirmative defenses. On August 22,
2005, the Company filed an amended answer to add charges of inequitable conduct.
The parties reached a settlement and on April 7, 2006, the Court entered
an order dismissing the complaint. The matter is now concluded. Settlement of
this matter did not have a material effect on the Company s financial position
or results of operations.
Tse
v. Apple Computer, Inc. et al.
Plaintiff Ho Keung Tse filed
this action against the Company and other defendants on August 5, 2005 in
the United States District Court for the District of Maryland alleging
infringement by the Company of U.S. Patent 6,665,797 entitled Protection of
Software Again [sic] Against Unauthorized Use.
The complaint seeks unspecified damages and other relief. The Company
filed an answer on October 31, 2005 denying all material allegations and
asserting numerous affirmative defenses. On October 28, 2005, the Company
and the other defendants filed a motion to transfer the case to the Northern
District of California.
Union Federale des Consummateurs - Que Choisir v.
Apple Computer France S.A.R.L. and iTunes S.A.R.L.
Plaintiff, a consumer
association in France, filed this complaint on February 9, 2005 alleging
that the above-listed entities are violating consumer law by (1) omitting
to mention that the iPod is allegedly not compatible with music from online
music services other than the iTunes Music Store and that the music from the
iTunes Music Store is only compatible with the iPod and (2) allegedly
tying the sales of iPods to the iTunes Music Store and vice versa. Plaintiff
seeks damages, injunctive relief and other relief. The first hearing on the
case took place on May 24, 2005. The Company s response to the complaint
was served on November 8, 2005. Plaintiff s responsive pleading was filed
on February 10, 2006. The Company s reply submission is not yet due.
Wimmer v. Apple Computer, Inc.
(originally filed as Tomczak v. Apple Computer, Inc.
on October 19, 2005 in the United States District Court for the Northern
District of California, San Jose Division; amended complaint filed October 26,
2005); Moschella, et al., v. Apple Computer, Inc. (filed October 26, 2005
United States District Court for the Northern District of California, San Jose
Division); Calado, et al. v. Apple
Computer, Inc. (filed October 26, 2005, Los Angeles County
Superior Court); Kahan, et al., v. Apple Computer, Inc.
(filed October 31, 2005, United States District Court for the Southern
District of New York); Jennings, et al., v. Apple
Computer, Inc. (filed November 4, 2005, United States
District Court for the Northern District of California, San Jose Division); Rappel v. Apple Computer, Inc. (filed on November 23,
2005, United States District Court for the District of New Jersey); Mayo v. Apple Computer, Inc. (filed on December 7,
2005, United States District Court for the Middle District of Louisiana); Valencia v. Apple Computer, Inc. (filed on December 22,
2005, United States District Court for the Northern District of California); Williamson v. Apple Computer, Inc. (filed on December 29,
2005, United States District Court for the Middle District of Louisiana); Sioson v. Apple Computer, Inc.
(filed on February 9, 2006, San Mateo County Superior Court; First Amended
Complaint filed March 16, 2006)
These federal and state
court complaints allege that the Company s iPod nano was defectively designed
so that it scratches excessively during normal use, rendering the screen
unreadable. The Wimmer and Moschella actions were brought on behalf of
purported nationwide classes of iPod nano purchasers, with the exception of
California purchasers, and allege violations of the consumer protection,
express and implied warranty statutes of each state covered by the putative class definition,
as well as negligent misrepresentation and unjust enrichment under the common
laws of these jurisdictions. The Calado action was brought on behalf of a
purported California class of iPod nano purchasers and asserts claims for
alleged violation of California Business & Professions Code 17200
(unfair competition), California Business & Professions Code 17500
(false advertising), the Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA), breaches of
express and implied warranties, negligent misrepresentation and unjust
enrichment. The Jennings action was brought on behalf of a purported class of
all iPod nano purchasers outside of the United States,
41
based upon alleged
violations of the same California statutes as in the Calado complaint. The
Kahan action was brought on behalf of a purported New York class of iPod
nano purchasers and alleges claims under the New York unfair competition law,
breach of express warranty and unjust enrichment. The Rappel complaint is filed on behalf of a
purported New Jersey class of purchasers and alleges claims under the New
Jersey Consumer Fraud Acts and for breach of warranty and unjust enrichment. The
Mayo and Williamson complaints were both brought on behalf of a Louisiana class of
purchasers, and allege breach of warranties, unjust enrichment and violations
of the Louisiana Products Liability Act. The Valencia complaint was brought on
behalf of a worldwide class of purchasers and alleges breach of
warranties, fraudulent concealment, violations of California s Business &
Professions Code 17200 and 17500 and the CLRA,
negligent misrepresentation and unjust enrichment. The complaints seek damages and various other
remedies. The Sioson complaint was brought on behalf of a purported class of
California purchasers. The complaint alleges breach of express and implied
warranties, unjust enrichment, fraudulent concealment, and violation of
California Business & Professions Code 17200 (unfair competition),
California Business & Professions Code 17500 (false
advertising), the CLRA; it purports to seek relief based upon alleged scratching
and screen cracking. The Company filed a motion for transfer and consolidation
before Judicial Panel on Multi-District Litigation (MDL) to have all of the
federal cases transferred to the Northern District of California and
consolidated for pre-trial purposes. In an order dated April 17,
2006, the MDL Panel granted the Company s motion and transferred the federal
cases to the Northern District of California before the Honorable Ronald M.
Whyte. The federal cases are all stayed pending further order by Judge Whyte
following the MDL Panel s order, and accordingly the responses to the federal
complaints are not yet due. The Company s response to the Calado complaint is
not yet due. The case is stayed pending a ruling on the petition for
coordination with the Sioson action. The Court has recommended coordination of
these two cases in Los Angeles Superior Court.
Two similar complaints, Carpentier v. Apple Canada, Inc., and Royer-Brennan v. Apple Computer, Inc. and Apple Canada, Inc. were
filed in Montreal, Quebec, Canada, on October 27, 2005 and November 9,
2005, respectively, seeking authorization to institute class actions on
behalf of iPod nano purchasers in Quebec. A similar complaint, Mund v. Apple Canada Inc. and Apple Computer, Inc., was