Apple

Corps Ltd. v. Apple Computer, Inc.; Apple Computer, Inc. v.

Apple Corps Ltd.

Plaintiff Apple Corps filed this action on July 4,

2003 in the High Court of Justice, Chancery Division, in London alleging that

the Company has breached a 1991 agreement that resolved earlier trademark

litigation between the parties regarding use of certain Apple marks. Plaintiff

seeks an injunction, unspecified damages, and other relief. The Company filed a

motion on October 13, 2003, challenging jurisdiction in the U.K. The Court

denied this motion on April 7, 2004. The Company filed an appeal of the

Court s decision but subsequently withdrew the appeal. In November 2004,

Plaintiff served the Company with an Amended Bill of Particulars and on December 23,

2004, the Company filed a Defence. On November 24, 2005, Plaintiff filed a

Re-Amended Bill of Particulars and the Company filed its Defence on December 16,

2005. Trial took place from March 29, 2006 through April 5, 2006. The

parties await a ruling.

On October 8, 2003, the Company filed a lawsuit

against Apple Corps in the United States District Court for the Northern

District of California requesting a declaratory judgment that the Company has

not breached the 1991 agreement. Apple Corps challenged jurisdiction in the

California case but the Court denied that challenge on March 25, 2004.

Apple Corps subsequently prevailed on a motion to stay the California case

during the pendency of the U.K. action. The Company has dismissed the

California lawsuit without prejudice.

Bader v.

Anderson; Bader v. Apple Computer, Inc. et al.

Plaintiff filed this purported shareholder derivative

action against the Company and each of its current executive officers and

members of its Board of Directors on May 19, 2005 in Santa Clara County

Superior Court asserting claims for breach of fiduciary duty, material

misstatements and omissions, and violations of California Businesses and

Professions Code 17200 (unfair competition). Plaintiff alleges that the

Company s March 14, 2005, proxy statement was false and misleading for

failure to disclose certain information relating to the Apple Computer, Inc.

Performance Bonus Plan, which was approved by shareholders at the annual

meeting held on April 21, 2005. Plaintiff, who ostensibly brings suit on

the Company s behalf, has made no demand on the Board of Directors and alleges

that such demand is excused. Plaintiff seeks injunctive and other relief for

purported injury to the Company. On July 27, 2005, Plaintiff filed an

amended complaint alleging that, in addition to the purported derivative

claims, adoption of the

bonus plan and distribution of the proxy statement describing that plan also

inflicted injury on her directly as an individual shareholder. On January 10,

2006, the Court sustained defendants demurrer to the amended complaint, with

leave to amend. Plaintiff filed a second amended complaint on February 7,

2006. The Company filed a demurrer to that complaint on April 20, 2006 and

a hearing is scheduled for June 13, 2006.

Baghdasarian,

et al. v. Apple Computer, Inc.

Plaintiffs filed this action

in Los Angeles County Superior Court on October 31, 2005, on behalf of a

purported nationwide class of all purchasers of all Apple wireless

products (router, modem, or adaptor) sold at any time. The complaint alleges

that the Company misrepresented the transmission rates of these products. The complaint

alleges causes of action for breach of express warranty and for violations of

the Consumer Legal Remedies Act, California Business & Professions

Code 17200 (unfair competition) and California Business & Professions

Code 17500 (false advertising). The complaint seeks damages and equitable

remedies. The Company filed an answer denying all allegations and asserting

numerous affirmative defenses to the complaint on December 15, 2005.

Birdsong v. Apple Computer, Inc.; Patterson v. Apple

Computer, Inc.

These federal court

complaints allege that the Company s iPod music players, and the ear bud

headphones sold with them, are inherently defective in design and are sold

without adequate warnings concerning the risk of noise-induced hearing loss by

iPod users. The Birdsong action was initially filed on January 30, 2006 in

the United States Antitrust Court for the Western District of Louisiana on

behalf of a purported Louisiana class of iPod purchasers and alleges

violations of the Louisiana Products Liability Act, breaches of implied

warranties, unjust enrichment and negligent misrepresentation. The Patterson

action was filed on January 31, 2006 in the United States Antitrust Court

for the Northern District of California on behalf of a purported class of

all iPod purchasers within the four-year period before January 31, 2006. That

action alleges breaches of implied and express warranties, violations of

California Business & Professions Code 17200 (unfair competition),

California Business & Professions Code 17500 (false advertising), the

Consumer Legal Remedies Act, breaches of express and implied warranties,

negligent misrepresentation and unjust enrichment. The Birdsong action has been

transferred to the Northern District of California and assigned to the same

judge as in Patterson. The Company s responses to the Birdsong and Patterson

complaints are not yet due.

36

similar complaint, Royer-Brennan v. Apple Computer, Inc.

and Apple Canada, Inc., was filed in Montreal, Quebec, Canada,

on February 1, 2006, seeking authorization to institute a class action

on behalf of iPod purchasers in Quebec. Preliminary motions must be filed by May 5,

2006.

Branning

et al. v. Apple Computer, Inc.

Plaintiffs originally filed this purported class action

in San Francisco County Superior Court on February 17, 2005. The initial

complaint alleged violations of California Business & Professions Code

17200 (unfair

competition) and violation of the Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA) regarding

a variety of purportedly unfair and unlawful conduct including, but not limited

to, allegedly selling used computers as new and failing to honor warranties. Plaintiffs

also brought causes of action for misappropriation of trade secrets, breach of

contract, and violation of the Song-Beverly Act. Plaintiffs requested

unspecified damages and other relief. On May 9, 2005, the Court granted

the Company s motion to transfer the case to Santa Clara County Superior Court.

On May 2, 2005, Plaintiffs filed an amended complaint adding two new named

plaintiffs and three new causes of action including a claim for treble damages

under the Cartwright Act (California Business & Professions Code 16700 et seq.) and a claim for false

advertising. The Company filed a demurrer to the amended complaint, which the

Court sustained in its entirety on November 10, 2005. The Court granted

Plaintiffs leave to amend and they filed an amended complaint on December 29,

2005. Plaintiffs amended complaint

added three plaintiffs and alleged many of the same factual claims as the

previous complaints, such as alleged selling of used equipment as new, alleged

failure to honor warranties and service contracts for the consumer plaintiffs,

and alleged fraud related to the opening of the Apple Retail stores. Plaintiffs continued to assert causes of

action for unfair competition ( 17200), violations of the CLRA, breach of

contract, misappropriation of trade secrets, violations of the Cartwright Act

and alleged new causes of action for fraud, conversion and breach of the

implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. The Company filed a

demurrer to the amended complaint on January 31, 2006, which the Court

sustained on March 3, 2006 on sixteen of seventeen causes of action.

Butzer, et al. v.

Apple Computer, Inc.; Wirges v. Apple Computer, Inc.; Blackwell v.

Apple Computer, Inc.

Plaintiffs filed the Butzer

action on August 23, 2005, in the United States District Court for the

Northern District of California, San Jose Division, on behalf of a purported

nationwide class of all purchasers of the Company s PowerBook G4 portable

computers. The complaint alleges defects in the memory of the computers. The

complaint alleges that this purported defect extends to other series of

the Company s portables and states that plaintiffs reserve the right to amend

the complaint to include these other series. Plaintiffs assert claims for

alleged violations of California Business & Professions Code 17200

(unfair competition), California Business & Professions Code 17500

(false advertising), the Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA) and the

Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act. The complaint seeks remedies including

restitution and/or damages and injunctive relief. The Wirges action was filed

on January 20, 2006 in the United States District Court for the Eastern

District of Arkansas, also on behalf of a purported nationwide class, and makes

similar allegations. Plaintiffs assert claims for breach of warranties,

violation of the Magnuson Moss Act, strict products liability and unjust

enrichment. The complaint seeks restitution, damages and other remedies. The

Blackwell action was filed on February 10, 2006, on behalf of a purported

nationwide class, and makes identical allegations to those made in the Butzer

case. Plaintiffs assert claims for breach of express and implied warranties,

violation of the California CLRA, violation of the California Song-Beverly Act,

false advertising and unfair competition. The complaint seeks restitution, an

injunction and other remedies. The Company filed an answer to the Butzer

complaint on October 19, 2005 denying all material allegations and

asserting numerous affirmative defenses. The case is in discovery. The Company

filed an answer to the Wirges action on February 28, 2006. The Company has

filed a motion to transfer the Wirges case to the Northern District of

California. The Company filed an answer to the Blackwell complaint on March 15,

2006 denying all material allegations and asserting numerous affirmative

defenses.

Compression Labs, Inc. v. Apple Computer, Inc.,

et al.; Apple v. Compression Labs, Inc., et al.

Plaintiff Compression Labs, Inc. filed this

patent infringement action on April 22, 2004 against the Company and

twenty-seven other defendants in the United States District Court for the

Eastern District of Texas, Marshall Division, alleging infringement of U.S.

patent 4,698,672 (the 672 patent). Plaintiff alleges that the Company

infringes the patent by complying with the JPEG standard as defined by CCITT

Recommendation T.81 entitled Information Technology Digital Compression and

Coding of Continuous Tone Still Images Requirements and Guidelines. Plaintiff

seeks unspecified damages and other relief.

On July 2, 2004, the Company and several other

defendants in the Texas action filed a lawsuit in the United States District

Court in Delaware against Compression Labs, Inc. and two other companies,

requesting a declaratory

37

judgment of non-infringement, invalidity, implied license

and unenforceability with respect to the 672 patent. Additional actions

regarding this patent have been filed in other jurisdictions. On February 16,

2005, the Panel on Multi-District Litigation (MDL) granted a petition filed by

certain defendants seeking coordination and transfer of all of these cases to

one court for pre-trial proceedings. The MDL Panel has transferred all of the

cases to the Northern District of California. The defendants in the Texas and

Delaware actions had filed motions to dismiss prior to the transfer and both

motions are still pending. A Markman hearing took place on March 9, 2006

and the parties await a ruling.

Contois Music Technology

LLC v. Apple Computer, Inc.

Plaintiff Contois Music

Technology ( Contois ) filed this action on June 13, 2005 in the

United States District Court for Vermont, alleging infringement by the Company

of U.S. Patent No. 5,864,868, entitled Computer Control System and User

Interface for Media Playing Devices. The complaint, which was served on October 4,

2005, seeks unspecified damages and other relief. The Company filed an answer

on November 23, 2005 denying all material allegations and asserting

numerous affirmative defenses. A Markman hearing is scheduled for June 13,

2006.

Two similar complaints

relative to iPod battery life, Wolfe v. Apple and Hirst v. Apple, were filed in Toronto, Ontario, Canada on August 15,

2005 and September 12, 2005, respectively. Both actions define the

purported class as a national class consisting of all persons in

Canada who have purchased or who own an iPod. In addition, a similar complaint

regarding iPod battery life, Hamiliton v. Apple

Computer, Inc. and Apple Canada, Inc.

was filed in Calgary, Alberta, Canada on October 5, 2005, purportedly on

behalf of all purchasers of iPods in Alberta, Canada. That complaint has not

been served. A motion for certification is set for June 9, 2006.

Davis v.

Apple Computer, Inc.

Plaintiff filed this purported class action in

San Francisco County Superior Court on December 5, 2002, alleging that the

Company engaged in unfair and deceptive business practices relating to its

AppleCare Extended Service and Warranty Plan. Plaintiff asserts causes of

action for violation of California Business & Professions Code 17200 (unfair competition),

California Business & Professions Code 17500 (false advertising), breach of the Song-Beverly Warranty

Act, intentional misrepresentation and concealment. Plaintiff requests

unspecified damages and other relief. The Company filed a demurrer and motion

to strike which were granted, in part, and Plaintiff filed an amended

complaint. The Company filed an answer on April 17, 2003 denying all

allegations and asserting numerous affirmative defenses. Plaintiff subsequently

amended his complaint. On October 29, 2003, the Company filed a motion to

disqualify Plaintiff s counsel in his role as counsel to the purported class and

to the general public. The Court granted the motion but allowed Plaintiff to

retain substitute counsel. Plaintiff did engage new counsel for the general

public, but not for the class. The Company moved to disqualify Plaintiff s new

counsel and to have the Court dismiss the general public claims for equitable

relief. The Court declined to disqualify Plaintiff s new counsel or to dismiss

the equitable claims, but did confirm that the class action claims are

dismissed. The Company appealed the ruling and the case was stayed pending the

outcome of the appeal. The Court of Appeals denied the appeal on August 17,

2005, affirming the trial court s decision. The Company filed a Petition for

review with the California Supreme Court, which was denied on November 23,

2005. The case has been remanded back to the trial court.

European

Commission Investigation

The European Commission has notified the Company that

it is investigating certain matters relating to the iTunes Music Store in the

European Union (EU). The European Commission is investigating claims made by

Which?, a United Kingdom (UK) consumer association, that the Company is

violating EU competition law by charging more for online music in the UK than

in Eurozone countries and preventing UK consumers from purchasing online music

from the iTunes Music Store for Eurozone countries. The Which? claims were

originally lodged with the UK Office of Fair Trading, which subsequently

referred them to the European Commission. The European Commission is

investigating the charges under Articles 81 and 82 of the European Commission

Treaty.

Gillis

et al. v. Apple Computer, Inc.

Plaintiffs

filed this purported class action on December 23, 2005 in San Diego

County Superior Court alleging that the Company has misrepresented the hard

drive capacity of two Powerbook G4 computers: the 12 inch, 1.5 GHz computer

with 512 MB of memory and a 100GB hard drive; and the 15 inch, 1.67 GHz

computer with 1GB of memory and a 100GB hard drive. Plaintiffs allege that the

Company s standard disclosure on its packaging regarding hard drive size was

not present on the packaging for these two models. The complaint alleges

violations of the California Business & Profession Code 17200 (unfair

competition), California Business & Profession Code 17500 (false

advertising), the Consumer Legal Remedies Act, and causes of action for deceit

and negligent

38

misrepresentation.

Plaintiffs seek restitution and other relief. On February 28, 2006, the

Company filed a demurrer and a motion to strike. The Company withdrew the

demurrer and motion to strike per stipulations and await an amended complaint.

Goldberg, et al. v. Apple Computer, Inc., et

al. (f.k.a. Dan v. Apple Computer, Inc. )

Plaintiffs filed this purported class action on September 22,

2003 in Los Angeles County Superior Court against the Company and other members

of the computer industry on behalf of an alleged nationwide class of

purchasers of certain computer hard drives. The case alleges violations of

California Business and Professions Code 17200 (unfair competition), the Consumer Legal Remedies Act and

false advertising related to the size of the drives. Plaintiffs allege that

calculation of hard drive size using the decimal method misrepresents the

actual size of the drive. The complaint seeks restitution and other relief.

Plaintiffs filed an amended complaint on March 30, 2004 and the Company

filed an answer on September 23, 2004, denying all allegations and

asserting numerous affirmative defenses. Defendants filed a motion to strike

portions of the complaint based on sales by resellers and filed a motion for

judgment on the pleadings based upon Proposition 64. The Court granted both

motions at a hearing on April 6, 2005. Plaintiffs thereafter filed an

amended complaint on May 6, 2005. The Defendants filed a demurrer on June 6,

2005, which was heard on August 22, 2005. The Court granted the demurrer

in part and denied it in part. Plaintiffs filed an amended complaint and the

Company filed an answer on December 15, 2005 denying all allegations and

asserting numerous assertive defenses.

Honeywell International, Inc., et al. v.

Apple Computer, Inc., et al.

Plaintiffs Honeywell International, Inc. and

Honeywell Intellectual Properties, Inc. filed this action on October 6,

2004 in the United States District Court in Delaware alleging infringement by

the Company and other defendants of U.S. patent 5,280,371 entitled Directional

Diffuser for a Liquid Crystal Display. Plaintiffs seek unspecified damages and

other relief. The Company filed an answer on December 21, 2004 denying all

material allegations and asserting numerous affirmative defenses. The Company

has tendered the case to several LCD manufacturer suppliers. On May 18,

2005 the Court stayed the case against the Company and the other

non-manufacturer defendants. Plaintiffs filed an amended complaint on November 7,

2005 adding additional defendants and expanding the scope of the accused

products. Given the stay, the Company s response to the amended complaint is

not yet due.

Lenzi v. Apple Canada, Inc.

(filed June 7, 2005, Superior Court, Montreal, Quebec)

Plaintiff filed a purported class action

allegedly on behalf of Quebec customers claiming false advertising and breach

of warranty relating to iPod battery life. Plaintiff sought authorization to institute a class action

on behalf of Generations 1, 2 and 3 iPod owners in Quebec. On February 2,

2006, the Court dismissed Plaintiff s motion for authorization to institute a class action.

Plaintiff has appealed this ruling.

MacTech Systems v. Apple Computer, Inc.;

Macadam v. Apple Computer, Inc.; Computer International, Inc. v.

Apple Computer, Inc.; Elite Computers and Software, Inc. v.

Apple Computer, Inc.; The Neighborhood Computer Store v. Apple

Computer, Inc.; MacAccessory Center, Inc. v. Apple Computer, Inc.;

Creative Online Computer Services, Inc., DBA MacOnline v. Apple Computer, Inc.;

MacGuys, Inc. v. Apple Computer, Inc. (all in Santa

Clara County Superior Court)

Eight resellers filed similar lawsuits against the

Company between late 2002 and early 2006 for various causes of action including

breach of contract, fraud, negligent and intentional interference with economic

relationship, negligent misrepresentation, trade libel, unfair competition and

false advertising. Plaintiffs request unspecified damages and other relief. The

Company answered the Computer International complaint on November 12,

2003, denying all allegations and asserting numerous affirmative defenses. The

Company filed an answer in the Macadam case on December 3, 2004 denying

all allegations and asserting numerous defenses. Three of the other Plaintiffs

filed amended complaints on February 7, 2005, and on March 16, 2005

the Company filed answers to these claims denying all allegations and asserting

numerous affirmative defenses. A sixth Plaintiff, MacAccessory Center, filed a

complaint on February 23, 2005. The Company filed an answer to this

complaint on April 20, 2005 denying all allegations and asserting numerous

affirmative defenses. On February 28, 2006, MacGuys and Creative Online

filed complaints against the Company. The Company s responses to these

complaints are not yet due. All of these cases with the exception of Macadam

are in discovery and are coordinated (along with the Branning class action)

in Santa Clara Superior Court. The cases (except Branning, MacGuys and Creative

Online) are set for trial on November 27, 2006. On December 19, 2005,

Tom Santos, Macadam s principal and an original Plaintiff in the Macadam case,

filed a Fifth Amended Complaint on his own behalf (not on behalf of Macadam)

alleging fraud, violations of California Business & Professional Code

17200 (unfair competition), California Business & Professional Code

39

17500 (false advertising) and the Consumer Legal

Remedies Act. The Company filed a demurrer to Santos amended complaint and a

special motion to strike the defamation cause of action on January 20,

2006. Those motions were heard on February 17, 2006, and the Court

sustained the demurrer without leave to amend as to one cause of action,

overruled the demurrer as to one cause of action and sustained the demurrer

with leave to amend as to two causes of action. The Court also denied the

special motion to strike. Santos has not yet filed a further amended complaint.

The Company also filed a cross complaint against Santos on January 20,

2006 alleging violations of California Business & Professional Code 17200,

fraud and deceit, breach of contract, and violation of California Penal Code 502.

On October 1, 2003, one of the reseller

Plaintiffs, Macadam, was deauthorized as an Apple reseller. Macadam filed a

motion for a temporary order to reinstate it as a reseller, which the Court

denied. The Court denied Macadam s motion for a preliminary injunction on December 19,

2003. On December 6, 2004 Macadam filed for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy in the

Northern District of California, which placed a stay on the litigation as to

Macadam only. The Company filed a claim in the bankruptcy proceedings on February 16,

2005. The Macadam bankruptcy case was converted to Chapter 7 (liquidation) on April 29,

2005. The Company has reached a tentative settlement of the Macadam case with

the Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Trustee. The Bankruptcy Court denied, without

prejudice, the Trustee s motion to approve that settlement on April 7,

2006. We expect the Trustee to re-file the motion to approve the settlement

with further support.

Macsolutions

Inc. v. Apple Computer, Inc.

Plaintiff Macsolutions, Inc.,

an Apple authorized reseller, filed this lawsuit against the Company on January 20,

2006 alleging breach of contract, fraud, misappropriation of trade secrets,

intentional interference with economic advantage, violation of the Cartwright

Act, violation of California Business & Professions Code 17200 (unfair business practices) and

fraudulent concealment. The factual allegations in this complaint are similar

to those in the eight other reseller cases and the Branning class action.

Principally, Plaintiffs allege that the Company has treated Macsolutions

unfairly compared to other resellers, that the Company has competed unfairly in

opening the Apple Retail stores, and has allegedly sold used goods as new. The

Company s response is not yet due.

Premier International

Associates LLC v. Apple Computer, Inc.

Plaintiff Premier

International Associates LLC filed this action on November 3, 2005 in the

United States District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, Marshall

Division, alleging infringement by the Company of U.S. Patents 6,243,725 and

6,763,345 both entitled List Building System.

The complaint seeks unspecified damages and other relief. The Company

filed an answer on January 13, 2006 denying all material allegations and

asserting numerous affirmative defenses. The Company also asserted counter

claims for a declaratory judgment of noninfringement and invalidity.

Quantum Technology

Management, Ltd. v. Apple Computer, Inc.

Plaintiff filed this action

on December 21, 2005 in the United States Court for the District of

Maryland against the Company and Fingerworks Ltd., alleging infringement of

U.S. Patent number 5,730,165 entitled Time Domain Capacitive Field Detector. The complaint seeks unspecified damages and

other relief. The Company s response is not yet due.

Slattery

v. Apple Computer, Inc.

Plaintiff filed this purported class action on January 3,

2005 in the United States District Court for the Northern District of

California alleging various claims including alleged unlawful tying of music

purchased on the iTunes Music Store with the purchase of iPods and vice versa

and unlawful acquisition or maintenance of monopoly market power. Plaintiff s

complaint alleged violations of 1 and 2 of the Sherman Act (15 U.S.C. 1 and 2), California

Business and Professions Code 16700

et seq. (the Cartwright Act), California Business and Professions Code 17200 (unfair competition), common

law unjust enrichment and common law monopolization. Plaintiff seeks

unspecified damages and other relief. The Company filed a motion to dismiss on February 10,

2005. On September 9, 2005, the Court denied the motion in part and

granted it in part. Plaintiff filed an amended complaint on September 23,

2005 and the Company filed an answer on October 18, 2005. On May 8,

2006, the Court will hear Plaintiff s motion for leave to file a second amended

complaint that substitutes two new plaintiffs for Slattery.

St-Germain v. Apple Canada, Inc.

Plaintiff filed this case in

Montreal, Quebec, Canada, on August 5, 2005, seeking authorization to

institute a class action for the refund by the Company of the Canadian

Private Copying Levy that was applied to the iPod purchase

40

price in Quebec between December 12,

2003 and December 14, 2004 but later declared invalid by the Canadian

Court. The Company has completed a refund program for this levy. A class certification

hearing took place January 13, 2006. On February 24, 2006 the Court

granted class certification and notice was published during the last week

of March 2006.

Teleshuttle

Technologies, LLC and BTG International Inc. v. Microsoft Corporation

and Apple Computer, Inc.

Plaintiffs filed this case on July 20, 2004 in

United States District Court for the Northern District of California alleging

infringement of U.S. patent 6,557,054, entitled Method and System for

Distributing Updates by Presenting Directory of Software Available for User

Installation That is Not Already Installed on User Station. Plaintiffs filed

an amended complaint on September 7, 2004, adding a second patent, U.S.

patent 6,769,009 entitled Method and System for Selecting a Personalized Set

of Information Channels. Plaintiffs seek unspecified damages and other relief.

The Company filed an answer on October 18, 2004, denying all material

allegations and asserting numerous affirmative defenses. On August 22,

2005, the Company filed an amended answer to add charges of inequitable conduct.

The parties reached a settlement and on April 7, 2006, the Court entered

an order dismissing the complaint. The matter is now concluded. Settlement of

this matter did not have a material effect on the Company s financial position

or results of operations.

Tse

v. Apple Computer, Inc. et al.

Plaintiff Ho Keung Tse filed

this action against the Company and other defendants on August 5, 2005 in

the United States District Court for the District of Maryland alleging

infringement by the Company of U.S. Patent 6,665,797 entitled Protection of

Software Again [sic] Against Unauthorized Use.

The complaint seeks unspecified damages and other relief. The Company

filed an answer on October 31, 2005 denying all material allegations and

asserting numerous affirmative defenses. On October 28, 2005, the Company

and the other defendants filed a motion to transfer the case to the Northern

District of California.

Union Federale des Consummateurs - Que Choisir v.

Apple Computer France S.A.R.L. and iTunes S.A.R.L.

Plaintiff, a consumer

association in France, filed this complaint on February 9, 2005 alleging

that the above-listed entities are violating consumer law by (1) omitting

to mention that the iPod is allegedly not compatible with music from online

music services other than the iTunes Music Store and that the music from the

iTunes Music Store is only compatible with the iPod and (2) allegedly

tying the sales of iPods to the iTunes Music Store and vice versa. Plaintiff

seeks damages, injunctive relief and other relief. The first hearing on the

case took place on May 24, 2005. The Company s response to the complaint

was served on November 8, 2005. Plaintiff s responsive pleading was filed

on February 10, 2006. The Company s reply submission is not yet due.

Wimmer v. Apple Computer, Inc.

(originally filed as Tomczak v. Apple Computer, Inc.

on October 19, 2005 in the United States District Court for the Northern

District of California, San Jose Division; amended complaint filed October 26,

2005); Moschella, et al., v. Apple Computer, Inc. (filed October 26, 2005

United States District Court for the Northern District of California, San Jose

Division); Calado, et al. v. Apple

Computer, Inc. (filed October 26, 2005, Los Angeles County

Superior Court); Kahan, et al., v. Apple Computer, Inc.

(filed October 31, 2005, United States District Court for the Southern

District of New York); Jennings, et al., v. Apple

Computer, Inc. (filed November 4, 2005, United States

District Court for the Northern District of California, San Jose Division); Rappel v. Apple Computer, Inc. (filed on November 23,

2005, United States District Court for the District of New Jersey); Mayo v. Apple Computer, Inc. (filed on December 7,

2005, United States District Court for the Middle District of Louisiana); Valencia v. Apple Computer, Inc. (filed on December 22,

2005, United States District Court for the Northern District of California); Williamson v. Apple Computer, Inc. (filed on December 29,

2005, United States District Court for the Middle District of Louisiana); Sioson v. Apple Computer, Inc.

(filed on February 9, 2006, San Mateo County Superior Court; First Amended

Complaint filed March 16, 2006)

These federal and state

court complaints allege that the Company s iPod nano was defectively designed

so that it scratches excessively during normal use, rendering the screen

unreadable. The Wimmer and Moschella actions were brought on behalf of

purported nationwide classes of iPod nano purchasers, with the exception of

California purchasers, and allege violations of the consumer protection,

express and implied warranty statutes of each state covered by the putative class definition,

as well as negligent misrepresentation and unjust enrichment under the common

laws of these jurisdictions. The Calado action was brought on behalf of a

purported California class of iPod nano purchasers and asserts claims for

alleged violation of California Business & Professions Code 17200

(unfair competition), California Business & Professions Code 17500

(false advertising), the Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA), breaches of

express and implied warranties, negligent misrepresentation and unjust

enrichment. The Jennings action was brought on behalf of a purported class of

all iPod nano purchasers outside of the United States,

41

based upon alleged

violations of the same California statutes as in the Calado complaint. The

Kahan action was brought on behalf of a purported New York class of iPod

nano purchasers and alleges claims under the New York unfair competition law,

breach of express warranty and unjust enrichment. The Rappel complaint is filed on behalf of a

purported New Jersey class of purchasers and alleges claims under the New

Jersey Consumer Fraud Acts and for breach of warranty and unjust enrichment. The

Mayo and Williamson complaints were both brought on behalf of a Louisiana class of

purchasers, and allege breach of warranties, unjust enrichment and violations

of the Louisiana Products Liability Act. The Valencia complaint was brought on

behalf of a worldwide class of purchasers and alleges breach of

warranties, fraudulent concealment, violations of California s Business &

Professions Code 17200 and 17500 and the CLRA,

negligent misrepresentation and unjust enrichment. The complaints seek damages and various other

remedies. The Sioson complaint was brought on behalf of a purported class of

California purchasers. The complaint alleges breach of express and implied

warranties, unjust enrichment, fraudulent concealment, and violation of

California Business & Professions Code 17200 (unfair competition),

California Business & Professions Code 17500 (false

advertising), the CLRA; it purports to seek relief based upon alleged scratching

and screen cracking. The Company filed a motion for transfer and consolidation

before Judicial Panel on Multi-District Litigation (MDL) to have all of the

federal cases transferred to the Northern District of California and

consolidated for pre-trial purposes. In an order dated April 17,

2006, the MDL Panel granted the Company s motion and transferred the federal

cases to the Northern District of California before the Honorable Ronald M.

Whyte. The federal cases are all stayed pending further order by Judge Whyte

following the MDL Panel s order, and accordingly the responses to the federal

complaints are not yet due. The Company s response to the Calado complaint is

not yet due. The case is stayed pending a ruling on the petition for

coordination with the Sioson action. The Court has recommended coordination of

these two cases in Los Angeles Superior Court.

Two similar complaints, Carpentier v. Apple Canada, Inc., and Royer-Brennan v. Apple Computer, Inc. and Apple Canada, Inc. were

filed in Montreal, Quebec, Canada, on October 27, 2005 and November 9,

2005, respectively, seeking authorization to institute class actions on

behalf of iPod nano purchasers in Quebec. A similar complaint, Mund v. Apple Canada Inc. and Apple Computer, Inc., was

filed in Ontario, Canada on January 9, 2006 seeking authorization to

institute a class action on behalf of iPod nano purchasers in Canada. In

the two Quebec Class Actions, a motion to stay the Royer-Brennan suit for

lis pendens was heard by the Court on April 21, 2006. The parties await a

decision.

Item 1A. Risk Factors

Because

of the following factors, as well as other factors affecting the Company s

operating results and financial condition, past financial performance should

not be considered to be a reliable indicator of future performance, and

investors should not use historical trends to anticipate results or trends in

future periods.

General

economic conditions and current economic and political uncertainty could

adversely affect the demand for the Company s products and the

financial health of its suppliers, distributors,

and resellers.

The Company s operating performance depends

significantly on general economic conditions in the U.S. and abroad. At times

in the past, demand for the Company s products has been negatively impacted by

difficult global economic conditions. Additionally, some of the Company s

education customers appeared to be delaying technology purchases due to

concerns about the overall impact of the weaker economy and state budget

deficits on their available funding. Although recent macroeconomic trends seem

to indicate an economic recovery, continued uncertainty about future economic

conditions makes it difficult to forecast future demand for the Company s

products and related operating results. Should global and/or regional economic

conditions deteriorate, demand for the Company s products could be adversely

affected, as could the financial health of its suppliers, distributors, and

resellers.

War,

terrorism, public health issues or other business interruptions could disrupt

supply, delivery or demand of products, which could negatively affect the

Company s operations and performance.

War, terrorism, public

health issues and other business interruptions whether in the U.S. or abroad,

have caused and could cause damage or disruption to international commerce by

creating economic and political uncertainties that may have a strong

negative impact on the global economy, the Company, and the Company s suppliers

or customers. The Company s major business operations are subject to

interruption by earthquake, other natural disasters, fire, power shortages,

terrorist attacks and other hostile acts, labor disputes, public health issues,

and other events beyond its control. The majority of the Company s research and

development activities, its corporate headquarters, information technology

systems, and other critical business operations, including certain component

suppliers and manufacturing vendors, are located near major seismic faults.

Because the Company does not carry earthquake

42

insurance for direct

quake-related losses, the Company s operating results and financial condition

could be materially adversely affected in the event of a major earthquake or other

natural or manmade disaster.

Although it is impossible

to predict the occurrences or consequences of any such events, such events

could result in a decrease in demand for the Company s products, make it

difficult or impossible for the Company to deliver products to its customers or

to receive components from its suppliers, and could create delays and

inefficiencies in the Company s supply chain. In addition, should major public

health issues, including pandemics, arise, the Company could be negatively

impacted by the need for more stringent employee travel restrictions,

additional limitations in the availability of freight services, governmental

actions limiting the movement of products between various regions, delays in

production ramps of new products, and disruptions in the operations of the

Company s manufacturing vendors and component suppliers. The Company s

operating results and financial condition have been, and in the future may be,

adversely affected by these events.

The

market for personal computers and related peripherals and services, as well as

digital music devices and related services, is highly competitive. If the

Company is unable to effectively compete in these markets, its results of

operations could be adversely affected.

The personal computer

industry is highly competitive and is characterized by aggressive pricing

practices, downward pressure on gross margins, frequent introduction of new

products, short product life cycles, evolving industry standards, continual

improvement in product price/performance characteristics, rapid adoption of

technological and product advancements by competitors, price sensitivity on the

part of consumers, and a large number of competitors. Over the past

several years, price competition in the market for personal computers and

related peripherals has been particularly intense as competitors who sell

Windows and Linux based personal computers have aggressively cut prices and

lowered their product margins for personal computing products. The Company s

results of operations and financial condition have been, and in the future may continue

to be, adversely affected by these and other industry-wide pricing pressures

and downward pressures on gross margins.

The personal computer

industry has also been characterized by rapid technological advances in

software functionality, hardware performance, and features based on existing or

emerging industry standards. Further, as the personal computer industry and its

customers place more reliance on the Internet, an increasing number of Internet

devices that are smaller and simpler than traditional personal computers may compete

for market share with the Company s existing products. Several competitors of

the Company have either targeted or announced their intention to target certain

of the Company s key market segments, including consumer, education,

professional and consumer digital video editing, and design and publishing.

Several of the Company s competitors have introduced or announced plans to

introduce digital music products and/or online stores offering digital music

distribution that mimic many of the unique design, technical features, and

solutions of the Company s products. The Company has a significant number of

competitors, many of whom have greater financial, marketing, manufacturing, and

technological resources, as well as broader product lines and larger installed

customer bases than those of the Company. Additionally, there has been a trend

towards consolidation in the personal computer industry that has resulted in

larger and potentially stronger competitors in the Company s markets.

The Company is currently

the only maker of hardware using the Mac OS. The Mac OS has a minority market

share in the personal computer market, which is dominated by makers of computers

utilizing other competing operating systems, including Windows and Linux. The

Company s future operating results and financial condition are substantially

dependent on its ability to continue to develop improvements to the Macintosh

platform to maintain perceived design and functional advantages over

competing platforms. Additionally,

if unauthorized copies of the Mac OS are used on other companies hardware

products and result in decreased demand for the Company s hardware products,

the Company s results of operations may be adversely affected.

The Company is currently

focused on market opportunities related to digital music distribution and

related consumer electronic devices, including iPods. The Company faces

increasing competition from other companies promoting their own digital music

products, including music enabled cell phones, distribution services, and free

peer-to-peer music services. These competitors include both new entrants with different

market approaches, such as subscription services models, and also larger

companies that may have greater technical, marketing, distribution, and

other resources than those of the Company, as well as established hardware,

software, and digital content supplier relationships. In addition, certain

countries have proposed or may propose in the future new legislation that

would cause suppliers of technical protection measures to provide information

so that content may be played on any system, which could have an impact on

the Company s ability to offer new and innovative products in a timely manner.

43

Failure to effectively

compete could negatively affect the Company s operating results and financial

position. There can be no assurance that the Company will be able to continue

to provide products and services that effectively compete in these markets or

successfully distribute and sell digital content outside the U.S. The Company may also

have to respond to price competition by lowering prices and/or increasing

features which could adversely affect the Company s music product gross margins

as well as overall Company gross margins.

The Company also faces

increased competition in the U.S. education market. U.S. elementary and

secondary schools, as well as college and university customers, remain a core

market for the Company. Uncertainty in this channel remains as several

competitors of the Company have either targeted or announced their intention to

target the education market for personal computers, which could negatively

affect the Company s market share. In an effort to regain market share and

remain competitive, the Company has been and will continue to pursue one-to-one

(1:1) learning solutions in education. 1:1 learning solutions typically consist

of iBook portable systems for every student and teacher along with a wireless

network connected to a central server. These 1:1 learning solutions and other

strategic sales are generally priced more aggressively and could result in

significantly less profitability or even in financial losses, particularly for

larger deals. Although the Company believes it has taken certain steps to

strengthen its position in the education market, there can be no assurance that

the Company will be able to increase or maintain its share of the education

market or execute profitably on large strategic arrangements. Failure to do so may have

an adverse impact on the Company s operating results and financial condition.

The Company s transition from PowerPC

microprocessors used by Macintosh computers to microprocessors built by Intel

is subject to numerous risks.

In June 2005, the

Company announced its intention to transition from the use of PowerPC

microprocessors to the use of Intel microprocessors in all of its Macintosh

computers by the end of calendar year 2007. As of April 1, 2006, the

Company has introduced the new iMac , MacBook Pro , and Mac mini computers,

which run on Intel microprocessors. The Company now expects to complete this

transition by the end of calendar year 2006. This transition is subject to

numerous risks and uncertainties, including the Company s ability to timely

develop and deliver new products using Intel microprocessors, the timely

innovation and delivery of related hardware and software products, including

the Company s applications, to support Intel microprocessors, market acceptance

of Intel-based Macintosh computers, the development and availability on

acceptable terms of components and services essential to enable the Company to

timely deliver Intel-based Macintosh computers, and the effective management of

inventory levels in line with anticipated product demand for both PowerPC and

Intel-based Macintosh computers. In addition, the Company is dependent on

third-party software developers such as Microsoft and Adobe continuing to

support current applications that run on PowerPC-based computers and timely

developing versions of current and future applications that run on Intel and

PowerPC-based Macintosh computers. Microsoft and Adobe have announced that

their Universal versions of Microsoft Office and Creative Suite applications,

respectively, may not be available until calendar year 2007. The Company s

inability to timely deliver new Intel-based products or obtain developer

commitment both to continue supporting applications that run on PowerPC

microprocessors and timely transition their applications to run natively on

Intel-based products may have an adverse impact on the Company s results

of operations. The Company s ongoing transition to Intel microprocessors has

negatively impacted and may continue to negatively impact sales of current

and future Macintosh products containing PowerPC microprocessors, as customers may elect

to delay purchases until the Intel-based products are available. Additionally,

there can be no assurance that the Company will be able to maintain its

historical gross margin percentages on its products, including Intel-based

Macintosh computers, which may adversely impact the Company s results of

operations.

Future

operating results are dependent upon the Company s ability to obtain a

sufficient supply of components, including microprocessors, some of which are

in short supply or available only from limited sources.

Although most components

essential to the Company s business are generally available from multiple

sources, certain key components including microprocessors and ASICs are

currently obtained by the Company from single or limited sources. Some key

components (including without limitation DRAM, NAND flash-memory, and TFT-LCD

flat-panel displays), while currently available to the Company from multiple

sources, are at times subject to industry-wide availability and pricing

pressures. In addition, new products introduced by the Company often initially

utilize custom components obtained from only one source until the Company has

evaluated whether there is a need for, and subsequently qualifies additional

suppliers. In situations where a component or product utilizes new

technologies, initial capacity constraints may exist until such time as

the suppliers yields have matured. The Company and other producers in the

personal computer industry also compete for various components with other

industries that have experienced increased demand for their products. The

Company uses some components that are not common to the rest of the personal

computer industry including certain microprocessors and ASICs. Continued

availability of these

44

components may be

affected if producers decided to concentrate on the production of components

other than those customized to meet the Company s requirements. If the supply

of a key component were delayed or constrained on a new or existing product,

the Company s results of operations and financial condition could be adversely

affected.

The Company s ability to

produce and market competitive products is dependent on the ability and desire

of IBM and Freescale Semiconductor, Inc. (Freescale) to supply PowerPC G4

and G5 microprocessors and Intel to supply its microprocessors for the Company s

Macintosh computers and to provide the Company with a sufficient supply of

microprocessors with price/performance features that compare favorably to those

supplied to the Company s competitors. While the Company has supply agreements

with IBM and Freescale, the Company s recent announcement of plans to

transition to Intel microprocessors may impact the continued availability

on acceptable terms of certain components and services, including PowerPC G4

and G5 microprocessors, which are essential to the Company s business and are

currently obtained by the Company from sole or limited sources. Additionally,

there have been instances in recent years where the inability of the Company s

suppliers to provide advanced PowerPC microprocessors in sufficient quantity

has had significant adverse effects on the Company s results of operations. In

addition, IBM is currently the Company s sole supplier of the PowerPC G5

processor, which is used in the Company s current Power Mac and Xserve products.

Freescale is the sole supplier of the PowerPC G4 processor, which is used in

the Company s eMac, and iBook products. Manufacturing problems experienced by

any of the Company s suppliers in the future or failure by them to deliver

components to the Company in sufficient quantities with competitive

price/performance features could adversely affect the Company s results of

operations and financial condition.

The

Company must successfully manage frequent product introductions and transitions

to remain competitive and effectively stimulate customer demand.

Due to the highly

volatile and competitive nature of the personal computer and consumer

electronics industries, which are characterized by dynamic customer demand

patterns and rapid technological advances, the Company must continually

introduce new products and technologies, enhance existing products to remain

competitive, and effectively stimulate customer demand for new products and

upgraded versions of the Company s existing products. The success of new product

introductions is dependent on a number of factors, including market acceptance;

the Company s ability to manage the risks associated with product transitions,

including the transition to Intel-based Macintosh computers, and production

ramp issues; the availability of application software for new products; the

effective management of purchase commitments and inventory levels in line with

anticipated product demand, including anticipated demand for PowerPC-based and

Intel-based Macintosh computers; the availability of products in appropriate

quantities to meet anticipated demand; and the risk that new products may have

quality or other defects in the early stages of introduction. Accordingly, the

Company cannot determine in advance the ultimate effect that new products will

have on its sales or results of operations.

The