Credit cards · Mortgages · Banking · Investing
Money tools
Compare › Credit cards › The Platinum Card from American Express › The Platinum Card from American Express vs Discover it Secured Cash Back

The Platinum Card from American Express vs Discover it Secured Cash Back: Credit cards compared

The Platinum Card from American Express and Discover it Secured Cash Back are two credit cards options. The sections below line up cost, what you get, fees, speed, and who each one fits.

The Platinum Card from American ExpressDiscover it Secured Cash Back
Cost$550 annual feeNo annual fee

Why compare them

When choosing a credit card, it’s essential to consider your financial goals and spending habits. The Platinum Card from American Express and Discover it Secured Cash Back serve different purposes. Comparing them can help you find the right fit for your needs.

The Platinum Card is designed for frequent travelers. It offers premium travel benefits, such as access to over 1,550 airport lounges. You can earn 5X points on flights and hotels, making it ideal for those who travel often. The high annual fee of $550 might deter some, but the perks can offset this cost if you utilize them effectively.

On the other hand, Discover it Secured Cash Back is a secured credit card. It has no annual fee, making it accessible for those looking to build or rebuild credit. The refundable deposit starts as low as $49, which is a low barrier to entry. This card offers a unique cash back structure, allowing you to earn 5% cash back on certain categories each quarter. Plus, you get a dollar-for-dollar match on all cash back earned in the first year.

If you prioritize travel rewards and luxury benefits, The Platinum Card could be worth the investment. However, if you are focused on building credit without the burden of an annual fee, the Discover it Secured Cash Back may be the better choice. Evaluating both options side by side helps you weigh the benefits against the costs.

  • The Platinum Card targets frequent travelers.
  • Offers premium perks like airport lounge access.
  • High annual fee can be offset by travel rewards.
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back is for building credit.
  • No annual fee and low refundable deposit.
  • Earn 5% cash back on select categories quarterly.
  • Dollar-for-dollar cash back match in the first year.

Cost

When considering credit cards, cost is a crucial factor. The Platinum Card from American Express comes with a hefty annual fee of $550. This fee can be a barrier for many potential users. However, the card offers extensive benefits that may justify the cost for frequent travelers. The high annual fee is offset by perks like access to airport lounges and hotel credits. If you travel often, these benefits can lead to significant savings.

On the other hand, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card has no annual fee. This makes it an attractive option for those looking to build or rebuild credit without incurring extra costs. Instead of an annual fee, users need to make a refundable deposit, which starts as low as $49. This deposit acts as collateral, making it a secured card. The absence of an annual fee allows users to focus on earning rewards without worrying about additional expenses.

In summary, the cost of each card varies significantly. The Platinum Card is designed for premium users willing to pay for luxury travel benefits. In contrast, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card is budget-friendly, ideal for those starting their credit journey. Understanding the costs associated with each card is essential for making an informed decision.

  • The Platinum Card from American Express: $550 annual fee.
  • Offers extensive travel benefits that may justify the high cost.
  • Includes access to airport lounges and hotel credits.
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back: No annual fee.
  • Requires a refundable deposit as low as $49.
  • Ideal for building or rebuilding credit without extra costs.
  • Focus on earning rewards without worrying about annual fees.

What you get

When comparing The Platinum Card from American Express and the Discover it Secured Cash Back, the features stand out for different reasons. The Platinum Card is designed for premium travelers. It comes with a hefty annual fee of $550. However, it offers extensive travel benefits that can offset this cost. You get access to over 1,550 airport lounges worldwide. This includes a Priority Pass membership, which enhances your travel experience significantly.

Additionally, cardholders can enjoy up to $600 in hotel credits. This can be a game-changer for frequent travelers. Dining is also covered, with up to $400 in credits available. Furthermore, the card provides up to $200 in airline fee credits. This means you can use the card for incidental expenses like baggage fees without worrying about extra costs. Another perk is that there are no foreign transaction fees, making it ideal for international travel.

On the other hand, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card is a more budget-friendly option. It has no annual fee, making it accessible for those looking to build or rebuild their credit. A refundable deposit starts as low as $49, which is manageable for many. The rewards structure is appealing, too. You earn 5% cash back on everyday purchases at various locations each quarter, up to a specific maximum. Plus, you earn 1% cash back on all other purchases.

A standout feature of this card is the welcome offer. At the end of your first year, Discover matches all the cash back you've earned. This can significantly boost your rewards without any additional effort.

  • The Platinum Card from American Express:
  • - $550 annual fee
  • - Access to 1,550+ airport lounges
  • - Up to $600 in hotel credits
  • - Up to $400 in dining credits
  • - Up to $200 in airline fee credits
  • - No foreign transaction fees
  • - 10 complimentary Delta Sky Club visits
  • - Priority Pass membership
  • - Up to $300 in statement credits for Fine Hotels + Resorts bookings
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back:
  • - No annual fee
  • - Refundable deposits as low as $49
  • - Earn 5% cash back on quarterly rotating categories
  • - Earn 1% cash back on all other purchases
  • - Unlimited dollar-for-dollar match on cash back earned in the first year

Who each one fits

Choosing the right credit card depends on your financial habits and goals. The Platinum Card from American Express is ideal for frequent travelers. It offers premium travel benefits that can enhance your travel experience. If you often fly or stay at hotels, the 5X points on flights and hotels can add up quickly. This card is best for those who can take advantage of its extensive perks, such as access to over 1,550 airport lounges. The high annual fee of $550 might deter some, but for regular travelers, the benefits can outweigh the costs.

On the other hand, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card is perfect for those looking to build or rebuild their credit. It has no annual fee and requires a refundable deposit as low as $49. This makes it accessible for many. The card offers 5% cash back on everyday purchases at various retailers each quarter, which is a great incentive for those who want to earn rewards while managing their finances. Plus, the unlimited dollar-for-dollar match on all cash back earned in the first year is a significant bonus for new cardholders.

In summary, if you travel frequently and can leverage premium benefits, The Platinum Card is a strong choice. However, if you are focused on building credit with no annual fee and want to earn cash back, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card is the better fit.

  • The Platinum Card from American Express:
  • Best for frequent travelers.
  • Offers premium travel benefits.
  • 5X points on flights and hotels.
  • Access to over 1,550 airport lounges.
  • High annual fee of $550 may be a drawback.
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back:
  • Ideal for building or rebuilding credit.
  • No annual fee.
  • Refundable deposits starting at $49.
  • Earn 5% cash back on everyday purchases.
  • Unlimited dollar-for-dollar match on cash back in the first year.

What you need to qualify

Qualifying for a credit card can vary significantly between products. Understanding the requirements is essential for potential applicants.

The Platinum Card from American Express is aimed at individuals with strong credit profiles. It generally requires a good to excellent credit score. This card is designed for those who travel frequently and can benefit from premium perks. The high annual fee of $550 reflects the card's luxury offerings. Applicants should be prepared to demonstrate their creditworthiness.

On the other hand, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card is designed for those looking to build or rebuild their credit. This card is accessible to individuals with lower credit scores. It requires a refundable security deposit, which can start as low as $49. This deposit acts as collateral and helps mitigate risk for the issuer. The absence of an annual fee makes it a more affordable option for many consumers.

For both cards, applicants should be ready to provide personal information. This includes income, employment status, and Social Security number. Lenders may also check credit reports to assess financial history. It's important to review your credit report before applying, as any inaccuracies could impact your chances of approval.

In summary, The Platinum Card from American Express is best for those with strong credit and a willingness to pay a high annual fee for premium benefits. The Discover it Secured Cash Back card is suitable for those looking to improve their credit with a low-cost option.

  • The Platinum Card from American Express requires a good to excellent credit score.
  • A high annual fee of $550 reflects its premium benefits.
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back is for those with lower credit scores.
  • Requires a refundable security deposit starting at $49.
  • No annual fee makes it affordable for many.
  • Applicants must provide personal information: income, employment, and Social Security number.
  • Credit reports are checked to assess financial history.
  • Review your credit report for inaccuracies before applying.

Fees and extra charges

When comparing fees and extra charges between The Platinum Card from American Express and Discover it Secured Cash Back, the differences are stark. The Platinum Card has a significant annual fee of $550. This fee can be a deterrent for some users. However, it comes with extensive travel benefits that may justify the cost for frequent travelers. On the other hand, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card has no annual fee, making it a more accessible option for those looking to build or rebuild their credit. This card requires a refundable deposit, which can start as low as $49. This deposit acts as collateral, ensuring that the cardholder can manage their spending responsibly. It's a low barrier to entry for those new to credit.

While The Platinum Card does not impose foreign transaction fees, which is a plus for international travelers, its high annual fee might overshadow this benefit for casual users. The Discover it Secured Cash Back card also does not have foreign transaction fees, making it a practical choice for those who travel abroad occasionally.

In summary, the fee structures of these two cards cater to different audiences. The Platinum Card is designed for premium users who can take advantage of its extensive travel perks. Meanwhile, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card is ideal for individuals looking to establish credit without incurring annual fees. Each card has its unique advantages and potential costs, making it essential to assess personal financial situations before choosing.

  • The Platinum Card has a $550 annual fee.
  • No foreign transaction fees with The Platinum Card.
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back has no annual fee.
  • Refundable deposits for Discover it start as low as $49.
  • Both cards have no foreign transaction fees.

How fast you get it

When applying for a credit card, approval time and funding speed are crucial factors. The Platinum Card from American Express typically offers a quick approval process. Most applicants receive a decision within minutes of submitting their application. However, some cases may require additional verification, which can delay the process. Once approved, the card is usually mailed out promptly, allowing you to start enjoying its benefits without much wait.

In contrast, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card also has a straightforward approval process. Applicants can expect a decision in a similar timeframe, often within minutes. However, since this is a secured card, you will need to make a refundable deposit. This deposit can be as low as $49, depending on your creditworthiness. The deposit is a key part of the application, as it secures your credit limit and may affect how quickly you can start using the card.

Once you are approved for the Discover it Secured Cash Back card, you will also receive your card in the mail shortly after. The timeframe for receiving the card can vary, but it generally takes about a week. In both cases, you can begin building your credit history quickly, as both cards report to the major credit bureaus.

  • The Platinum Card from American Express: Quick approval, often within minutes.
  • Potential delays for additional verification.
  • Card mailed promptly after approval.
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back: Approval also typically within minutes.
  • Requires a refundable deposit, which can slow down the process slightly.
  • Deposit amount affects your credit limit.
  • Card usually arrives within a week after approval.

How to compare them

When comparing The Platinum Card from American Express and Discover it Secured Cash Back, consider several key factors. Each card serves different needs and financial situations. Start by looking at the annual fees. The Platinum Card has a high annual fee of $550, while the Discover it Secured Cash Back has no annual fee. This difference is significant for budget-conscious consumers.

Next, evaluate the rewards structure. The Platinum Card offers 5X Points on flights and hotels, making it ideal for frequent travelers. In contrast, the Discover it Secured Cash Back provides 5% cash back on rotating categories each quarter, along with 1% on all other purchases. This card is better suited for everyday spending and those looking to build credit.

Consider the additional benefits. The Platinum Card includes perks like access to over 1,550 airport lounges and various travel credits, which can enhance the travel experience. However, these benefits are more valuable for those who travel often. The Discover it Secured Cash Back, on the other hand, focuses on cash back rewards and has a welcome offer of unlimited dollar-for-dollar match on cash back earned in the first year, appealing to new credit card users.

Lastly, think about eligibility. The Platinum Card targets consumers with excellent credit, while the Discover it Secured Cash Back is a secured card, making it accessible for those with limited or poor credit histories. Aligning these factors will help you determine which card fits your financial lifestyle.

  • Annual Fees: $550 for The Platinum Card; no fee for Discover it Secured.
  • Rewards: 5X Points on flights/hotels vs. 5% cash back on rotating categories.
  • Travel Benefits: Extensive perks with The Platinum Card; cash back focus with Discover.
  • Welcome Offer: Unlimited cash back match for Discover; no offer for The Platinum Card.
  • Eligibility: The Platinum Card for excellent credit; Discover for those building credit.

What to watch for

When choosing a credit card, it's vital to consider the limits and catches that can affect your overall costs. Each card has unique features that may seem appealing but can come with hidden drawbacks.

For The Platinum Card from American Express, the high annual fee of $550 is a significant factor. While the card offers premium travel benefits, those benefits may only be worthwhile if you travel frequently. If you don’t use the perks, the cost can outweigh the benefits.

Additionally, while the card provides access to over 1,550 airport lounges and various credits, these benefits come with usage limits. For instance, the dining and hotel credits are capped at specific amounts. If you don’t spend enough to reach these caps, you might not get full value from your investment.

On the other hand, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card has no annual fee, which is a clear advantage. However, it requires a refundable deposit that can start as low as $49. This deposit is a consideration for those new to credit or rebuilding their credit history. You must also actively manage your spending to maximize the 5% cash back in rotating categories each quarter.

It's essential to activate these categories to earn the higher rate. Failing to do so means you will only earn 1% cash back on those purchases. This could lead to lower rewards than expected if you forget to activate.

Both cards have their pros and cons. Understanding these limits and catches will help you make an informed decision.

  • The Platinum Card from American Express:
  • - High annual fee of $550.
  • - Premium travel benefits may require frequent travel to be worthwhile.
  • - Hotel and dining credits have usage caps.
  • - Access to lounges may not justify the cost if not used often.
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back:
  • - No annual fee, making it budget-friendly.
  • - Requires a refundable deposit starting at $49.
  • - 5% cash back is limited to activated categories each quarter.
  • - Forgetting to activate can reduce cash back earnings.

Which one to choose

Choosing between The Platinum Card from American Express and Discover it Secured Cash Back depends on your financial goals and spending habits. Each card serves a different purpose and appeals to distinct audiences.

The Platinum Card is ideal for frequent travelers. It comes with a hefty annual fee of $550 but offers extensive travel perks. You get access to over 1,550 airport lounges, which can make your travel experience more comfortable. Additionally, there are significant hotel and dining credits available. You can receive up to $600 in hotel credits and up to $400 in dining credits. These benefits can offset the high annual fee if you utilize them effectively.

On the other hand, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card is geared toward those looking to build or rebuild their credit. With no annual fee, it’s a more budget-friendly option. The card requires a refundable deposit, starting as low as $49, making it accessible for many. It offers a unique rewards structure, allowing you to earn 5% cash back on select categories each quarter and 1% on everything else. Plus, there’s a welcome offer that matches all cash back earned in the first year, which can be a great incentive for new users.

If you prioritize luxury travel benefits and can justify the annual fee, The Platinum Card may be the right choice. However, if you are focused on building credit without incurring annual fees, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card is a solid option.

  • The Platinum Card: Best for premium travel benefits.
  • Offers 5X points on flights and hotels.
  • Access to over 1,550 airport lounges.
  • High annual fee of $550.
  • Significant hotel and dining credits available.
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back: Best for building credit.
  • No annual fee, making it budget-friendly.
  • Refundable deposits start at $49.
  • Earn 5% cash back on select categories each quarter.
  • 1% cash back on all other purchases.
  • Unlimited dollar-for-dollar match on cash back in the first year.

Rates and fees change. Check with the lender before you apply. This is general information, not financial advice.