Old Navy Encore Mastercard vs Instacart Mastercard: Credit cards compared
Old Navy Encore Mastercard and Instacart Mastercard are two credit cards options. The sections below line up cost, what you get, fees, speed, and who each one fits.
| Old Navy Encore Mastercard | Instacart Mastercard | |
|---|---|---|
| APR range | 33.49% | 18.49%–27.99% variable APR |
| Cost | No Annual Fee | No annual fee |
Why compare them
When choosing a credit card, it’s essential to compare options. The Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the Instacart Mastercard cater to different spending habits. Understanding their features can help you make an informed decision.
The Old Navy Encore Mastercard is ideal for shoppers who frequently buy from the Gap Inc. family of brands. It offers 5X points for every dollar spent at these stores. You also earn 3X points at eligible retail apparel brands and 1X everywhere else. This card comes with a welcome offer of 30% off your first purchase, which is a great incentive for new users.
On the other hand, the Instacart Mastercard is designed for those who rely on grocery delivery. It provides 5% cash back on Instacart purchases and Chase Travel. If you dine out or fill up your gas tank often, you’ll appreciate the 2% cash back in those categories. The welcome offer of $50 Instacart credit is also appealing for new cardholders.
Both cards have no annual fee, making them budget-friendly options. However, the Old Navy card has a high APR of 33.49%, which could be a drawback if you carry a balance. In contrast, the Instacart Mastercard has a variable APR range of 18.49% to 27.99%. This could be more manageable for some users.
Additionally, the Old Navy card offers perks like free shipping on orders over $35 and $0 fraud liability protection. The Instacart card provides cash back that doesn’t expire as long as the account remains open. Evaluating these differences can help you choose the card that aligns with your lifestyle and spending habits.
- Old Navy Encore Mastercard:
- - 5X points at Gap Inc. brands
- - 3X points at eligible retail apparel brands
- - 1X points on all other purchases
- - Welcome offer: 30% off first purchase
- - High APR of 33.49%
- - Free shipping on orders over $35
- - $0 fraud liability protection
- Instacart Mastercard:
- - 5% cash back on Instacart and Chase Travel
- - 2% cash back at restaurants and gas stations
- - 1% cash back on all other purchases
- - Welcome offer: $50 Instacart credit
- - Variable APR of 18.49% to 27.99%
- - Cash back doesn’t expire with an open account
Cost
When choosing between the Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the Instacart Mastercard, cost is a key factor. Both cards have no annual fee, making them accessible for budget-conscious consumers. However, the differences in APR and fees can significantly impact your overall expenses.
The Old Navy Encore Mastercard has a high APR of 33.49%. This rate is steep and could lead to high interest charges if you carry a balance. Additionally, if you plan to transfer a balance, be aware that the card imposes a fee. You will pay either $5 or 5% of the amount transferred, whichever is greater. This can add up quickly, especially with larger balances.
In contrast, the Instacart Mastercard offers a variable APR ranging from 18.49% to 27.99%. While still potentially high, this range is more manageable than the Old Navy card's fixed rate. The Instacart card does not have balance transfer fees, which can be a significant cost-saving feature if you need to move a balance from another card.
Both cards provide value without an annual fee, but the long-term costs can vary greatly based on your spending habits and payment behavior. If you tend to carry a balance, the lower APR of the Instacart Mastercard may save you money over time. However, if you pay off your balance in full each month, the rewards structure of each card could be more important than the APR.
- Both cards have no annual fee.
- Old Navy Encore Mastercard has a high APR of 33.49%.
- Balance transfer fees apply on the Old Navy card: either $5 or 5% of the amount transferred.
- Instacart Mastercard has a variable APR of 18.49% to 27.99%.
- No balance transfer fees with the Instacart Mastercard.
- Consider your spending habits when evaluating costs.
What you get
Both the Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the Instacart Mastercard offer appealing features for different types of consumers. The Old Navy Encore Mastercard comes with no annual fee, making it cost-effective for those who shop at Gap Inc. brands. The card provides 5X points for every dollar spent at these stores, which include Old Navy, Gap, and Banana Republic. For purchases at eligible retail apparel brands, cardholders earn 3X points. All other purchases earn 1X points. Additionally, new cardholders receive a welcome offer of 30% off their first purchase at Old Navy. The card also includes complimentary FICO Score access and offers $0 fraud liability protection for unauthorized purchases. However, it has a high APR of 33.49% and balance transfer fees apply.
On the other hand, the Instacart Mastercard also has no annual fee and is ideal for frequent Instacart users. It offers 5% cash back on Instacart purchases and Chase Travel purchases. Cardholders earn 2% cash back at restaurants and gas stations, and 1% cash back on all other purchases. A notable welcome offer includes a $50 Instacart credit upon approval. This card has a variable APR ranging from 18.49% to 27.99%, which can be high but is generally lower than the Old Navy card. Points earned do not expire as long as the account remains open, providing flexibility for users. However, eligibility is restricted to those who do not currently hold the Instacart Mastercard or have received a cash back bonus from Chase in the past 24 months.
- Old Navy Encore Mastercard:
- - No annual fee
- - Earn 5X points at Gap Inc. brands
- - Earn 3X points at eligible retail apparel brands
- - Earn 1X points on all other purchases
- - 30% off first purchase at Old Navy
- - Complimentary FICO Score access
- - $0 fraud liability protection
- - High APR of 33.49%
- - Balance transfer fees apply
- Instacart Mastercard:
- - 5% cash back on Instacart purchases
- - 5% cash back on Chase Travel purchases
- - 2% cash back at restaurants and gas stations
- - 1% cash back on all other purchases
- - $50 Instacart credit upon approval
- - Variable APR of 18.49% to 27.99%
- - Points do not expire with an open account
- - Eligibility restrictions apply
Who each one fits
Choosing the right credit card depends on your spending habits. The Old Navy Encore Mastercard is ideal for shoppers who frequently buy from Gap Inc. brands. This card offers 5X points on every dollar spent at Old Navy, Gap, and similar stores. If you enjoy fashion and often shop for apparel, this card can help you rack up rewards quickly. Plus, you get a 30% discount on your first purchase, which is a nice incentive to start using the card.
On the other hand, the Instacart Mastercard is perfect for those who rely on grocery delivery services. If you regularly use Instacart for your shopping, this card provides 5% cash back on those purchases. The card also gives 5% cash back on Chase Travel, making it a good fit for frequent travelers. Additionally, it offers 2% cash back at restaurants and gas stations, which can add up if you dine out or drive often.
Both cards come with no annual fee, making them accessible choices. However, the Old Navy card has a high APR of 33.49%, which may deter those who plan to carry a balance. In contrast, the Instacart card has a variable APR ranging from 18.49% to 27.99%. This makes it a slightly better option for those who might need to finance their purchases.
Ultimately, if you love shopping for clothes and want to earn points for future purchases, go for the Old Navy Encore Mastercard. If you want to maximize cash back on grocery and travel expenses, the Instacart Mastercard is the better choice.
- Old Navy Encore Mastercard fits:
- - Shoppers of Gap Inc. brands
- - Those who want high rewards on apparel purchases
- - Individuals looking for discounts on first purchases
- Instacart Mastercard fits:
- - Frequent Instacart users
- - Travelers who book through Chase
- - Diners and drivers seeking cash back
What you need to qualify
Qualifying for a credit card can vary significantly between products. Each card has its own set of requirements. Here’s what you need to know for the Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the Instacart Mastercard.
For the Old Navy Encore Mastercard, there are no specific eligibility criteria listed. However, general credit card qualifications apply. Applicants typically need a good to excellent credit score. This means a score often above 700. The application process will also require personal information, such as income and employment details. It's wise to check your credit report before applying. This helps ensure you meet the expected standards.
On the other hand, the Instacart Mastercard has specific eligibility rules. You must not currently have the Instacart Mastercard. Additionally, you cannot have received a cash back new cardmember bonus from Chase in the last 24 months. This limits eligibility to new users. Like the Old Navy card, a good credit score is also beneficial. Chase generally looks for applicants with a score in the good to excellent range.
Both cards do not charge an annual fee, making them attractive options for budget-conscious consumers. However, the Old Navy card may appeal more to those who frequently shop at Gap Inc. brands. In contrast, the Instacart Mastercard is best suited for regular Instacart users. Understanding these qualifications can help you choose the right card for your needs.
- Old Navy Encore Mastercard:
- - No specific eligibility criteria listed.
- - Good to excellent credit score recommended (typically above 700).
- - Requires personal information like income and employment details.
- - Check your credit report before applying.
- Instacart Mastercard:
- - Must not currently have the Instacart Mastercard.
- - Cannot have received a cash back bonus from Chase in the past 24 months.
- - Good to excellent credit score is beneficial.
- - Best for new users looking for high cash back on Instacart purchases.
Fees and extra charges
When comparing the Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the Instacart Mastercard, fees and extra charges play a crucial role in your decision. Both cards have no annual fee, which is a significant advantage for budget-conscious consumers.
However, they differ in other charges. The Old Navy Encore Mastercard imposes a balance transfer fee. This fee is either $5 or 5% of the transfer amount, whichever is greater. This can add up quickly if you plan to transfer a large balance. Additionally, this card has a high APR of 33.49%, which can lead to substantial interest costs if you carry a balance.
On the other hand, the Instacart Mastercard does not have any listed fees beyond the absence of an annual fee. However, it features a variable APR ranging from 18.49% to 27.99%. This means that while the starting rate is lower than the Old Navy card, it can still become high depending on your creditworthiness and market conditions.
It's also important to note that the Instacart Mastercard has eligibility requirements. You cannot have had the card or received a cash back bonus from Chase in the past 24 months. This could limit access for some potential applicants.
In summary, while both cards are appealing due to their no annual fee structure, the Old Navy card has additional costs associated with balance transfers and a notably high APR. The Instacart card offers a more straightforward fee structure, making it potentially easier to manage.
- Both cards have no annual fee.
- Old Navy Encore Mastercard: Balance transfer fee of either $5 or 5% of the transfer amount.
- High APR of 33.49% for the Old Navy card.
- Instacart Mastercard: Variable APR of 18.49% to 27.99%.
- Instacart card has no additional fees listed.
- Eligibility for Instacart card includes not having the card or a cash back bonus from Chase in the past 24 months.
How fast you get it
When considering credit cards, the speed of approval and access to funds is crucial. Both the Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the Instacart Mastercard offer quick approval processes, but they differ in specifics. The Old Navy Encore Mastercard is designed for shoppers who frequent the Gap Inc. family of brands. Approval can often be obtained within minutes online. Once approved, you can start using your card immediately for online purchases. However, physical card delivery may take a few days, delaying access to in-store benefits.
On the other hand, the Instacart Mastercard also promises a fast approval process. Similar to the Old Navy card, you can expect a quick decision online. Upon approval, you receive a $50 Instacart credit, which is automatically applied. This can be used right away for your Instacart purchases, making it very convenient for frequent users. The card will also be mailed to you, which may take additional time for physical access.
Both cards provide immediate benefits upon approval, but the Instacart Mastercard offers a direct cash incentive that can be used right away. The Old Navy card, while providing immediate online access, may not offer the same instant financial benefit. Consider your shopping habits and how quickly you want to access your rewards when choosing between these options.
- Old Navy Encore Mastercard:
- - Quick online approval, often within minutes.
- - Immediate online use after approval.
- - Physical card delivery may take a few days.
- - No instant cash benefits upon approval.
- Instacart Mastercard:
- - Fast online approval process.
- - $50 Instacart credit available immediately upon approval.
- - Physical card also mailed, which may delay in-store access.
- - Ideal for frequent Instacart shoppers.
How to compare them
When comparing the Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the Instacart Mastercard, several key factors come into play. Start with the cost. Both cards have no annual fee, which is a plus for budget-conscious consumers. However, the fees associated with each card differ. The Old Navy card has balance transfer fees, while the Instacart card does not list any fees, making it potentially more appealing for those who may transfer balances.
Next, look at the APR range. The Old Navy card has a high APR of 33.49%, which could lead to significant interest charges if you carry a balance. In contrast, the Instacart card offers a variable APR ranging from 18.49% to 27.99%. This range is generally more manageable, especially for those who might carry a balance occasionally.
Rewards are another critical area to consider. The Old Navy card offers points for purchases, with 5X points at Gap Inc. brands and 3X at eligible retail apparel brands. However, the rewards are only useful if you frequently shop at these stores. The Instacart card, on the other hand, provides cash back, which is often more flexible. It offers 5% cash back on Instacart and Chase Travel purchases, making it ideal for regular users of these services.
Finally, consider the welcome offers. The Old Navy card provides a 30% discount on the first purchase, while the Instacart card gives $50 in credit upon approval. This difference may sway your decision based on your immediate shopping needs.
- Both cards have no annual fee.
- Old Navy card has balance transfer fees; Instacart card does not.
- Old Navy's APR is 33.49%; Instacart's APR ranges from 18.49% to 27.99%.
- Old Navy rewards points; Instacart offers cash back.
- Old Navy gives 5X points at Gap Inc. brands; Instacart gives 5% cash back on Instacart and Chase Travel.
- Welcome offers differ: 30% off first purchase for Old Navy vs. $50 Instacart credit.
What to watch for
When considering credit cards, it's vital to look beyond the surface. Both the Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the Instacart Mastercard have appealing features, but they come with potential pitfalls. Understanding these limits and catches can help you avoid unexpected costs.
The Old Navy Encore Mastercard offers no annual fee, which is a plus. However, it has a high APR of 33.49%. This rate can significantly increase your costs if you carry a balance. Additionally, balance transfer fees apply. You’ll pay either $5 or 5% of the amount transferred, whichever is greater. This can add up quickly if you transfer a large balance.
On the rewards side, while you can earn 5X points at Gap Inc. brands, the value of those points is limited. You need 500 points for a $1 reward, which means you’ll need to spend a lot to see significant returns. Also, the card only offers rewards for specific categories, which may not suit everyone’s spending habits.
The Instacart Mastercard also has no annual fee and offers a welcome bonus of $50 in Instacart credit. However, it’s essential to note that the variable APR ranges from 18.49% to 27.99%. This variability can lead to higher costs if interest rates rise or if you have a high balance.
While the cash back rates are appealing, they are limited to certain categories. For instance, you earn 5% cash back on Instacart and Chase Travel purchases but only 1% on all other purchases. This could restrict your ability to earn rewards on everyday spending.
- Old Navy Encore Mastercard has a high APR of 33.49%.
- Balance transfer fees are either $5 or 5% of the amount transferred.
- 500 points equals $1 reward, requiring significant spending for value.
- Instacart Mastercard has a variable APR from 18.49% to 27.99%.
- Cash back rates are limited to specific categories.
- 5% cash back on Instacart and Chase Travel, 1% on other purchases.
Which one to choose
Choosing between the Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the Instacart Mastercard depends on your shopping habits. Each card offers unique benefits tailored to different lifestyles.
If you frequently shop at Old Navy or other Gap Inc. brands, the Old Navy Encore Mastercard is a solid choice. It provides 5X points on every dollar spent at these stores. You also earn 3X points at eligible retail apparel brands. For all other purchases, you earn 1X point per dollar. This card is ideal for those who want to maximize rewards on clothing purchases.
On the other hand, if you regularly use Instacart for grocery shopping, the Instacart Mastercard may be more beneficial. It offers 5% cash back on Instacart purchases and Chase Travel purchases. Additionally, you earn 2% cash back at restaurants and gas stations. This card is perfect for those who want to earn rewards on everyday expenses.
Both cards come with no annual fee, which is a plus. However, the Old Navy card has a high APR of 33.49%. This could be a drawback if you carry a balance. The Instacart card has a variable APR ranging from 18.49% to 27.99%, which is generally more manageable.
The welcome offers also differ significantly. The Old Navy card gives you 30% off your first purchase, while the Instacart card provides a $50 credit upon approval. Consider which offer aligns better with your immediate shopping needs.
In summary, choose the Old Navy Encore Mastercard for clothing rewards and perks. Opt for the Instacart Mastercard if you prioritize grocery shopping and cash back on everyday purchases.
- Old Navy Encore Mastercard: Best for clothing shoppers.
- Earn 5X points at Gap Inc. brands.
- High APR of 33.49% could be a concern.
- Welcome offer: 30% off first purchase.
- Instacart Mastercard: Best for grocery shoppers.
- Earn 5% cash back on Instacart and Chase Travel.
- Variable APR of 18.49% to 27.99%.
- Welcome offer: $50 Instacart credit upon approval.
Rates and fees change. Check with the lender before you apply. This is general information, not financial advice.