Credit cards · Mortgages · Banking · Investing
Money tools
Compare › Credit cards › Old Navy Encore Mastercard › Old Navy Encore Mastercard vs BJ's One+ Mastercard

Old Navy Encore Mastercard vs BJ's One+ Mastercard: Credit cards compared

Old Navy Encore Mastercard and BJ's One+ Mastercard are two credit cards options. The sections below line up cost, what you get, fees, speed, and who each one fits.

Old Navy Encore MastercardBJ's One+ Mastercard
CostNo Annual Fee$0 annual fee

Why compare them

When choosing a credit card, it's crucial to compare options. The Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the BJ's One+ Mastercard serve different needs. Each card has unique benefits and potential drawbacks that can impact your financial choices.

The Old Navy Encore Mastercard is ideal for those who frequently shop at Gap Inc. brands. It offers 5X points on purchases made at these stores. If you love Old Navy, this card can help you earn rewards quickly. However, it comes with a high APR of 33.49%. This means carrying a balance can become costly. Additionally, there are balance transfer fees to consider.

On the other hand, the BJ's One+ Mastercard is designed for shoppers who frequent BJ's Wholesale Club. It provides 5% back on most purchases at BJ's, plus 2% on other purchases. This card is straightforward with no annual fee and no balance transfer fees. It also offers a discount on gas at BJ's, which can lead to significant savings if you fill up regularly.

Both cards have no annual fee, making them accessible options. However, the rewards structure differs significantly. If you prefer shopping at apparel stores, the Old Navy card might be appealing. Conversely, if you want cash back on a broader range of purchases, including groceries and gas, the BJ's card stands out.

Ultimately, your choice should align with your spending habits. Assess where you spend the most money. This will help you determine which card offers the best value for your lifestyle.

  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard: 5X points at Gap Inc. brands.
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard: 5% back at BJ's, 2% elsewhere.
  • Old Navy card has a high APR of 33.49%.
  • BJ's card has no annual fee and no balance transfer fees.
  • Consider where you shop most often.
  • Rewards structure varies significantly between the two cards.
  • Old Navy card is great for apparel shoppers.
  • BJ's card offers savings on gas and groceries.

Cost

When considering the cost of credit cards, it's essential to look at annual fees, interest rates, and any additional charges. The Old Navy Encore Mastercard has no annual fee, which is a significant advantage for budget-conscious consumers. However, it does come with a high APR of 33.49%. This rate can lead to substantial interest charges if you carry a balance from month to month. Additionally, the card has balance transfer fees, which are either $5 or 5% of the amount transferred, whichever is greater. This can add up quickly if you are transferring a large balance.

On the other hand, the BJ's One+ Mastercard also has no annual fee. This card stands out because it has no additional fees listed, making it potentially more cost-effective for users who want to avoid unexpected charges. While the APR range is not specified, the absence of balance transfer fees is a notable perk. The rewards structure of the BJ's card is appealing, offering 5% back on most purchases at BJ's and 2% back on all other purchases. This can offset costs over time, especially for frequent BJ's shoppers.

Both cards provide opportunities to earn rewards, but the costs associated with high APRs and balance transfer fees can impact overall expenses. If you plan to carry a balance, the Old Navy card's high APR may lead to higher costs compared to the BJ's card, which has no specified APR and no balance transfer fees.

  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard:
  • - No annual fee
  • - High APR of 33.49%
  • - Balance transfer fees: $5 or 5% of the transfer amount
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard:
  • - $0 annual fee
  • - No additional fees listed
  • - Rewards: 5% back at BJ's, 2% everywhere else
  • - No specified APR

What you get

The Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the BJ's One+ Mastercard offer distinct features tailored to different spending habits. Both cards have no annual fee, making them accessible for budget-conscious consumers.

The Old Navy Encore Mastercard is ideal for shoppers who frequent Gap Inc. brands. It offers 5X points for every $1 spent at these stores. This includes popular names like Old Navy and Banana Republic. For purchases at other eligible retail apparel brands, cardholders earn 3X points. All other purchases earn 1X point per dollar. Points accumulate quickly, as 500 points translate to a $1 reward redeemable in the Encore Market. Additionally, new cardholders receive a welcome offer of 30% off their first purchase at Old Navy. This card also provides free shipping on online orders over $35 and access to exclusive events and discounts.

On the other hand, the BJ's One+ Mastercard appeals to those who shop at BJ's Wholesale Club. Cardholders earn 5% back in rewards on most purchases made at BJ's. For other purchases, they receive 2% back. A unique perk of this card is the discount on gas, offering 15 cents off per gallon at BJ's Gas stations. This can lead to significant savings for frequent BJ's shoppers.

While the Old Navy card has a high APR of 33.49%, the BJ's One+ Mastercard does not list an APR range. However, it is important to note that the Old Navy card incurs balance transfer fees, which can add to costs. Overall, both cards provide valuable rewards tailored to their respective audiences.

  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard:
  • - No annual fee
  • - 5X points at Gap Inc. brands
  • - 3X points at eligible retail apparel brands
  • - 1X point on all other purchases
  • - 30% off first purchase at Old Navy
  • - Free shipping on orders over $35
  • - Complimentary FICO Score access
  • - High APR of 33.49%
  • - Balance transfer fees apply
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard:
  • - 5% back on purchases at BJ's
  • - 2% back on other purchases
  • - 15 cents off per gallon at BJ's Gas
  • - Good-Excellent credit required

Who each one fits

Choosing the right credit card depends on your spending habits and lifestyle. The Old Navy Encore Mastercard is ideal for shoppers who frequently buy from Gap Inc. brands. If you love Old Navy, Gap, Banana Republic, or Athleta, this card rewards you generously. You earn 5X points for every $1 spent at these stores. This can lead to significant savings over time.

The card also offers 3X points at other retail apparel brands, making it a solid choice for fashion enthusiasts. Additionally, you earn 1X points on all other purchases. The welcome offer of 30% off your first purchase is a nice incentive for new cardholders. However, keep in mind the high APR of 33.49%. This card is best for those who pay off their balance each month to avoid interest charges.

On the other hand, the BJ's One+ Mastercard is a great fit for those who shop at BJ's Wholesale Club. It offers 5% back in rewards on most purchases made at BJ's. If you fill up your tank at BJ's, you can also enjoy 15 cents off per gallon of gas. This card is beneficial for everyday shoppers and those who want to maximize their rewards on groceries and gas.

Both cards have no annual fee, making them accessible options. The Old Navy card is perfect for fashion lovers, while the BJ's card suits budget-conscious shoppers who prioritize savings on bulk purchases and gas. Consider where you shop most often to determine which card aligns with your needs.

  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard:
  • - Best for shoppers at Gap Inc. brands.
  • - Earn 5X points at Old Navy and related stores.
  • - High APR; best for those who pay balances in full.
  • - 30% off first purchase welcome offer.
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard:
  • - Ideal for BJ's Wholesale Club shoppers.
  • - Earn 5% back on purchases at BJ's.
  • - 15 cents off per gallon at BJ's Gas.
  • - No annual fee and no balance transfer fees.

What you need to qualify

Qualifying for a credit card can vary based on the issuer and the specific card. Each card has its own set of requirements. Understanding these can help you prepare your application.

The Old Navy Encore Mastercard is issued by Barclays. While specific credit score requirements aren't detailed, generally, a good credit score is beneficial. This card is ideal for those who frequently shop at Gap Inc. brands. It offers rewards that cater to loyal customers of these stores. Make sure your credit history reflects responsible use of credit.

In contrast, the BJ's One+ Mastercard is issued by Capital One. This card requires good to excellent credit for approval. This means a credit score typically above 700. If you have a solid credit history, your chances of qualifying improve significantly. This card is a good fit for BJ's shoppers, offering rewards on purchases made at their stores and gas stations.

Both cards have no annual fee, making them accessible options. However, the Old Navy card has a high APR of 33.49%. This means if you carry a balance, it could become costly. It's crucial to assess your spending habits and payment capability before applying.

For both cards, having a stable income can also enhance your application. Lenders want to see that you can repay your debts. Additionally, be prepared to provide personal information, such as your Social Security number and employment details, during the application process.

  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard: Good credit score recommended.
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard: Requires good to excellent credit (typically above 700).
  • No annual fee for both cards.
  • Old Navy card has a high APR of 33.49%.
  • Stable income can improve your chances of approval.
  • Prepare to provide personal information during application.

Fees and extra charges

When choosing a credit card, understanding fees and extra charges is crucial. The Old Navy Encore Mastercard and BJ's One+ Mastercard have different cost structures. Both cards come with no annual fee, which is a significant advantage for budget-conscious consumers.

The Old Navy Encore Mastercard does have some fees to consider. It charges a balance transfer fee, which is either $5 or 5% of the transfer amount, whichever is greater. This can add up quickly if you plan to transfer a large balance. Additionally, this card has a high APR of 33.49%. This rate can lead to substantial interest charges if you carry a balance from month to month.

On the other hand, the BJ's One+ Mastercard has no listed fees. This means cardholders can enjoy the benefits of rewards without worrying about extra charges. It also offers a solid rewards program, providing 5% back on most purchases at BJ's and 2% back on other purchases. This card also includes a discount on gas at BJ's, adding further value without any additional costs.

Both cards offer unique benefits, but the Old Navy card's balance transfer fee and high APR may deter some users. In contrast, the BJ's card stands out with its lack of fees, making it an attractive option for those who want to avoid extra charges. Overall, understanding these fees and charges can help you make a more informed decision.

  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard: No annual fee.
  • Balance transfer fee: $5 or 5% of the transfer amount.
  • High APR of 33.49% can lead to high interest charges.
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard: No annual fee and no listed fees.
  • 5% back on most purchases at BJ's.
  • 2% back on purchases everywhere else Mastercard is accepted.
  • Discount on gas at BJ's without extra costs.

How fast you get it

When applying for a credit card, approval time and funding speed are crucial factors. Both the Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the BJ's One+ Mastercard offer quick approval processes. Generally, you can expect to receive a decision within minutes after submitting your application online. This immediate feedback allows you to know if you’ve been approved or need to take further steps.

Once approved, the next step is receiving your card. Typically, you can expect your physical card to arrive by mail within 7 to 10 business days. This timeframe is standard for most credit cards, including both options here. However, some issuers may offer expedited shipping for an additional fee, allowing you to receive your card sooner.

In terms of funding speed, both cards allow you to start using your credit line immediately upon approval. You can often access a virtual card number for online purchases right away. This feature is especially useful if you need to make a purchase before your physical card arrives.

It's important to note that while both cards provide quick approval and access to your credit line, the Old Navy Encore Mastercard does have a welcome offer that allows you to save on your first purchase. This can be appealing if you plan to shop at Old Navy soon after getting your card.

  • Quick approval process, usually within minutes.
  • Physical card arrives in 7 to 10 business days.
  • Immediate access to a virtual card number for online purchases.
  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard offers a welcome discount on first purchase.

How to compare them

When comparing the Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the BJ's One+ Mastercard, consider several key factors. Start with the cost. Both cards have no annual fee, which is a plus. However, the Old Navy card has a balance transfer fee that could add up. Next, look at the rewards structure. The Old Navy card offers 5X points on purchases at Gap Inc. brands, while the BJ's card provides 5% back on most purchases at BJ's. This difference can significantly impact your rewards based on where you shop most often.

APR is another crucial element. The Old Navy card has a high APR of 33.49%. This rate can be costly if you carry a balance. The BJ's One+ Mastercard does not list an APR range, which may indicate more favorable terms, but it’s essential to verify this before applying. Then, examine any perks or benefits. The Old Navy card offers free shipping on online orders over $35 and early access to special events. These benefits can be appealing if you frequently shop at Old Navy or its affiliates.

Additionally, consider the fraud protection offered. The Old Navy card includes $0 fraud liability protection, which is a valuable safety net. The BJ's card does not specify fraud protection details, so check its terms. Lastly, think about eligibility. The BJ's card requires good to excellent credit, while the Old Navy card does not specify any eligibility criteria. This could make the Old Navy card more accessible for some users.

  • Both cards have no annual fee.
  • Old Navy card has a balance transfer fee.
  • Old Navy offers 5X points at Gap Inc. brands.
  • BJ's card gives 5% back on most purchases at BJ's.
  • Old Navy card has a high APR of 33.49%.
  • BJ's card does not list an APR range.
  • Old Navy provides free shipping on orders over $35.
  • Old Navy card offers early access to events and discounts.
  • Old Navy includes $0 fraud liability protection.
  • BJ's card requires good to excellent credit.

What to watch for

When considering credit cards, it's essential to look beyond the surface. Both the Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the BJ's One+ Mastercard have appealing features, but they come with important details that can affect your overall cost and benefits.

The Old Navy Encore Mastercard has no annual fee, which is a plus. However, it carries a high APR of 33.49%. This means if you carry a balance, you could end up paying a lot in interest. Additionally, there are balance transfer fees. You’ll pay either $5 or 5% of the transfer amount, whichever is higher. This can add up quickly if you’re transferring a significant balance.

On the rewards side, the Old Navy card offers 5X points at Gap Inc. brands, but you earn just 1X points on other purchases. This could limit your rewards potential if you don't shop at those specific stores often.

The BJ's One+ Mastercard also has no annual fee, which is attractive. It offers 5% back on purchases at BJ's, which can be beneficial for frequent shoppers there. However, it lacks a detailed APR range, which could be a concern for potential cardholders. Knowing the interest rates is crucial for understanding the cost of borrowing.

Both cards have their pros and cons. The Old Navy card provides a welcome offer of 30% off your first purchase, which is enticing. However, the high APR and balance transfer fees could negate those savings if not managed well. The BJ's card offers rewards on gas purchases, but it’s essential to have good to excellent credit to qualify. Keep these factors in mind to make an informed decision.

  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard: No annual fee but high APR of 33.49%.
  • Balance transfer fees: $5 or 5% of the transfer amount, whichever is greater.
  • Rewards: 5X points at Gap Inc. brands, 1X points elsewhere.
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard: Also has no annual fee.
  • Rewards: 5% back at BJ's, 2% on other purchases.
  • No detailed APR range available for BJ's card.
  • Old Navy card offers 30% off first purchase.
  • Consider your shopping habits to maximize rewards.
  • High APR and fees can impact overall cost.

Which one to choose

Choosing between the Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the BJ's One+ Mastercard depends on your shopping habits. Each card offers unique benefits tailored to different consumers.

If you frequently shop at Gap Inc. brands, the Old Navy Encore Mastercard could be your best bet. It earns 5X points on purchases at Old Navy and other Gap brands. This makes it ideal for loyal customers of these stores. Plus, you get 3X points at eligible retail apparel brands and 1X points on all other purchases. The welcome offer of 30% off your first purchase is also a nice incentive.

However, the card comes with a high APR of 33.49%. If you carry a balance, the interest can quickly add up. Additionally, balance transfer fees apply, which can detract from its overall value. On the positive side, there is no annual fee, and you benefit from free shipping on online orders over $35. The $0 fraud liability protection is another perk, ensuring you won't be held responsible for unauthorized charges.

On the other hand, the BJ's One+ Mastercard is a strong choice if you often shop at BJ's or fuel up at BJ's Gas stations. It offers 5% back on most purchases at BJ's and 2% back on other Mastercard transactions. Although it lacks a welcome offer, it has no balance transfer fees and no annual fee, making it a straightforward option. The 15¢ off per gallon at BJ's Gas is an added bonus for those who drive frequently.

In summary, if you prioritize rewards on apparel purchases, the Old Navy card might suit you better. If you want straightforward cash back and savings on gas, consider the BJ's card.

  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard:
  • - Earn 5X points at Gap Inc. brands.
  • - 3X points at eligible retail apparel brands.
  • - 1X points on all other purchases.
  • - 30% off first purchase as a welcome offer.
  • - High APR of 33.49%.
  • - Balance transfer fees apply.
  • - No annual fee.
  • - Free shipping on online orders over $35.
  • - $0 fraud liability protection.
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard:
  • - 5% back on purchases at BJ's.
  • - 2% back on all other Mastercard purchases.
  • - 15¢ off per gallon at BJ's Gas.
  • - No balance transfer fees.
  • - Good to excellent credit required.

Rates and fees change. Check with the lender before you apply. This is general information, not financial advice.