Credit cards · Mortgages · Banking · Investing
Money tools
Compare › Credit cards › Old Navy Encore Mastercard › Old Navy Encore Mastercard vs BJ's One Mastercard

Old Navy Encore Mastercard vs BJ's One Mastercard: Credit cards compared

Old Navy Encore Mastercard and BJ's One Mastercard are two credit cards options. The sections below line up cost, what you get, fees, speed, and who each one fits.

Old Navy Encore MastercardBJ's One Mastercard
CostNo Annual Fee$0 annual fee

Why compare them

When choosing a credit card, it’s essential to compare options. The Old Navy Encore Mastercard and BJ's One Mastercard offer different benefits and features. Understanding these differences can help you make a better decision based on your spending habits.

The Old Navy Encore Mastercard is ideal for shoppers who frequently buy from Gap Inc. brands. With 5X points on purchases at these stores, it rewards loyal customers. Additionally, it offers 3X points at eligible retail apparel brands and 1X points elsewhere. The welcome offer of 30% off your first purchase is an attractive incentive for new cardholders.

On the other hand, the BJ's One Mastercard caters to those who shop at BJ's Wholesale Club. It provides 3% back on most purchases at BJ's, making it a strong choice for regular members. The card also offers 1.5% back on all other purchases, ensuring rewards for everyday spending. Plus, cardholders enjoy a discount on gas at BJ's stations, which can lead to significant savings over time.

Both cards come with no annual fee, making them accessible to a wide range of consumers. However, the Old Navy card has a high APR of 33.49%, which may be a concern if you carry a balance. In contrast, the BJ's One Mastercard does not list an APR range, indicating it may be more favorable for those looking to avoid high interest charges.

In summary, comparing these two cards allows you to weigh the rewards against potential costs. Consider where you shop most often and how you plan to use the card. This way, you can choose the credit card that best fits your lifestyle.

  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard:
  • - 5X points at Gap Inc. brands
  • - 3X points at eligible retail apparel brands
  • - 1X points on other purchases
  • - 30% off first purchase offer
  • - High APR of 33.49%
  • - Balance transfer fees apply
  • BJ's One Mastercard:
  • - 3% back on purchases at BJ's
  • - 1.5% back on all other purchases
  • - 10¢ off/gallon at BJ's Gas
  • - No annual fee
  • - No listed APR range

Cost

When considering the cost of credit cards, two options stand out: the Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the BJ's One Mastercard. Both cards have no annual fee, making them appealing for budget-conscious consumers.

The Old Navy Encore Mastercard does come with some fees. If you plan to transfer a balance, be aware that there is a fee of either $5 or 5% of the amount transferred, whichever is greater. This can add up if you're transferring a large balance. Additionally, the card has a high APR of 33.49%. This means that if you carry a balance, the interest charges can be significant.

On the other hand, the BJ's One Mastercard has no listed fees, which is a major advantage. There are no balance transfer fees or other hidden costs. This card also does not disclose an APR range, which could be a concern for potential cardholders. However, it is important to note that this card requires good to excellent credit for eligibility.

Both cards offer rewards, but the cost of carrying a balance may outweigh the benefits of rewards if you are not careful. With the Old Navy card, you earn points that can be redeemed for rewards, but the high APR can diminish the value of those rewards if you do not pay off your balance each month. The BJ's card offers cash back on purchases, which can be more straightforward and beneficial for those who shop frequently at BJ's.

  • Both cards have no annual fee.
  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard has balance transfer fees: $5 or 5% of the transfer amount.
  • High APR of 33.49% for the Old Navy card can lead to high interest charges.
  • BJ's One Mastercard has no listed fees.
  • BJ's card requires good to excellent credit for eligibility.
  • Old Navy card rewards can be diminished by high interest if balances are carried.
  • BJ's card offers straightforward cash back on purchases.

What you get

The Old Navy Encore Mastercard offers a range of features tailored for shoppers at Gap Inc. brands. It has no annual fee, making it budget-friendly. You can earn significant rewards with this card. For every $1 spent at Old Navy and other Gap Inc. brands, you earn 5X points. Shopping at eligible retail apparel brands gives you 3X points. For all other purchases, you earn 1X points. This card also provides a welcome offer of 30% off your first purchase at Old Navy, which can be a nice incentive for new users. Additionally, you get free shipping on online orders over $35, early access to sales, and partner perks. The card includes $0 fraud liability protection, ensuring you won't be held responsible for unauthorized purchases. However, be cautious of the high APR of 33.49% and balance transfer fees, which can be either $5 or 5% of the amount transferred, whichever is greater. You also have access to your complimentary FICO Score, helping you keep track of your credit health.

On the other hand, the BJ's One Mastercard is designed for frequent BJ's shoppers. It also has a $0 annual fee, making it accessible for many users. This card offers 3% back in rewards on most purchases made at BJ's and 1.5% back on all other purchases. Additionally, cardholders benefit from a discount of 10 cents off per gallon at BJ's Gas stations. This card does not have any balance transfer fees or other hidden costs, making it straightforward to use. Eligibility requires good to excellent credit, which may limit access for some potential applicants. Overall, both cards provide valuable rewards, but they cater to different shopping habits and preferences.

  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard:
  • - No annual fee
  • - Earn 5X points at Gap Inc. brands
  • - Earn 3X points at eligible retail apparel brands
  • - Earn 1X points on all other purchases
  • - Welcome offer: 30% off first purchase at Old Navy
  • - Free shipping on online orders over $35
  • - Early access to sales and partner perks
  • - $0 fraud liability protection
  • - High APR of 33.49%
  • - Balance transfer fees: $5 or 5% of the transfer amount
  • - Complimentary FICO Score access
  • BJ's One Mastercard:
  • - $0 annual fee
  • - 3% back in rewards at BJ's
  • - 1.5% back on all other purchases
  • - 10 cents off per gallon at BJ's Gas
  • - No balance transfer fees
  • - Simple rewards structure
  • - Eligibility: Good to excellent credit

Who each one fits

Choosing the right credit card depends on your shopping habits and preferences. The Old Navy Encore Mastercard is ideal for those who frequently shop at Gap Inc. brands. This includes Old Navy, Gap, Banana Republic, and Athleta. If you love fashion and often buy clothing, this card rewards you significantly. You earn 5X points for every dollar spent at these stores. Additionally, you get 3X points at other eligible retail apparel brands. For everyday purchases, you earn 1X point per dollar spent. This card also offers a welcome discount of 30% on your first purchase, making it attractive for new cardholders.

On the other hand, the BJ's One Mastercard is perfect for those who shop at BJ's Wholesale Club. If you regularly buy groceries or household items in bulk, this card provides 3% back on most purchases at BJ's. You also earn 1.5% back on all other purchases. If you drive, the card offers a discount of 10 cents per gallon at BJ's Gas, which can add up over time. This card has no annual fee and no balance transfer fees, making it a straightforward choice for budget-conscious consumers.

In summary, if you are a fashion enthusiast who shops at Gap Inc. brands, the Old Navy Encore Mastercard fits you well. If you prefer bulk shopping and want rewards on groceries and gas, go for the BJ's One Mastercard.

  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard:
  • - Best for frequent shoppers at Gap Inc. brands.
  • - Earn 5X points at Old Navy and other Gap brands.
  • - 3X points at eligible retail apparel brands.
  • - 1X point on all other purchases.
  • - Welcome offer: 30% off first purchase.
  • - No annual fee.
  • - High APR of 33.49% may deter some users.
  • BJ's One Mastercard:
  • - Best for bulk shoppers at BJ's Wholesale Club.
  • - Earn 3% back on purchases at BJ's.
  • - 1.5% back on all other purchases.
  • - 10 cents off per gallon at BJ's Gas.
  • - $0 annual fee and no balance transfer fees.
  • - Good to excellent credit required.

What you need to qualify

To qualify for the Old Navy Encore Mastercard, you typically need to have a good credit score. This means your credit history should show responsible borrowing. A score in the mid-600s or higher is often considered sufficient. The application process will require you to provide personal information, including your income and employment details. Barclays, the issuer, may also look at your credit utilization and payment history.

For the BJ's One Mastercard, the eligibility requirement is also focused on credit quality. Applicants should have good to excellent credit. This generally means a score of 700 or above. Like the Old Navy card, you will need to share personal information during the application. Capital One, the issuer, will assess your creditworthiness based on your credit report, income, and other financial indicators.

Both cards do not charge an annual fee, making them accessible options for consumers looking to avoid extra costs. However, the Old Navy card has a high APR of 33.49%, which can affect your decision if you plan to carry a balance. The BJ's card does not list an APR range, which may suggest more favorable borrowing terms. Always check your credit score before applying for either card to ensure you meet the necessary criteria.

  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard
  • Requires good credit, typically mid-600s or higher
  • Application needs personal info like income and employment
  • Issuer: Barclays evaluates credit history and utilization
  • BJ's One Mastercard
  • Eligibility is good to excellent credit, usually 700+
  • Personal information required during application
  • Issuer: Capital One checks credit report and income
  • Both cards have no annual fee
  • Old Navy card has a high APR of 33.49%
  • BJ's card may have more favorable borrowing terms

Fees and extra charges

When comparing fees and extra charges for the Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the BJ's One Mastercard, it's essential to look closely at what each card offers. Both cards have no annual fee, which is a significant advantage for consumers looking to minimize costs. However, they differ in other fee structures.

The Old Navy Encore Mastercard has specific fees to note. It charges a balance transfer fee, which is either $5 or 5% of the amount transferred, whichever is greater. This can add up quickly if you plan to transfer a large balance. Additionally, the card has a high APR of 33.49%, which can lead to substantial interest charges if you carry a balance. While there are no foreign transaction fees, the potential costs associated with balance transfers and high-interest rates are critical considerations.

On the other hand, the BJ's One Mastercard does not list any fees beyond the absence of an annual fee. This makes it a more straightforward option for consumers who want to avoid extra charges. It also offers rewards on purchases, including 3% back at BJ's and 1.5% on other purchases. Notably, it provides a discount on gas purchases at BJ's, which can lead to additional savings.

In summary, if you prefer a card with minimal fees, the BJ's One Mastercard is the better choice. However, if you frequently shop at Gap Inc. brands and can manage the high APR and balance transfer fees, the Old Navy Encore Mastercard may still be appealing.

  • Both cards have no annual fee.
  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard charges a balance transfer fee: $5 or 5% of the amount transferred.
  • High APR of 33.49% for Old Navy cardholders.
  • BJ's One Mastercard has no listed fees beyond the annual fee.
  • BJ's One Mastercard offers 3% back on purchases at BJ's.
  • 1.5% back on purchases everywhere else with BJ's One Mastercard.
  • BJ's One Mastercard provides a discount on gas purchases at BJ's.

How fast you get it

When applying for a credit card, the speed of approval and access to funds can be crucial. Both the Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the BJ's One Mastercard offer quick approval processes, but there are some differences worth noting.

The Old Navy Encore Mastercard is issued by Barclays. Typically, applicants can receive a decision within minutes. This quick turnaround allows you to start enjoying benefits almost immediately. Once approved, you can begin using your card right away for online purchases. However, physical cards may take a few days to arrive by mail.

On the other hand, the BJ's One Mastercard, issued by Capital One, also boasts a swift approval process. Similar to the Old Navy card, you can expect a decision in just a few minutes. Once approved, you can use your card for online purchases immediately. The physical card will also be mailed to you, which may take several days.

Both cards allow you to start earning rewards right after approval. This means you don't have to wait long to take advantage of their respective benefits. However, keep in mind that while you can shop online right away, you won't have access to the physical card for in-store purchases until it arrives.

In summary, both cards provide fast approval and immediate online use. The main difference lies in the specifics of how soon you receive the physical card. If instant access is a priority, both options are solid choices.

  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard: Quick approval, typically within minutes.
  • Immediate online use after approval.
  • Physical card may take several days to arrive.
  • BJ's One Mastercard: Also offers quick approval, usually within minutes.
  • Immediate online access after approval.
  • Physical card delivery may take a few days.

How to compare them

When comparing the Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the BJ's One Mastercard, start by looking at the costs. Both cards have no annual fee, which is a plus for budget-conscious consumers. However, the Old Navy card has balance transfer fees that can add up. This is an important consideration if you plan to transfer existing debt.

Next, examine the rewards structure. The Old Navy card offers a tiered rewards system. You earn 5X points at Gap Inc. brands and 3X points at eligible retail apparel stores. For all other purchases, you earn 1X points. In contrast, the BJ's One Mastercard provides a straightforward rewards system. You earn 3% back on most purchases at BJ's and 1.5% back everywhere else. If you frequently shop at BJ's, this card may offer better value.

Consider the APR as well. The Old Navy card has a high APR of 33.49%. This can be a significant drawback if you carry a balance. The BJ's One Mastercard does not list an APR range, which may indicate more favorable terms. However, it's crucial to check with the issuer for specifics.

Look at additional perks. The Old Navy card offers free shipping on orders over $35 and early access to sales. It also provides $0 fraud liability protection. The BJ's card has no additional perks listed, which may make it less appealing for some shoppers.

Finally, think about eligibility. The BJ's card requires good to excellent credit, while the Old Navy card does not specify eligibility criteria. This could impact your chances of approval.

  • Both cards have no annual fee.
  • Old Navy card has balance transfer fees.
  • Rewards: Old Navy - 5X at Gap brands, 3X at apparel stores, 1X elsewhere.
  • BJ's card offers 3% back at BJ's, 1.5% back elsewhere.
  • High APR of 33.49% for Old Navy card.
  • BJ's One Mastercard APR not specified.
  • Old Navy card perks: free shipping, early access, fraud protection.
  • BJ's card lacks additional perks.
  • BJ's card requires good to excellent credit.

What to watch for

When choosing a credit card, it's essential to look beyond the surface. Each card has its own limits and catches that can affect your overall cost. The Old Navy Encore Mastercard and BJ's One Mastercard both offer appealing features but come with specific considerations.

The Old Navy Encore Mastercard has a high APR of 33.49%. This rate can significantly increase your costs if you carry a balance. Additionally, balance transfer fees apply, which can be either $5 or 5% of the transfer amount, whichever is greater. This means if you need to transfer a balance, it could get expensive quickly.

On the rewards side, the Old Navy card offers 5X points at Gap Inc. brands and 3X points at eligible retail apparel brands. However, the value of these points can diminish if you don't shop frequently at these stores. Also, the card has a redemption threshold of 500 points for a $1 reward, which may take time to accumulate.

The BJ's One Mastercard, on the other hand, has no annual fee and offers 3% back on purchases at BJ's. This can be beneficial for regular shoppers at BJ's, but the rewards are limited to that store. Outside of BJ's, you earn only 1.5% back, which is less competitive compared to other cards.

Both cards have their perks, but it's crucial to consider how often you will use them. If you primarily shop at Old Navy or BJ's, the rewards may be worthwhile. However, if you need flexibility, look for cards with broader rewards and lower fees.

  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard has a high APR of 33.49%.
  • Balance transfer fees: $5 or 5% of the transfer amount.
  • Rewards: 5X points at Gap Inc. brands; 3X points at eligible retail apparel brands.
  • Redemption threshold: 500 points = $1 reward.
  • BJ's One Mastercard has no annual fee.
  • 3% back on purchases at BJ's; 1.5% back elsewhere.
  • Rewards limited to BJ's can reduce overall value for non-members.
  • Consider your shopping habits before choosing a card.

Which one to choose

Choosing between the Old Navy Encore Mastercard and the BJ's One Mastercard depends on your shopping habits. Each card offers unique benefits tailored to different consumers.

If you frequently shop at Gap Inc. brands, the Old Navy Encore Mastercard is a strong choice. It rewards you with 5X points for every dollar spent at stores like Old Navy and Gap. This can lead to significant savings if you shop there often.

The BJ's One Mastercard, on the other hand, is ideal for those who shop at BJ's Wholesale Club. You earn 3% back on most purchases at BJ's and 1.5% on all other Mastercard transactions. Plus, you get a discount on gas, which can add up quickly if you fill up regularly at BJ's.

Consider the Old Navy card if you want perks like free shipping on online orders over $35 and early access to sales. The complimentary FICO score access is another plus for those looking to monitor their credit health.

However, the Old Navy card has a high APR of 33.49%. This can be a drawback if you carry a balance. Additionally, balance transfer fees apply, which may not be appealing for those looking to transfer existing debt.

The BJ's One Mastercard has no annual fee and no balance transfer fees. This makes it a straightforward option for everyday spending without worrying about extra costs. It also requires good to excellent credit for eligibility.

In summary, if you are a frequent shopper at Gap Inc. brands, the Old Navy card is a great fit. For those who prefer shopping at BJ's and want a simple rewards structure, the BJ's One Mastercard is the better choice.

  • Old Navy Encore Mastercard: Best for Gap Inc. shoppers.
  • Earn 5X points at Old Navy and Gap.
  • Free shipping on orders over $35.
  • High APR of 33.49% can be a downside.
  • Balance transfer fees apply.
  • BJ's One Mastercard: Best for BJ's Wholesale Club shoppers.
  • Earn 3% back on BJ's purchases.
  • 1.5% back on all other purchases.
  • 10¢ off per gallon at BJ's Gas.
  • No annual fee and no balance transfer fees.
  • Requires good to excellent credit.

Rates and fees change. Check with the lender before you apply. This is general information, not financial advice.