Credit cards · Mortgages · Banking · Investing
Money tools
Compare › Credit cards › American Express Gold Card › American Express Gold Card vs Discover it Secured Cash Back

American Express Gold Card vs Discover it Secured Cash Back: Credit cards compared

American Express Gold Card and Discover it Secured Cash Back are two credit cards options. The sections below line up cost, what you get, fees, speed, and who each one fits.

American Express Gold CardDiscover it Secured Cash Back
Cost$325 annual feeNo annual fee
Fees$0 annual fee for additional cards (up to 5), $35 for each additional card beyond the fifthRefundable deposits as low as $49

Why compare them

When choosing a credit card, it's essential to consider your spending habits and financial goals. The American Express Gold Card and Discover it Secured Cash Back serve different needs. Comparing them helps you make an informed decision.

The American Express Gold Card is ideal for those who dine out frequently or shop at U.S. supermarkets. With 4X points on restaurants and supermarkets, you can quickly accumulate rewards. The card also offers additional perks like dining credits and Uber cash, which can enhance your overall value. However, it comes with a high annual fee of $325, which might not suit everyone.

On the other hand, the Discover it Secured Cash Back is a secured credit card with no annual fee. It's designed for individuals looking to build or rebuild their credit. While it has a more straightforward rewards structure, earning 5% cash back on rotating categories can be beneficial for everyday purchases. Plus, the unlimited dollar-for-dollar match on cash back after the first year is a significant advantage.

By comparing these two cards, you can weigh the benefits of high rewards against the need for low fees. If you value travel and dining rewards, the American Express Gold Card might be worth the cost. However, if you're focused on building credit without incurring fees, the Discover it Secured Cash Back is a strong contender. Understanding the pros and cons of each card allows you to align your choice with your financial goals.

  • American Express Gold Card: Great for rewards on dining and groceries.
  • High annual fee could be a drawback for some users.
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back: No annual fee, ideal for credit building.
  • Offers cash back on everyday purchases, plus a matching bonus.
  • Consider your spending habits before choosing a card.
  • Evaluate the importance of rewards versus fees.

Cost

When choosing a credit card, understanding the costs involved is crucial. The American Express Gold Card comes with a significant annual fee of $325. This fee is on the higher side compared to many other credit cards. However, it offers several perks that can justify the cost for frequent travelers and diners. Additional cards can be added for no fee, up to five. Beyond that, a charge of $35 applies for each extra card.

In contrast, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card has no annual fee. This makes it a more budget-friendly option, especially for those looking to build or rebuild their credit. One of the standout features of this card is the low refundable deposit requirement, starting as low as $49. This deposit acts as collateral and can be refunded if you close the account in good standing.

The American Express Gold Card offers extensive rewards that may offset its high cost. With 4X points on dining and U.S. supermarkets, the card can be advantageous for those who spend heavily in these categories. It also provides dining credits and cash back options that can further enhance its value.

On the other hand, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card focuses on cash back rewards. It offers 5% cash back on rotating categories each quarter, which can be appealing for everyday purchases. Additionally, the unlimited dollar-for-dollar match on cash back earned in the first year is a unique incentive that can help maximize rewards without an upfront cost.

  • American Express Gold Card: $325 annual fee
  • $0 fee for up to 5 additional cards; $35 for each extra card after that
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back: No annual fee
  • Refundable deposits starting at $49
  • Gold Card rewards may offset costs for frequent diners and travelers
  • 5% cash back on rotating categories with Discover it card
  • Unlimited cash back match in the first year with Discover it card

What you get

The American Express Gold Card offers a range of benefits tailored for frequent diners and travelers. It comes with a $325 annual fee. Additional cards can be added at no cost for up to five cards. Beyond that, there is a $35 fee for each extra card. Rewards are robust, with 4X points at restaurants worldwide and U.S. supermarkets. You also earn 5X points on prepaid hotels booked through AmexTravel.com. For flights, you get 3X points when booked through AmexTravel.com or directly with airlines. Prepaid car rentals booked through AmexTravel.com yield 2X points. The card also provides significant dining credits, including $120 in dining credits and $120 in Uber Cash annually. Other perks include a $100 Resy credit and an $84 Dunkin' credit. The card has no foreign transaction fees, making it a good choice for international travelers. Additional features include trip delay insurance, baggage insurance, and car rental loss and damage insurance. Cardholders also enjoy Hertz Five Star Status eligibility, purchase protection, and extended warranty coverage.

On the other hand, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card is designed for those looking to build or rebuild their credit. It has no annual fee, making it a cost-effective option. The card requires a refundable deposit, starting as low as $49. Rewards include 5% cash back on everyday purchases at different places each quarter, up to a quarterly maximum when activated. Additionally, you earn 1% cash back on all other purchases. A standout feature is the welcome offer, which includes an unlimited dollar-for-dollar match on all cash back earned at the end of the first year. This can significantly boost your rewards if used wisely.

  • American Express Gold Card:
  • - $325 annual fee
  • - $0 for up to 5 additional cards, $35 for each beyond that
  • - 4X points at restaurants and U.S. supermarkets
  • - 5X points on prepaid hotels booked through AmexTravel.com
  • - 3X points on flights booked through AmexTravel.com or directly with airlines
  • - 2X points on prepaid car rentals booked through AmexTravel.com
  • - $120 dining credit and $120 Uber Cash annually
  • - $100 Resy credit and $84 Dunkin' credit
  • - No foreign transaction fees
  • - Trip delay and baggage insurance
  • - Car rental loss and damage insurance
  • - Purchase protection and extended warranty
  • - Hertz Five Star Status eligibility
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back:
  • - No annual fee
  • - Refundable deposits starting at $49
  • - 5% cash back on everyday purchases at different places each quarter
  • - 1% cash back on all other purchases
  • - Unlimited dollar-for-dollar match on cash back earned in the first year

Who each one fits

Choosing the right credit card depends on your lifestyle and financial goals. The American Express Gold Card is ideal for frequent diners and travelers. It offers robust rewards on dining and supermarkets. If you often eat out or shop for groceries, you'll benefit from the 4X points in these categories. The card also provides dining credits and Uber cash, making it a great choice for those who enjoy dining experiences. However, the $325 annual fee can be a drawback for some. If you can maximize the rewards and credits, the fee may be worth it.

On the other hand, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card is designed for those looking to build or rebuild their credit. It has no annual fee, which is a significant advantage for budget-conscious users. The refundable deposit starts as low as $49, making it accessible for many. This card earns 5% cash back on rotating categories, which can lead to substantial rewards if you activate the offers. Additionally, the unlimited dollar-for-dollar match on cash back earned in the first year is a strong incentive for new cardholders. This card is perfect for anyone new to credit or those who want a straightforward way to earn rewards while improving their credit score.

  • American Express Gold Card:
  • - Best for frequent diners and travelers.
  • - 4X points at restaurants and U.S. supermarkets.
  • - Offers dining credits and Uber cash.
  • - High annual fee of $325 may deter some users.
  • - Ideal for maximizing rewards and credits.
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back:
  • - Best for building or rebuilding credit.
  • - No annual fee makes it budget-friendly.
  • - Refundable deposit starts at $49.
  • - Earn 5% cash back on rotating categories.
  • - Unlimited cash back match in the first year.

What you need to qualify

Qualifying for a credit card can vary significantly between products. Each card has its own requirements. Understanding these can help you choose the right card for your financial situation.

The American Express Gold Card is a premium credit card. It typically requires a good to excellent credit score. This means a score of at least 700 is often necessary. You may also need to provide proof of income. This helps demonstrate your ability to pay off the card. American Express may also look at your credit history. A longer history with responsible credit use can strengthen your application.

On the other hand, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card is designed for those looking to build or rebuild their credit. It requires a refundable security deposit. This deposit can start as low as $49. Your credit limit will usually match your deposit amount. This makes it more accessible for individuals with lower credit scores. There are no credit score requirements listed, making it a good option for those with limited credit history.

Both cards have different approaches to eligibility. The Gold Card is for those with established credit. The Secured Card is for those starting their credit journey. Consider your current credit situation before applying. Each card can serve different financial needs.

  • American Express Gold Card:
  • Requires good to excellent credit score (usually 700+).
  • Proof of income may be necessary.
  • Credit history is considered.
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back:
  • No specific credit score requirement.
  • Requires a refundable security deposit (as low as $49).
  • Credit limit matches the deposit amount.
  • Ideal for building or rebuilding credit.

Fees and extra charges

When comparing the American Express Gold Card and the Discover it Secured Cash Back, fees and extra charges are crucial. The American Express Gold Card has a significant annual fee of $325. This fee is standard for premium credit cards that offer extensive rewards and benefits. Additionally, there are no fees for up to five additional cards. However, if you want more than five, there is a charge of $35 for each extra card. This can add up quickly if you have a large family or want to share the card with friends.

On the other hand, the Discover it Secured Cash Back has no annual fee. This makes it an attractive option for those looking to build or rebuild their credit without incurring extra costs. Instead, it requires a refundable deposit, which can be as low as $49. This deposit acts as collateral for the secured credit card and can be a barrier for some, but it is a manageable cost for many. The lack of an annual fee is a significant advantage for budget-conscious consumers.

Both cards have their own unique costs associated with them. The American Express Gold Card offers numerous benefits, which justify its higher fee. In contrast, the Discover it Secured Cash Back is designed for those who may not have access to traditional credit cards and want to avoid ongoing fees. Choosing between these two options depends on your financial situation and how you plan to use the card.

  • American Express Gold Card: $325 annual fee.
  • $0 fee for up to 5 additional cards; $35 for each extra card beyond that.
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back: No annual fee.
  • Requires a refundable deposit starting at $49.
  • American Express offers extensive rewards and benefits for its fee.
  • Discover it is ideal for budget-conscious users wanting to build credit.

How fast you get it

When it comes to getting your credit card, speed matters. The American Express Gold Card offers a straightforward application process. Approval can be quick, often within minutes. However, the actual card delivery may take longer, typically around 7 to 10 business days. Once you have the card, you can start earning rewards immediately. This card is designed for those who want to maximize their dining and grocery rewards without delay.

On the other hand, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card is aimed at individuals looking to build or rebuild their credit. The approval process is also prompt, often taking just a few minutes. However, since this is a secured card, you will need to make a refundable deposit. This deposit can be as low as $49, but it must be paid upfront. Once approved, your card will usually arrive within 7 to 10 business days as well. Like the American Express Gold Card, you can start earning cash back as soon as you activate your card.

Both cards offer a quick approval experience. However, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card requires an initial deposit, which might delay your ability to start using the card. In contrast, the American Express Gold Card allows for immediate rewards but comes with a higher annual fee. The choice between the two cards will depend on your immediate financial needs and long-term goals.

  • American Express Gold Card: Approval often within minutes.
  • Card delivery typically takes 7 to 10 business days.
  • Start earning rewards immediately upon activation.
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back: Quick approval process.
  • Requires a refundable deposit, as low as $49.
  • Card usually arrives within 7 to 10 business days.
  • Start earning cash back right after activation.

How to compare them

When comparing the American Express Gold Card and the Discover it Secured Cash Back, consider several key factors. These factors will help you understand which card suits your needs better. Start with the annual fees. The American Express Gold Card has a $325 annual fee, while the Discover it Secured Cash Back has no annual fee. This difference is significant, especially if you are budget-conscious.

Next, think about rewards. The American Express Gold Card offers a robust rewards program. You earn 4X points at restaurants and U.S. supermarkets, 5X points on prepaid hotels, and 3X points on flights. In contrast, the Discover it Secured Cash Back provides 5% cash back on rotating categories each quarter and 1% on all other purchases. If you dine out or shop at supermarkets frequently, the Gold Card may yield more rewards for you.

Consider additional benefits as well. The American Express Gold Card offers dining credits, Uber Cash, and various insurances, including trip delay and baggage insurance. The Discover it Secured Cash Back focuses on cash back rewards and has a welcome offer that matches your cash back earned in the first year. This can be appealing for those looking to maximize their cash rewards.

Lastly, think about accessibility. The Discover it Secured Cash Back is a secured card, requiring a refundable deposit, which may be a good choice for those building or rebuilding credit. The American Express Gold Card is a premium option, likely suited for those with established credit.

In summary, weigh the annual fees, rewards structure, additional benefits, and your credit situation when comparing these two cards.

  • Annual fees: $325 for American Express Gold, $0 for Discover it Secured.
  • Rewards: Gold Card offers 4X points at restaurants and supermarkets; Discover offers 5% cash back on rotating categories.
  • Additional benefits: Gold Card includes dining credits and insurance; Discover focuses on cash back rewards.
  • Accessibility: Discover is a secured card for building credit; Gold Card is for those with established credit.

What to watch for

When considering a credit card, it’s crucial to understand the limits and catches that can impact your overall costs. Each card has unique features that may seem appealing but can have hidden implications. For the American Express Gold Card, the $325 annual fee is a significant cost. While it offers numerous rewards, the high fee can offset potential benefits if not used wisely. Additionally, if you plan to add more than five additional cards, the $35 fee per card can quickly add up. This is important to factor in if you want to share the card with family or friends.

On the other hand, the Discover it Secured Cash Back card has no annual fee, making it a more accessible option for those looking to build or rebuild credit. However, it requires a refundable deposit, which can start as low as $49. This deposit is a catch that could deter some users, especially if they are not prepared to lock away that amount. The rewards structure is appealing, offering 5% cash back on rotating categories. However, you must activate these categories each quarter to earn the higher rate, which can be a hassle and may lead to missed opportunities.

Another consideration is the cash back match offered by Discover. While it sounds enticing, it only applies at the end of your first year. If you don’t use the card frequently during that time, you might not maximize this benefit. Additionally, the American Express Gold Card provides various credits, like dining and Uber cash, but these credits come with specific conditions that must be met to realize their full value. Understanding these limits and catches is essential for making an informed decision.

  • American Express Gold Card has a high annual fee of $325.
  • Adding more than five additional cards incurs a fee of $35 each.
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back has no annual fee, making it budget-friendly.
  • Requires a refundable deposit starting at $49.
  • 5% cash back on rotating categories requires activation each quarter.
  • Cash back match only applies at the end of the first year.
  • American Express Gold Card offers various credits, but conditions apply.

Which one to choose

Choosing between the American Express Gold Card and the Discover it Secured Cash Back depends on your financial needs and spending habits. Each card serves a different purpose and audience.

The American Express Gold Card is ideal for frequent diners and travelers. It offers substantial rewards for dining and grocery shopping. With 4X points at restaurants and U.S. supermarkets, it’s a great choice for food lovers. Additionally, you earn 5X points on prepaid hotels booked through AmexTravel.com, making it appealing for those who travel often.

However, the Gold Card comes with a high annual fee of $325. This may not be worth it for casual users. The card also provides various credits, such as $120 for dining and $120 in Uber Cash. These perks can offset the annual fee if you utilize them fully.

On the other hand, the Discover it Secured Cash Back is perfect for those looking to build or rebuild their credit. It has no annual fee and requires a refundable deposit starting at $49. This makes it accessible for many. The card allows you to earn 5% cash back on rotating categories each quarter, which can add up if you shop strategically. Plus, the dollar-for-dollar match on cash back earned in the first year is a significant incentive.

In summary, if you dine out frequently and travel often, the American Express Gold Card may be worth the investment. If you’re focused on building credit without incurring fees, the Discover it Secured Cash Back is the better choice.

  • American Express Gold Card
  • Best for frequent diners and travelers.
  • 4X points on restaurants and U.S. supermarkets.
  • 5X points on prepaid hotels booked through AmexTravel.com.
  • High annual fee of $325.
  • Offers dining and Uber credits to offset costs.
  • Discover it Secured Cash Back
  • Best for building or rebuilding credit.
  • No annual fee.
  • Refundable deposits starting at $49.
  • Earn 5% cash back on rotating categories.
  • 1% cash back on all other purchases.
  • Dollar-for-dollar match on cash back earned in the first year.

Rates and fees change. Check with the lender before you apply. This is general information, not financial advice.