Credit cards · Mortgages · Banking · Investing
Money tools
Compare › Credit cards › American Express Gold Card › American Express Gold Card vs BJ's One+ Mastercard

American Express Gold Card vs BJ's One+ Mastercard: Credit cards compared

American Express Gold Card and BJ's One+ Mastercard are two credit cards options. The sections below line up cost, what you get, fees, speed, and who each one fits.

American Express Gold CardBJ's One+ Mastercard
Cost$325 annual fee$0 annual fee

Why compare them

Comparing the American Express Gold Card and the BJ's One+ Mastercard can help you choose the right credit card for your needs. Both cards offer unique benefits that cater to different spending habits. Understanding these differences is key to maximizing your rewards and minimizing costs.

The American Express Gold Card comes with a substantial annual fee of $325. However, it offers rich rewards, especially for dining and groceries. You earn 4X points at restaurants and U.S. supermarkets. This makes it an excellent choice for food lovers and frequent diners. Additionally, you can earn 5X points on prepaid hotels booked through AmexTravel.com. This card also provides various dining credits and cash back options, which can offset the high annual fee.

On the other hand, the BJ's One+ Mastercard has no annual fee. This makes it an attractive option for budget-conscious consumers. You earn 5% back on most purchases at BJ's, which is great if you shop there regularly. Plus, you get 2% back on purchases made anywhere else Mastercard is accepted. The added benefit of saving 15 cents per gallon at BJ's Gas can lead to significant savings over time.

When comparing these two cards, consider your spending patterns. If you dine out often and shop at supermarkets, the American Express Gold Card may provide more value despite its fee. Conversely, if you prefer a no-annual-fee card with straightforward rewards, the BJ's One+ Mastercard could be the better fit.

  • American Express Gold Card: $325 annual fee.
  • Earn 4X points at restaurants and U.S. supermarkets.
  • 5X points on prepaid hotels booked through AmexTravel.com.
  • Dining credits and Uber cash can offset the annual fee.
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard: No annual fee.
  • 5% back on most purchases at BJ's.
  • 2% back on purchases everywhere else Mastercard is accepted.
  • 15 cents off per gallon at BJ's Gas.

Cost

When considering credit cards, the cost is a crucial factor. The American Express Gold Card has a significant annual fee of $325. This fee can be a deterrent for some users. However, it offers a range of benefits that may justify the cost for frequent travelers and diners. Additional cards can be added at no cost for up to five cards. Beyond that, there is a $35 fee for each extra card. This flexibility can be appealing for families or groups who want to share benefits.

In contrast, the BJ's One+ Mastercard has no annual fee. This makes it an attractive option for budget-conscious consumers. With no cost to maintain the card, users can enjoy rewards without the burden of an annual fee. This card is particularly beneficial for those who shop at BJ's regularly, as it offers 5% back on purchases made at BJ's. Additionally, it provides 2% back on purchases made anywhere else Mastercard is accepted. The savings can add up quickly, especially for frequent shoppers.

The cost differences between these two cards reflect their target audiences. The American Express Gold Card is designed for those who value premium rewards and benefits, while the BJ's One+ Mastercard caters to everyday consumers looking for straightforward savings without an annual fee.

  • American Express Gold Card: $325 annual fee.
  • $0 annual fee for up to 5 additional cards.
  • $35 fee for each additional card beyond the fifth.
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard: $0 annual fee.
  • 5% back on most purchases at BJ's.
  • 2% back on purchases everywhere else Mastercard is accepted.
  • No hidden fees with BJ's One+ Mastercard.

What you get

The American Express Gold Card offers a range of valuable features for those who dine out or shop at supermarkets frequently. With an annual fee of $325, it may seem steep, but the benefits can outweigh the cost for the right user. Cardholders earn 4X points at restaurants worldwide and at U.S. supermarkets, making it ideal for food lovers. Additionally, you can earn 5X points on prepaid hotels booked through AmexTravel.com, and 3X points on flights booked through AmexTravel.com or directly with airlines. For car rentals, you earn 2X points on prepaid bookings through AmexTravel.com. This card also comes with a variety of credits, including a $120 dining credit and $120 in Uber Cash, which can help offset the annual fee. Other perks include eligibility for Hertz Five Star Status, trip delay insurance, and purchase protection.

On the other hand, the BJ's One+ Mastercard has no annual fee, making it a budget-friendly choice. This card rewards users with 5% back on most purchases made at BJ's, which can add up quickly for frequent shoppers. Additionally, it offers 2% back on purchases everywhere else Mastercard is accepted. Another appealing feature is the 15¢ off per gallon at BJ's Gas, which can lead to significant savings for those who fill up regularly. While it lacks the extensive perks of the American Express Gold Card, its straightforward rewards structure and lack of fees make it a solid choice for everyday spending.

  • American Express Gold Card:
  • - $325 annual fee
  • - 4X points at restaurants worldwide
  • - 4X points at U.S. supermarkets
  • - 5X points on prepaid hotels booked through AmexTravel.com
  • - 3X points on flights booked through AmexTravel.com or directly with airlines
  • - 2X points on prepaid car rentals booked through AmexTravel.com
  • - $120 dining credit
  • - $120 Uber Cash
  • - $100 Resy credit
  • - $84 Dunkin' credit
  • - No foreign transaction fees
  • - Trip delay insurance and purchase protection
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard:
  • - $0 annual fee
  • - 5% back in rewards at BJ's
  • - 2% back on purchases everywhere else Mastercard is accepted
  • - 15¢ off per gallon at BJ's Gas
  • - Good-Excellent credit required

Who each one fits

Choosing the right credit card depends on your spending habits and lifestyle. The American Express Gold Card is ideal for foodies and travelers. If you dine out often or shop at U.S. supermarkets, this card offers excellent rewards. You earn 4X points at restaurants and supermarkets. This makes it a strong choice for those who prioritize dining and grocery shopping. Additionally, the card provides valuable dining credits and cash for Uber, enhancing its appeal for frequent diners.

On the other hand, the BJ's One+ Mastercard suits budget-conscious shoppers. With no annual fee, it’s a great choice for those who want to save on card costs. If you frequently shop at BJ's, the 5% back in rewards on most purchases is a significant benefit. This card also offers 2% back on purchases made everywhere else. For those who fill up at BJ's Gas, the additional savings of 15¢ off per gallon adds to its value. This card is perfect for families or individuals who want to maximize rewards without the burden of an annual fee.

In summary, if you are a frequent diner or traveler willing to pay an annual fee for premium rewards, the American Express Gold Card is a great fit. If you prefer a no-fee card that provides solid rewards for everyday purchases, consider the BJ's One+ Mastercard.

  • American Express Gold Card: Best for foodies and travelers.
  • Earn 4X points at restaurants and supermarkets.
  • Offers dining credits and Uber cash.
  • Ideal for those who dine out frequently.
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard: Best for budget-conscious shoppers.
  • No annual fee makes it cost-effective.
  • 5% back on purchases at BJ's.
  • 2% back on purchases everywhere else.
  • 15¢ off per gallon at BJ's Gas.

What you need to qualify

Qualifying for a credit card often depends on your credit score and financial history. Each card has its own requirements. Understanding these can help you choose the right card for your needs.

For the American Express Gold Card, the issuer typically looks for applicants with good to excellent credit. This generally means a credit score of 700 or higher. Additionally, your income and debt-to-income ratio may be evaluated. You may need to provide documentation like pay stubs or tax returns to prove your financial stability. Having a solid credit history with timely payments can also enhance your chances of approval.

On the other hand, the BJ's One+ Mastercard also requires good to excellent credit for approval. Similar to the Gold Card, a score around 700 or higher is often needed. However, this card does not have an annual fee, which may make it more appealing for those who want to avoid high costs. You might not need to provide as much documentation as with the Gold Card, but demonstrating responsible credit use is still important.

Both cards have different benefits and costs, but qualifying for either one hinges on your creditworthiness. It's wise to check your credit score before applying to ensure you meet the criteria.

  • American Express Gold Card: Good to excellent credit typically needed.
  • Credit score around 700 or higher is often required.
  • Income and debt-to-income ratio may be evaluated.
  • Documentation like pay stubs may be necessary.
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard: Also requires good to excellent credit.
  • Similar credit score requirements as the Gold Card.
  • No annual fee may make it more accessible.
  • Responsible credit use is crucial for approval.

Fees and extra charges

When considering credit cards, understanding fees and extra charges is crucial. The American Express Gold Card comes with a $325 annual fee. This fee is on the higher side compared to many other credit cards. However, it offers significant rewards that may offset this cost for some users. Additional cards can be added at no cost for up to five cards. Beyond that, there is a fee of $35 for each extra card. This can be beneficial for families or groups who want to share a card account.

On the other hand, the BJ's One+ Mastercard has no annual fee. This makes it an attractive option for those looking to avoid upfront costs. There are no additional fees for extra cards, making it a straightforward choice for users who want to keep things simple. The BJ's Mastercard also provides rewards on purchases, offering 5% back at BJ's and 2% back everywhere else Mastercard is accepted. Additionally, cardholders benefit from a discount on gas at BJ's stations, which can lead to significant savings over time.

In summary, the American Express Gold Card has a high annual fee but offers various credits and rewards that can make it worthwhile for frequent diners and travelers. The BJ's One+ Mastercard, with its $0 annual fee, is ideal for budget-conscious consumers looking for everyday rewards without the burden of extra charges.

  • American Express Gold Card: $325 annual fee.
  • $0 annual fee for up to 5 additional cards; $35 for each beyond that.
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard: $0 annual fee.
  • No fees for additional cards on BJ's Mastercard.
  • American Express offers dining credits and travel benefits.
  • BJ's Mastercard provides rewards on everyday purchases.
  • Consider how fees align with your spending habits.

How fast you get it

When applying for a credit card, the speed of approval and funding can be crucial. With the American Express Gold Card, applicants typically receive a decision quickly. Most approvals happen within minutes. However, some cases may require additional documentation, which could delay the process. Once approved, the card is usually sent out promptly, allowing users to start enjoying their benefits without long waits.

In contrast, the BJ's One+ Mastercard also offers a swift approval process. Applicants can expect a decision in a similar time frame, generally within minutes. If approved, the card is mailed out, and users can activate it as soon as it arrives. This quick turnaround is beneficial for those who need access to credit immediately.

Both cards have straightforward application processes. Users can apply online, making it convenient. However, the American Express Gold Card requires good to excellent credit for approval. This may impact the speed of the process if additional checks are necessary. The BJ's One+ Mastercard also requires good to excellent credit, but its application is designed to be user-friendly.

In summary, both cards promise quick approval times. However, factors like credit history and documentation can influence individual experiences. Users should be prepared for potential delays if further information is needed.

  • American Express Gold Card: Quick approval, often within minutes.
  • May require additional documentation, which can delay the process.
  • Card is sent out promptly after approval.
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard: Also offers fast approval, typically in minutes.
  • Card activation happens upon arrival.
  • Both cards require good to excellent credit for approval.
  • Online applications make the process convenient.

How to compare them

When comparing the American Express Gold Card and the BJ's One+ Mastercard, several key factors come into play. Start with the annual fees. The American Express Gold Card has a significant annual fee of $325, while the BJ's One+ Mastercard has no annual fee. This difference can heavily influence your decision, especially if you want to avoid ongoing costs.

Next, look at the rewards structure. The American Express Gold Card offers a robust rewards program. You earn 4X points at restaurants and U.S. supermarkets, 5X points on prepaid hotels booked through AmexTravel.com, and 3X points on flights booked through AmexTravel.com or directly through airlines. In contrast, the BJ's One+ Mastercard provides 5% back in rewards on most purchases at BJ's and 2% back on purchases everywhere else. This makes the American Express Gold Card more appealing for those who dine out frequently or travel often.

Consider additional benefits. The American Express Gold Card comes with various perks, including dining credits, Uber cash, and travel insurance. These features add value, especially for frequent travelers. The BJ's One+ Mastercard, while lacking in premium benefits, offers straightforward cash back rewards and savings on gas purchases at BJ's.

Lastly, think about eligibility and credit requirements. The American Express Gold Card does not specify eligibility criteria, while the BJ's One+ Mastercard requires good to excellent credit. This could affect your ability to apply for either card.

In summary, weigh the annual fees, rewards programs, additional benefits, and credit requirements to determine which card best suits your financial needs.

  • American Express Gold Card: $325 annual fee
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard: $0 annual fee
  • Rewards: Amex Gold offers 4X points at restaurants and supermarkets, 5X on prepaid hotels
  • BJ's One+: 5% back at BJ's, 2% back elsewhere
  • Amex Gold includes dining credits and travel insurance
  • BJ's One+ offers savings on gas at BJ's
  • Amex Gold: No specified eligibility criteria
  • BJ's One+: Requires good to excellent credit

What to watch for

When choosing a credit card, it's crucial to look beyond the surface. Both the American Express Gold Card and the BJ's One+ Mastercard have unique features, but they come with different considerations that could affect your overall experience and costs.

The American Express Gold Card carries a hefty annual fee of $325. While it offers substantial rewards, especially for dining and groceries, the high fee can offset some of those benefits. Users should assess their spending habits. If you dine out frequently or shop at U.S. supermarkets, the rewards may justify the cost. However, if those categories don’t apply, the fee might not be worth it.

On the other hand, the BJ's One+ Mastercard has no annual fee, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious consumers. It offers 5% back on purchases at BJ's and 2% on all other purchases. This straightforward rewards structure is appealing, but it may not provide the same level of perks as the American Express Gold Card.

Another important factor is additional card fees. The American Express Gold Card allows for up to five additional cards at no cost. However, it charges $35 for each card beyond that limit. This could add up if you plan to share the card with family members.

In contrast, the BJ's One+ Mastercard does not have any additional card fees, making it a more flexible choice for families or groups. Additionally, consider the rewards redemption process. American Express may have more complex redemption options compared to BJ's straightforward cash back.

Lastly, both cards have unique perks. The American Express Gold Card includes dining credits and travel insurance, while the BJ's One+ Mastercard offers discounts on gas. Weigh these benefits against the costs to determine which card aligns best with your financial goals.

  • American Express Gold Card: $325 annual fee.
  • High rewards potential, especially for dining and groceries.
  • Up to 5 additional cards for free; $35 for each extra.
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard: $0 annual fee.
  • 5% back at BJ's; 2% back elsewhere.
  • No fees for additional cards.
  • Consider your spending habits before choosing.
  • Rewards redemption may vary between cards.
  • American Express offers travel perks; BJ's focuses on everyday savings.

Which one to choose

Choosing between the American Express Gold Card and the BJ's One+ Mastercard depends on your spending habits and lifestyle. Each card has distinct advantages that cater to different needs.

The American Express Gold Card is ideal for foodies and travelers. It offers impressive rewards: 4X points at restaurants and U.S. supermarkets, and 5X points on prepaid hotels booked through AmexTravel.com. If you dine out frequently or shop for groceries, this card can quickly accumulate points. Additionally, it provides valuable perks like a $120 dining credit and $120 in Uber Cash, which can offset the $325 annual fee. However, the high annual fee may deter some users.

On the other hand, the BJ's One+ Mastercard is a great choice for budget-conscious shoppers. With no annual fee, it provides 5% back in rewards on most purchases at BJ's and 2% back everywhere else Mastercard is accepted. This card is particularly beneficial for those who frequently shop at BJ's. The added benefit of saving 15 cents per gallon at BJ's Gas can lead to significant savings over time.

If you prioritize travel rewards and dining benefits, the American Express Gold Card stands out. But if you want a no-cost option with straightforward cash back rewards, the BJ's One+ Mastercard is the way to go.

  • American Express Gold Card: High annual fee but rich rewards.
  • 4X points on restaurants and supermarkets.
  • 5X points on prepaid hotels booked through AmexTravel.com.
  • $120 dining credit and $120 Uber Cash.
  • BJ's One+ Mastercard: No annual fee and straightforward rewards.
  • 5% back at BJ's and 2% everywhere else.
  • 15 cents off per gallon at BJ's Gas.
  • Best for frequent BJ's shoppers and budget-conscious users.

Rates and fees change. Check with the lender before you apply. This is general information, not financial advice.